Sunday said:I don't see how you can hope to compress it all into one thread. If you want to make a Pokemon competitive, in any metagame, then just as much thought must be given to this Pokemon base stats / Movepool / Abilitys / etc as any other Pokemon we create. If we look at the "how do we create a Pokemon" guide, we need steps that would usually total two weeks, and that's if this was a main project.
But Movepool is limited to what Syclant gets, all we would need is to reorganize it, the Abilitys would simply be the same as Syclant has (unless people voice other opinions, if they do a 1 day bold text poll would fix it) Stats would not bee too hard as it would have to be a fast mixed sweeper like Syclant the exact stats would be voted on be a 1 day poll, really its not much work to finish off.
Sunday said:As a side project it would take even longer I suspect. Compressing that into one thread, as a side project, for not one but two pre-evos, with the aim of making these into UU Pokemon, for a tier that
2 pre-evos? no just Syclar, and it would not have to take long as most of the stages are picked by the evo already.
Sunday said:a) Doesn't have the numbers for proper, balanced decesions to be made in polls and
I disagree with this, even if it does not have the numbers of the main CaP project it will have enough.
Sunday said:b) Could radically shift at any time after we've created this Pokemon makes it rather hard to even know what options we should allow into a poll, let alone get the whole Pokemon completed.
But then it would simply fit into whatever tier replaces UU, and the options on the poll would be guided by discussions.
Sunday said:Having experienced UU players to guide the process seems a good idea in theory but, well, they need to be well respected by everyone and their opinions actually listened to or else we end up with another "aki" situation, where someone goes around backing up his opinion after every post someone makes. At the same time it can't become a 'war' with two or three 'big' people attempting to influence every decesion their way.
I am 100% sure that their opinions will be listened to if they explain them in a clear way, maybe a few people will disagree but that's how CaP works.
In the end its the people who explain it best who convince the majority to vote for their idea.
I think there should be a thread for discussing this really, SQ/SA is not really fitting. I will write one up sometime if that is ok.