The fuck? I bring up Wild Charge and you shoot me down, then Pocket agrees with me and you change your mind completely.
In any case, Venusaur is without a doubt bulkier then Victreebel, and thus should be utilized as such. I personally don't even like Sleep Powder on Venusaur, as I find it compounds coverage issues on a mon that reall needs the Growth to sweep.
sorry lol, the inner workings of my mind are an enigma. but seriously, i still think skarm beats it unless you can get rocks and +2, which as i stated previously is unlikely. sawsbuck could potentially be a big threat, but in most scenarios it's not.
@Lavos Spawn
So as you said Victreebel is a better cleaner and revenge killer than Venusaur against Offensive teams, but against Stall and Balanced teams, that have a solid defensive core that you have to break through (which is difficult to do unboosted), as you more often than not have to set-up in order to sweep, Venusaur seems better, as after a Growth it outclasses Victreebel.
Also Victreebel is a shaky check to Dnite as +1 ES does 69.2 - 81.45%, a potential ohko after SR + Spikes or if Victreebel has taken any previous damage. And Venusaur can ohko Mence more often than not anyway, as after SR, a Modest LO Sludge Bomb has a 62.5% chance to ohko Naught / Naive Mence after SR. So Victreebel is only slightly better when it comes to revenge killing, and downright inferior when it comes to sweeping balanced / stall teams.
And while yeah, Dugtrio can trap and kill most fire types there are 3 problems with this:
1. Not all teams use Dugtrio
2. Dugtrio many times won't be able to trap both the weather inducer and the Fire type
3. Stone Edge-less Dugtrio cannot deal with Volcarona
stall teams lose to victreebel because it can set up to +6 one-on-one vs the pink blobs and each giga drain will restore enough hp to take it out of seismic toss ko range easily. venusaur can say the same, so there's no difference here.
i strongly disagree with your interpretation of revenge-killing dragonite, as 1) it could be locked into outrage in which case it's a free kill, while venusaur can't kill with sludge bomb and then gets ohko'd by the +1 outrage, or 2) it might not have a boost at all. the point is, if dragonite switches in on venusaur, you get out. if dragonite switches in on victreebel, you laugh and kill it.
also, once again, you're making assumptions about the salamence scenario. rocks are not guaranteed to be up. and even if they are, are you willing to risk the life of your venusaur on a 62.5% chance? i'd rather stick with the 100% chance that victreebel hp ice will ohko.
finally, on your counterpoints to dugtrio,
1) anyone who doesn't use dugtrio with victreebel is not worth our time
2) many times there isn't even a fire-type, and if there is, it's a priority over the weather inducer in most cases, though a sun team generally has some means of dealing with fire types other than dugtrio lol
3) what self-respecting dugtrio does not carry stone edge?