As promised, here are my thoughts on some of the other entries:
CyzirVisheen said:Manticore
I think that this concept as you've drawn it is absolutely a perfect mix of fearsome and adorable. I know that you decided later on to go in a different direction, but I really hope that you'll consider expanding on this idea, because I really like it a lot better than your other one.
Quanyails said:Snake Oil
I wasn't really into this at first, but it's growing on me. I'd love to see it further developed by more supporting artwork. I'll definitely say that I
love the bit where it looks like a Hoop Snake, presumably for Flame Wheel.
Mos-Quitoxe said:Lava Lamp Cone Snail
I already told you on #cap, but when I first saw this idea with all of its supporting artwork, I almost threw up because it was so awesome. Like, my body was not prepared to experience or deal with something so amazing. I don't know what else to say to this other than that I don't agree with any of the criticisms that anybody's had against it (beyond adding the cap, which I think was a good move).
aragornbird said:Nuclear Camel
This is without question my favorite of your designs, because I think that it's the most unique and imaginative. I especially liked later on when you patterned its ears and nose to look like the radiation hazard symbol.
Yilx said:Sun God
The artistic quality here is outstanding, no question about it. But, I'm not really getting the concept. I see the two types in isolation, but I'm not seeing how they synthesize. Let me try an example analogy here:
If we're looking for a Water/Rock design, I don't want Carracosta as much as I want Corsola. Carracosta is just a rocky aquatic Pokemon, the types aren't well synthesized. Corsola, on the other hand, is a coral Pokemon, a concept that can only exist as a synthesis of those two types without needing to emphasize either any further.
What I'm seeing from the Sun God design is a design is like what I see from Carracosta, where I can easily distinguish and separate the two types, and I don't want to be able to do that. I want more Corsola. Does that makes sense? There are a lot of designs that I see that this same criticism applies to, and I hope that they read this too. I'm just picking on you because I think that the artistic quality of yours is the best of them, possibly one of the best in the thread in general.
Phazon-764 said:Teapot
This is actually super cute. The only problem, though, is that I didn't realize it was a teapot until I read it in your description because of the color changes between the body and the neck. If you can find a way to make it look more like a teapot, I think that would be great; maybe remove the tail, make the legs smaller or more discreet, and work on the coloring separation between the main body and the rest.
EDIT: Oh, you posted a new one as I was writing this. The new one actually looks even less like a teapot, I'm afraid.
SubwayJ said:Test Tube Frog
Um... So, about that test tube tail... I can't think of any other way to say this, so I'm just going to say it. That doesn't look like a tail. It just looks like it has a test tube stuck into its butt. >.<
paintseagull said:Frilled Basilisk Newt
Sorry, I didn't know what else to call it, because I think that it integrates all three of the different inspiration elements very well. It's definitely simple in its design, but I also think that it's very cute. I look forward to supporting artwork maybe?