• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Bard's College Mafia - Day Three

Status
Not open for further replies.
Aura Guardian said:
My read on you is that I can't tell if you're scum but very good at hiding, or if you're a very proactive villager.
Click to expand...
Then why are you not asking me questions in order to figure out my alignment?

I'm trying to be proactive because I'm frankly surprised that we've only hit, I dunno, 300 posts for Day 1, and the game I replaced into and we lost (The Thing) the activity was abysmal.

Last game I played had like, I dunno, 3000 posts in a 72 hour Day 1? And we ended up winning, so I think activity is very important.
 
KnightsofCydonia said:
I firmly believe Proph is Town because how the hell does scum fake that level of hard work. Seriously, Prophylaxis , if I get boozled here, tell me how after the game so I can improve my playstyle.
Click to expand...

Honestly I'm a little paranoid that you're scum and are trying to buddy up hard with me but if you and I are still alive we can sort that out another Day.

Still townreading you because I don't think you ever think to get mad at me about scumhunting methods if you're scum.
 
Jalmont said:
Prophylaxis can u answer why u are against a mxmts lynch but are voting granny pie as i asked u last night
Click to expand...
I'm not against a mxmts lynch. I'm fine with lynching him, but I think GP's bandwagoning is more scummier. I thought GP was more active when I was reading last night but now I see that they're around the same activity level.

The problem with both is that it's really easy to justify lynching either of them as they aren't really playing super well.
 
Oh that's helpful

Tell me about bluedoom, as I've never played with him - what makes you think he could be a deep wolf as opposed to just a good town player ATM? Why would potentially team members change your opinion of him?
 
Mainly due to his pushing of Champ in worlds where Champ is town, since him pushing Champ then backing off on him when thread momentum shifted against Champ is kind of noteworthy. And if Champ is scum then.. bluedoom is likely town, though that makes me look at the backing off in a little different light.

Honestly it's mostly just gut; I expect the scum team to have players capable of playing well to fool me Day 1 because no one can be 100% accurate, especially early game.
 
Granny Pie(4): Champ1604, Prophylaxis, KnightsOfCydonia, MeowMIXXX
Champ1604(2): mxmts, Aura Guardian
Hitmonleet(1): Haruno
Haruno(1): Hitmonleet
BLOODYRAIN1001(1): MeowMIXXX
jalmont(1): Texas Cloverleaf
mxmts(1): jalmont
Aura Guardian(1): XnadrojX
Haruno(1): Earlio
XnadrojX(1): bluedoom
Prophylaxis(1): Granny Pie

Not voting: BLOODYRAIN1001, Former Hope, ItsViper482, MoodyCloud, shubaka17, tonithetourguide

ItzViper482
shubaka17

deadline is in 3 hours 33 minutes
 
Well we could always lynch champ but tbh I'd need to see more posting from him to rly make a judgement. He was scum last game and when pressured he kinda unraveled - could be something to look for D2

bluedoom hi hey hello

Can you expand on the above a little bit more? Especially in regards to your rationale behind pulling off of champ
 
I probably get one more chance to check in before deadline. Prophylaxis I'm reasonably sure you're town and if you're not this gets me more important info than anything else so if it's necessary my vote goes to sheeping yours for the day
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top