• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC a nice basic game of actual mafia - game over - won by the Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Votecount
Thetwinmasters (1) - shubaka17
Former Hope (1) - Thetwinmasters

Not Voting (7) - Aubisio, Da Letter El, Former Hope, Josh, pancake, SomewhatOddish, Whydon
 
Thoughts on the claim, I think it's legit and it makes sense to my reads. That said, it'd interesting that it would seem that the mafia knew about this and might be worth looking into who was trying to get them lynched.

To answer your thing, how about explaining your scum read? Nobody has actually done that for me and with my tunneling on Whydon until today, not to mention my lynching leaves little scummy Ness about it, I'm confused. Also school gets out in an hour so more meaty posts then
 
Unless I'm misunderstanding a role cop, I'm 90% sure they knew of Shus role. Otherwise role blocking the woodsman the night after the arson died is way to great of a coincidence
 
hi !
just got home from school and have a driving lesson soon so no time to read page by page and get quotes BUT I've been following this thread from day 1 and have some thoughts. just wanna say i'm a tos player and this is my first forum mafia game so i'm not a noob persay but i don't know the terminology so bear with me

former hope is scummy as fuck, iirc (s)he idled initially and didnt really say anything of substance ever, as well as low activity overall. if i had to pick one person to be maf its them

pancake seems scummy too and id lean pretty strongly towards maf. shubaka is a tossup, i'm about 50/50. whydon is also somewhat scummy, id say 50/50 there too. you (twin) are the only person i am almost certain is town, everyone else is in the middle for me. i say almost because from tos experience nobody is ever out of suspicion unless their role is 100% confirmable, and with all the vanilla roles in this game its hard for me, im used to forcing scum to claim a hard town role for other(s) with that role to potentially call them out but here with all the vanilla roles and with the other roles not being 100% confirmable its a bit different
 
Honestly, should I be mafia, who in turn would possibly be my partners? Like I've stated previously, I scum read Aubisio and Haruno/Josh and they both scumread me. The only other 'scum read' person who I'm not at odds with would be Shubaka but they just claimed woodcutter and haven't been CC'd. With that said, I'm going to go with one of my reads and


Lynch Aubisio
Mostly for just the random bandwagons on lynches and for their refusal to clarify why they got on those bandwagons.
 
Top scum is aubisio; he hasn't done anything to change my mind on him since my d2 scumread.

Then former hope

Then whydon

Then josh/haruno

i think you're definitely town, oddish is definitely town, and pancakes is probably town

vote aubisio

fh voting aubisio is interesting though, but unsure what to make of it. Last time i voted for someone voting for aubisio they were just town
 
twin, didn't you scum read me for thinking the sub was scummy due to all the subs? and then use it as ammunition to lynch me? also you just named literally half the PL as part of your scum read. is this hitting anybody else?
 
this is my lynch list in order

Former Hope
pancake / Aubisio
Whydon
SomewhatOddish
Da Letter El
Thetwinmasters


shubaka17 is somewhere depending on if anyone ccs him or not. im also new here so i dont know playstyles but the fact that the two best players are both the most innocent might just be them outplaying us, just what comes to mind. its so hard playing higher elo players on tos and its the same shtick here.
 
Will make a read post later because I'm on my phone and also it's been really hard to type up stuff beside my laptop charger broke and it's dead so I'm forced to type and read the forums on my phone
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top