Panic Station said:M24 scumlean - When he gave a take, he did so easily. When it came under scrutiny, he became self conscious about it.
Duskfall98 said:Do you think being afraid of looking scummy, is in fact scummy? Especially for a new player?
This is mostly what I wanted to get into with
OM since he's voting there (and now Panic too ig) but I'm glad it's coming up now. I think there are some decent arguments for M24 being scum, but I also think a good deal of care needs to be put into discerning new+messy from new+scummy. I dislike how readily OM slapped his vote there (citing wishy-washiness) without, imo, doing anything to make heads or tails of the slot--like I mentioned earlier, it felt like he was content to just vote the newbie without doing anything to make him legible. He starts digging in later posts, but not without some
nagging prompting--which irked me & still irks me. I'm loath to say M24 deserves no suspicion whatsoever (quite the contrary, he's done some weird shit this game), but I'm disappointed in how that's been handled, for the most part.
In M24's first game, their 8ball game (town), I think they did a *much* better job in terms of being forthright. First example that comes to mind is their earlygame push on hal, who pushed back pretty quickly, but M24 handled the pressure there p well imo--he eased back his read a bit, but I never got the sense he was apologizing for it or trying to cover his bases. Here, though, there's a fair bit of - like Panic said - self-consciousness coming through. OM called out the handwringing, which is neat!, but again, I think if that case is being made, there needs to be an attempt to distinguish it from, y'know, newbies being new.
Going back to the 8ball game, it also seems to me like M24 needed a lot less prodding to share their thoughts. They gave the hal read unprompted, commented pretty readily on things of actual substance (unexpected wagon movement, possible partnerships, etc.), and asked
way more questions. Most of anything meaningful that's come from M24 this game exists because they were directly asked to provide it.
There's also a lack of elaboration on their part that idt is *strictly* ai (again, looking at their first game), but looks worse in light of the other things. There's probably an excuse that could be made along the lines of thread activity/limited time to engage with certain things. Example that comes to mind is when I asked for thoughts on Tommy & Panic, the only two players this game that they'd had some prior experience with, and the response was basically "I don't remember. Tommy talked a lot. I'd have to check logs."
Spoiler
They never did
I don't think it's out of the ordinary for new players to be inconsistent, but it does strike me as odd that after a first game where they were specifically praised for exuding towniness, their play is so different.
I had/have other thoughts, but in the interest of spending less time organizing my thoughts into something resembling sense and spending more time keeping up with the thread I'm going to click "Post reply" and follow up as things move along.
I need to hear from OM before I do anything at all with my vote.
I think 460 is being too generous toward M24, though I agree that OM has fewer partners here than most.
Post reply.