Here's my tier list
Hm ok, this is what I thought might be the case. It's not a huge issue because you're new to mafia, but I would urge you to try to distinguish thread prescence from towniness. Your soft town are basically the 6 people who have posted the most (not sure this applies to Psy but he's had a very strong presence regardless of post number).View attachment 399393
Here's my tier list
okThis is good and useful but I'd be interested in a wider range / compilation of reads
which feels like too broad of a possibility for town eli to support or back in any form considering the rest of his reads have been more specific to individuals and less pointing fingers but w/e this is mostly outweighed by his other postsis it bad i could unironically see this being a thing in some world
OK this makes sense and is towny. I read the highlighted Nuxl (Nuxl is eli? I'll use that from now on lol) as a joke but if you're taking it to be AI I agree it leans scummy.ok
nuxl - unless openwolfing and using misc fillerposts to up his contribution i'm p sure he's just town, one exception to the townread being:
which feels like too broad of a possibility for town eli to support or back in any form considering the rest of his reads have been more specific to individuals and less pointing fingers but w/e this is mostly outweighed by his other posts
zero clue how hal plays forum mafia and might go review older games on here to understand, but would imagine if he dials back on his town leading pr claim stance at all in the next couple of nights, scum is possible, as of now softlean town hal and don't see the suspense claim of "knowing a scum 100%" as something he'd lean into so hard as scum. more of a baiting tactic to gauge reactions if anything
could be experienced based/knowing what to say on this topic but seems town just due to directing attention to the likely possibility one of the highest 5-6 contributors by post count has good odds of having a scum + reinforcing this idea to newer playerHm ok, this is what I thought might be the case. It's not a huge issue because you're new to mafia, but I would urge you to try to distinguish thread prescence from towniness. Your soft town are basically the 6 people who have posted the most
read it as like a disguised joke? throttling whydon's reads that he doesn't totally disagree with but also isn't placing full support behind itOK this makes sense and is towny. I read the highlighted Nuxl (Nuxl is eli? I'll use that from now on lol) as a joke but if you're taking it to be AI I agree it leans scummy.
Basically yeah, since Whydon is mostly trolling and that list of scum is entirely baseless I read Eli's response as being more like "it's funny that this is actually somewhat feasible and rational"read it as like a disguised joke? throttling whydon's reads that he doesn't totally disagree with but also isn't placing full support behind it
I haven't played scum in literally a year and a half so uh yeah I dunno. I think I'd probably play better than I used to but thats speculation on my part based on feeling like my emotions are a little less involved right now as town.Got it. Ty. I’m pretty sure throughout this game I agree w your pushes randomly most out of anybody now so that’s a good sign just:
M2H Final question: be honest with me do you flake out your posting as scum with what u think ur current skill atm. Pls link a game supporting this answer
idk you tell me little homieM2H who is scum this game
Great take. Are you voting himLooking through the more inactive players I feel DaLetterEl is kinda sus bc they've been online and posted a decent amount but they haven't been acting town-like, if that makes sense? Like they haven't been giving reads and trying to find scum, which doesn't seem like what a town player would do
I kinda feel the same about realiti but to a lesser extent
Also would be based if you voted Texas tbhM2H who is scum this game
Not yet, probably laterGreat take. Are you voting him
currently trepidatious about CaffeineBoost Spiderz (mr “i want to see content not from newbies”) for potentially trying to overcompensate as town fodder, soft scumAlso dave ngl I would love a readslist from you
I'm sorry QWEJFQOWEJFOQWEFQJO I've literally been working on it for 15 minutes. Honestly don't feel like my reads brought too much to the table, but wanted to get my thoughts out there with what I had.of course i posted that while dyo drops a massive in-depth list of reads