I do agree that a mafia goon looks pretty weak but we cannot ignore the possible existence of a godfather role doing something+showing up vanilla either, and going after Proph/Earlio/Jalmont just doesn't make sense when we still have a shady slot to figure out
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Animal Mafia ~Game Over~
- Thread starter Metal Sonic
- Start date
- Status
forgot to mention Epik in that pool
So, literally your entire reason for scumreading me is because my predecessor was a terrible, trolling poster?
I feel disappointed now.
Could you at least provide some reasoning based on my play? If you want to solve my slot, why not actually look at my posts and actions?
Alright, screw it, I don't think anyone is going to give a shit about anything I'm actually trying to say or ask.
Lynch Jalmont
My strongest scumread atm, feeling sus of Moody/Hauno/(Maybe Proph? Idk) outside of them. One of them is prob scum.
Lynch Jalmont
My strongest scumread atm, feeling sus of Moody/Hauno/(Maybe Proph? Idk) outside of them. One of them is prob scum.
Yo, explanation pls? Or is this just you being silly and random, even though this really isn't the time for this and we should be trying to find the last scum?
I think Leet might might might be town? Thinking.
Hoping to get to this game in an hour or so.
Hoping to get to this game in an hour or so.
The thing is I don't really think Jalmont is scum, because I can't really fathom a world where the mafia both have a message sender and a neighborizer.
That's just too much redundancy unless Metal Sonic specifically designed the setup to punish modgaming like that, which is.. a possibility? I don't know.
That's just too much redundancy unless Metal Sonic specifically designed the setup to punish modgaming like that, which is.. a possibility? I don't know.
OK I'm back, gonna spend like 30 minutes rereading thread.
Who else could possibly be mafia here?
Haruno - can't be mafia because he protected Texas the same night as texas was targeted by knights. obviously that doesn't make sense if they are both on the same team
Earlio - probably not mafia because of aubisio's role. what use is a commuter if town has barely any useful roles eg roles that target people? The only way this makes sense is if commuter was meant to be a fake claim role which is highly possible. i dont know otherwise his content has gone downhill but he did suggest thinking knights as deep scum/feeling like he was mafia day 2 which would seem odd to setup so early on in the game. definitely still in consideration though, but with all things considered (such as the mafia cop) it's hard to see earlio as mafia.
Hitmonleet - most likely to be mafia i think. the interaction with aubisio looks really awkward too in hindsight. says a lot of strange things that proph has already brought up, but his weird insistence on handwaving away people's thoughts eg in 1940 strikes me as no good. #1880 is also oddly confident from someone who self proclaims he doesn't like putting forward confident opinions.
Jalmont - town
3P1K - all behavior points to town - in general good reads and is giving a fuck. i cant remember everything but pretty confident he's town. can reread and explain better if necessary but i probably won't.
Former Hope - i just don't see why mafia redirector attempts to redirect his teammate who then immediately afks. that seems like a pretty nonsensical course of action from the mafia point of view.
MoodyCloud - checked by ap although theoretically could still be mafia. played well this game though. same boat as epik i can reread to explain better but his pushes don't feel informed in any way.
Prophylaxis - a lot of excuses but decent analysis. i see him at odds with leet a lot tbh. the things he says are a lot more balanced and reasonable compared to leet who comes off as pretty desperate. I think mafia has a lot to gain trying to push a mislynch on me and it's one of the only ways they win. I don't really see how proph intends to vote his way to the end assuming he's mafia without leaving me open as an option.
so it has to be leet i think.
Haruno - can't be mafia because he protected Texas the same night as texas was targeted by knights. obviously that doesn't make sense if they are both on the same team
Earlio - probably not mafia because of aubisio's role. what use is a commuter if town has barely any useful roles eg roles that target people? The only way this makes sense is if commuter was meant to be a fake claim role which is highly possible. i dont know otherwise his content has gone downhill but he did suggest thinking knights as deep scum/feeling like he was mafia day 2 which would seem odd to setup so early on in the game. definitely still in consideration though, but with all things considered (such as the mafia cop) it's hard to see earlio as mafia.
Hitmonleet - most likely to be mafia i think. the interaction with aubisio looks really awkward too in hindsight. says a lot of strange things that proph has already brought up, but his weird insistence on handwaving away people's thoughts eg in 1940 strikes me as no good. #1880 is also oddly confident from someone who self proclaims he doesn't like putting forward confident opinions.
Jalmont - town
3P1K - all behavior points to town - in general good reads and is giving a fuck. i cant remember everything but pretty confident he's town. can reread and explain better if necessary but i probably won't.
Former Hope - i just don't see why mafia redirector attempts to redirect his teammate who then immediately afks. that seems like a pretty nonsensical course of action from the mafia point of view.
MoodyCloud - checked by ap although theoretically could still be mafia. played well this game though. same boat as epik i can reread to explain better but his pushes don't feel informed in any way.
Prophylaxis - a lot of excuses but decent analysis. i see him at odds with leet a lot tbh. the things he says are a lot more balanced and reasonable compared to leet who comes off as pretty desperate. I think mafia has a lot to gain trying to push a mislynch on me and it's one of the only ways they win. I don't really see how proph intends to vote his way to the end assuming he's mafia without leaving me open as an option.
so it has to be leet i think.
Haruno - Doctor.
Haruno: Can you please fullclaim actions and number of shots? Who did you target on later nights? Are you a full doctor?
Earlio - Voyeur.
Earlio: Can you please fullclaim actions and number of shots? Who did you target on later nights? Are you a full voyeur?
Hitmonleet - Vanilla.
Jalmont - Message Sender
Jalmont: I know it's scattered throughout the thread, but can you claim full night actions? Who did you send a message to last night?
3P1K - Vanilla.
Former Hope - Two Shot Redirector. Xnadroj to Aubisio/Apricity, Jalmont to Earlio.
MoodyCloud - Tree Stump
Prophylaxis - Vanilla.
Haruno: Can you please fullclaim actions and number of shots? Who did you target on later nights? Are you a full doctor?
Earlio - Voyeur.
Earlio: Can you please fullclaim actions and number of shots? Who did you target on later nights? Are you a full voyeur?
Hitmonleet - Vanilla.
Jalmont - Message Sender
Jalmont: I know it's scattered throughout the thread, but can you claim full night actions? Who did you send a message to last night?
3P1K - Vanilla.
Former Hope - Two Shot Redirector. Xnadroj to Aubisio/Apricity, Jalmont to Earlio.
MoodyCloud - Tree Stump
Prophylaxis - Vanilla.
Want to get all claims sorted out and in order because that helps us not overlook things.
Is it confirmed that FH redirected Xnadroj to one of the A-names?Jalmont said:
Me/Moody/Haruno/Jalmont/Former Hope all town
Earlio/Hitmonleet/3P1K? I'm just ignoring 3P1K's solid behavior though
Earlio/Hitmonleet/3P1K? I'm just ignoring 3P1K's solid behavior though
Earlio proooob town for this?
Doesn't seem like scum tried to bus if at all in this game.
Knights not voting Durza in 226 when other townies are voting him.
this prob makes earlio town?
getting to the part where earlio derpcleared himself
feel more comfortable with him as town, especially with how knights tried and failed to take a swing at him
feel more comfortable with him as town, especially with how knights tried and failed to take a swing at him
FH can go back in PoE, Earlio moving up.
Earlio/Hitmonleet/FH prob ends game unless Jalmont is scum because Metal Sonic hates modgaming or 3P1K is having the game of his life.
Earlio/Hitmonleet/FH prob ends game unless Jalmont is scum because Metal Sonic hates modgaming or 3P1K is having the game of his life.
Likely Knights decided to go with the 2 town/1 scum pairing here in this post, which makes Epik/FH town.Knights said:
lolKnights said:
Knights + XnadrojX both voting EPIK nearly clears the slot for me
Unless they were hardcore bussing like last game, I'd be surprised if he was scum
Unless they were hardcore bussing like last game, I'd be surprised if he was scum
OK yeah, Hitmonleet is probably just the last scum and I'm just way overthinking it.
If he isn't scum we come back tomorrow and the game goes to Hard Mode but him being vanilla makes sense when the rolecop is a thing because it gives a false positive as opposed to all the scum being outed by it.
Vote Hitmonleet (L-2)
Hitmonleet if you're town please leave a legacy, you are literally first on the PoE and that is why you are being suspected. You're lynching Jalmont but you aren't explaining why Jalmont's actions are indicative of a mafia mindset
Haruno is doc, Moody is rolecop checked Tree Stump, I'm pretty obvious town
If he isn't scum we come back tomorrow and the game goes to Hard Mode but him being vanilla makes sense when the rolecop is a thing because it gives a false positive as opposed to all the scum being outed by it.
Vote Hitmonleet (L-2)
Hitmonleet if you're town please leave a legacy, you are literally first on the PoE and that is why you are being suspected. You're lynching Jalmont but you aren't explaining why Jalmont's actions are indicative of a mafia mindset
You're ignoring that Haruno claimed doc and he blocked the Texas NK when Knights tried to kill him.
This feels like you're trying to line up mislynches and figure out optimal path to victory here
Haruno is doc, Moody is rolecop checked Tree Stump, I'm pretty obvious town
just feels like hitmonleet is trying to EXPAND the poe instead of trying to shrink it
if he's town then.. game becomes substantially more difficult. but i think game ends with the leet lynch
if he's town then.. game becomes substantially more difficult. but i think game ends with the leet lynch
One last thing, don't understand why he's been so angry this game
If he's actually town here, then he replaced in and then three scum have been lynched in a row. Any town replacing into that situation would be FRICKIN HYPED.
But instead he's been complaining/ranting for most of the game about not being listened to, which.. is true in a way, but the reason why he's being lynched is because he is first rung up in the PoE and hasn't made significant strides to distinguish himself a part from that
i think the mindset dissonance is worth noting though.
---
Also sorry if any of my posts have gone over the line Hitmonleet, I'm not trying to ignore you, I just think that you're the last scum because PoE and behavior
If he's actually town here, then he replaced in and then three scum have been lynched in a row. Any town replacing into that situation would be FRICKIN HYPED.
But instead he's been complaining/ranting for most of the game about not being listened to, which.. is true in a way, but the reason why he's being lynched is because he is first rung up in the PoE and hasn't made significant strides to distinguish himself a part from that
i think the mindset dissonance is worth noting though.
---
Also sorry if any of my posts have gone over the line Hitmonleet, I'm not trying to ignore you, I just think that you're the last scum because PoE and behavior
Overthinking never hurt anyone proph bb; seconding guessing can though. On another note I see no way hitmonleet should be allowed to live to lylo; xand i dont see logic in scum offing him implying him to be town. So im perfectly fine with that lynch since before looking back he'd be first on my POE as well.
Still gonna try to find the willpower to do the busywork sometime during this day phase but if the lynch is set in stone for the most part and its currently 3am im gonna be lazy and push off figuring out the exact order my personal POE would fall in until tommorow. I'll still be lurking the thread until i zonk and happy to discuss if anyone wishes.
Still gonna try to find the willpower to do the busywork sometime during this day phase but if the lynch is set in stone for the most part and its currently 3am im gonna be lazy and push off figuring out the exact order my personal POE would fall in until tommorow. I'll still be lurking the thread until i zonk and happy to discuss if anyone wishes.
- Status