BH BH7 Suspect #2: Water Bubble - Voter Identification & Discussion

[sodass]

Option 3
Alt: Sodass1 (E4 Flint gave me the permission to use this alt.)
GXE: 79.1%
# of Games: 49
COIL: 2708.1

 

[Winstoon]

Option 1
Alt: Winstoon
Elo: 1436
GXE: 76.5
Games: 101
COIL: 2837.5
Proof: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=solve 101 = 11/log2(40*76.5/x)

View attachment 78142
Gen 7 Bh okey?

Hope this works

Edit: In Case that didn't work
Option 3
Alt Schemingpanda

My Proof

Voting WB Ban

 

[Oberon Kagé]

Option 1:
Alt: Oberon Kage
My Coil: 40*75.6*2^(-11/(51+29)) = 2749.097
http://m.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=+40*75.6*2^(-11/(51+29))&x=0&y=0

 

[Transcendent God Champion]

Option 3

Alt: WBUltimateChampion
Elo: 1475
GXE: 81.3%
Games: 41
COIL: 2700

 

[draegn]

Option3

Alt: wb draegn
Elo: 1485
Gxe: 82.2
Games: 39
Coil: 2704

 

[shivarus]

Option 3
Alt: WB shivarus
ELO: 1446
GXE: 75.3
Games: 70
COIL: 2701

Proof:
http://imgur.com/a/v8kgc

I'm gonna go for the ban. I used it w/ aqua jet on a M-Gyar with belly drum for a while. Unstoppable monster. Only removed it because it didn't fit my team comp too well.

 

[Eien]

Turns out Assist Pdon teams still work and let randoms like me get reqs twice LOL

55 games with 77.7 GXE, 2706 COIL and 1415 ELO.

proof HIGH RES

 

[Dot Agumon]

Option 3 (this is what I get for having different usernames)
Alt: wb shed team
ELO: 1431
GXE: 72.5%
Games: 107
COIL: 2701

Hide

 

[Ren]

Option 3
Alt: wb trash account
ELO: 1510
GXE: 82.6%
Games: 38
COIL: 2703

proof

roses are red
ladder had me pissed
FOR FUCK'S SAKE PLEASE BAN IO APS AND ASSIST

e: roses are red
litwick wants me to change the poem because apparently i dont know what syllables are
he's bad at life

 

[Fervis]

Option 1
Alt: Fervis (Blaziken)
ELO: 1578
GXE: 80.3
Games: 462
Effective COIL: 3159.4

Proof:

 

[MamoJustWins]

The picture is obviously my reqs, and I also have a vid from my channel proving it and that the account is mine and yadda yadda (It includes a discussion on the suspect and some calcs for my side along with a couple games, and this is my shameless plug) and it can be found here:

I'm almost definitely voting ban on this one, y'all.

 

[Sweet Jesus]

Option 3
Alt: Lee-Q
ELO: 1468
GXE: 81.9%
Games: 40
COIL: 2707

Pic

 

[Ren]

Option 1
Alt: Fervis (Blaziken)
ELO: 1578
GXE: 80.3
Games: 462
Effective COIL: 3159.4

Proof:

[OPTION 1] if you have an alt on PS! that matches your Smogon username perfectly and was registered before today, February 12, with rank in the original BH Ladder (i.e. the rank should NOT say "[Gen 7] Balanced Hackmons Suspect Test") that corresponds to the COIL value, you may substitute that alt instead of a new suspect one and vote

I don't know if Flint approved your alt or not but I thought I'd put it here because if he didn't and you end up being unable to vote because of it, that'd be unfortunate.

Option 3
Alt: Lee-Q
ELO: 1468
GXE: 81.9%
Games: 40
COIL: 2707

Pic

[OPTION 3] If you cannot do either of the above, for this suspect you must ladder to achieve reqs

FAQ:
Can I ladder on my main for Option3?
No. I would prefer that if you do ladder, you do it with an alt with the right naming convention with "WB" as stated in the OP. If you use a different one, it won't be counted.

Same case here. Again, just letting you know - I don't know what Flint will say but if you don't get counted, it'd be unfortunate so just in case you want to vote and want to guarantee that you get counted, here it is.

 

[fsk]

Option 3
Alt:WB Noidea
GXE: 83.8%
# of Games: 37
COIL: 2727

proof of ownership

http://imgur.com/a/ycT30

Apparently, I am too lazy to build a solid team and ends up taking around 5-min yesterday to make a trash team just to get reqs quickly.
Somehow it seems that I am one of the few that actually uses WB as a wincon: Shift Gear Groud Z Physical P-orge to lure in all kinds of Assault Vest Special Wall / Pdon and makes way for Spec WB P-orge. But based on my experience SashSmash & IO are just everywhere and creating more aids.
And I still have no idea on how this meta is gonna be for PS, as my alt indicates :v
Banning WB is not gonna bring a clean meta, but getting rid of it is one necessary step I guess.

 

[Sweet Jesus]

Same case here. Again, just letting you know - I don't know what Flint will say but if you don't get counted, it'd be unfortunate so just in case you want to vote and want to guarantee that you get counted, here it is.

Dang, don't want to be a whiny bitch, but that wasn't even in the OP, you had to continue reading 2 posts later. I don't play that regularly anymore, I'm just an old player (in smogon standards) that used to play a lot and still has the twist. Back in my days you could ladder with what the hell you wanted, so I didn't think that would've changed. Anyway, you don't seem to be responsible of this so I'll let E4 Flint decide, but it just seems a little ridiculous to take away my vote when I can clearly prove I fullfilled the necessary requirements.

 

[Quantum Tesseract]

Dang, don't want to be a whiny bitch, but that wasn't even in the OP, you had to continue reading 2 posts later. I don't play that regularly anymore, I'm just an old player (in smogon standards) that used to play a lot and still has the twist. Back in my days you could ladder with what the hell you wanted, so I didn't think that would've changed. Anyway, you don't seem to be responsible of this so I'll let E4 Flint decide, but it just seems a little ridiculous to take away my vote when I can clearly prove I fullfilled the necessary requirements.

You failed if that was your goal, especially since it is in the OP:
"Do so by making a new alt with "WB" anywhere in the name of the alt but they must be as one unit."

 

[Rumors]

Ah crap, I misread those examples and had started laddering an account called "Water Bubble.exe" Well, guess I gotta start over.

 

[Balanced Freakmons]

Option 3
Alt: Balanced WBmons
GXE: 79.7%
Number of Games: 46
COIL: 2701

Vote: Ban

 

[morogrim]

Option 1, using main acc (morogrim)
GXE: 87.3%
Games played: a bit over 225 at the time (prolly 226 or 227)
COIL (calculated): 3375.6 (used 225 games)
Not sure if I need to post a proof that that's my account but w/e..

proofs

 

[jrm115]

Option3

I'm pretty sure this is about all I need
I'll vote keep, probably.

 

[lepton]

Option 3

Alt: pileoWB
https://ibb.co/g60MmF
(I don't know how to insert the picture on mobile)

 

[RNGIsFatal]

Option 3

followed by Option 1

Alt: CancerRNG>WB
GXE: 85.7%
# of Games played: 32
Coil: 2701

Water Bubble? Why does that matter?
RNG has better wallbreaking power with hax crits, and has better potency to burn than Steam Eruption with Scald with 90% burn chance. It also ruins Russian Roulette speed tie by favoring the side it has been, and kills over 10,000 PS! users per year with rage stroke induced from RNG.

But suspect is a suspect. Let's get this WB out of the way.
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

I know this meta is very chaotic, but play with optimism, perseverance, and patience! Then you should reach your goal!

Good luck everyone!

 

[GLIIISSCCOOORRR9]

ghig WB
I vote to not Ban water bubble
Water Bubble is definitly good no doubt. But so is imposter chansey. So is contray users. And so are any pokemon with prnsker who can with destiny bond kill any pokemon. Should we ban those no. I did try Water Bubble on all different pokemon (Mega-Scizor,Mega-Gyrados,Greninja,Katana, and of course Primal Kyorge) on anouther account and i found that despite the huge base power moves they are not as effective as you would think they are as A: water is just not a very offensive types to begin with and B: the fact that the pokemon who use them (except for Greninja) are very slow for BH. And if you give greninja Water bubble it is at the mercy of priorty users who use his low bulk against him. The immunity to burn helps gyrados out but it is weak to fighting with out unware and will be used to help aid contrary users via superpower. Kyorge is the best one out of all of them for his insane power and decent bulk. you could slap a choice scarf, leftover, or water-Z on him to make him get some easy kills, but even he (like greninja) has a weakness to physical prority. Or physical attacks in general that are strong.

While Water Bubble is a good surprise move that can give any pokemon great killing power, so can prankster, contrary and innards out. But we should not Ban those. HERE IS PROFF http://pokemonshowdown.com/users/ghigwb

 

[E4 Flint]

The period to get reqs has ended. I have composed the list of eligible voters below. If you are here, you should've been tagged

click to view

Quantum Tesseract
Laxpras
Piccolo Daimao
Funbot28
motherlove
InfernapeTropius11
The Guy Who Has Many Alts
highlighter
SuperSkylake
GmU pokeboss9
RNGIsCancer
Ztest
ElMustacho
MAMP (vote taken in advance)
Zephyr Dragon Lord
aki0s
tysequaine
Silver_Lucario42
Illusio
sodass
Winstoon
Oberon Kagé
Transcendent God Champion
draegn
shivarus
Eien
Dot Agumon
VoltDarkrai
MamoJustWins
fsk
Balanced Freakmons
morogrim
jrm115
pileosand
GLIIISSCCOOORRR9

E4 Flint

The following are those who did not meet reqs due to not following the rules, but may contact me on smogon/PS asking for an official exemption and screenshots of proof (you can just use your old ones). You should've done this beforehand like others who have done so instead of making me run after you.

Click to view

Sweet Jesus
Fervis- APPROVED

If you do not see yourself and believe it's an error from me let me know. Note that if you did not provide proof of ownership of your alt, you won't be counted, which I made pretty clear in this thread a few times.

Voting Specifics:

• Procedure:
  1. Go here, and click on "Post new thread" on the right hand side
  2. Title your thread "BH7 Suspect 2 WB" or anything similar
  3. In the body of your post, put your vote. You may vote BAN or DO NOT BAN
  4. Hit "Create thread"
  5. Your thread will be created. Do not be alarmed if you only see your own, as that is the intended behavior
• The voting begins now and will end on March 5.
• A decision will be made when there is a majority of 60%. We have 36 voters (possible 38), so that should be 22 (23 with 38) votes either way.

Thanks for participating.

 

[Deleted User 91486]

I want to vote for a ban, but I can't take a screenshot proving that I meet the requirements (2900 COIL on the suspect ladder, same nick as here), since the ladder was reverted back to the "normal", non-suspect ladder, What now?

Edit: used the command /ranking to get my ranking table in the chat. I hope this is okay: