Houndoomsday I think TIK is referring to lynching the mafia, not inspecting them.
THE_IRON_KENYAN At 6 men left, we'd no-lynch to still get down to the 2/5 chance the next day. 4 villagers/2 mafia is mylo, not lylo. This is why I said we're deciding whether to no-lynch now or later. I do however, agree with you that we should do it now. If we mislynch a vanilla/miller, then no-lynch the next day, we give the mafia a 2/5 then 2/4 shot of hitting a power role, 1/5 and 1/4 of hitting the cop. If we no-lynch today, they only have a 2/6 or 1/6 shot tonight.
unvote, vote no-lynch
zorbees said pretty much everything i want to say on this, but ill add even more reasons why we should no lynch today and not use the misslynch today.
You could make the cop have to out himself, in which case we will never have any chance of getting the best thing this village could get: a mafia report on one of the players. He will just get hooked over and over again. You want to at least give the cop a chance to possibly get that best case scenario mafia report. Lynching TODAY would certainly make cops job easier if we misslynched correctly (got a villager) or got godfather or hooker ( If we get hooker today and cop gets scum tomorrow, its a village clear because the godfather pops up town while the only thing left to pop up scum is the miller, which is town,) but it just wouldnt be worth the risk of making the cop claim and then making him useless for as long as the roleblocker is in the game.
We have a 2/8 chance to lynch the mafia today, off of nothing but this conversation and whatever conversations happen later in the day.
Tomorrow, we have a 2/7 chance of hitting mafia, off of the conversations of the day before( this day), the conversations of that day, the possible cop report of mafia on somebody, and the person that died.
This seems like a pretty easy choice to me, so im gonna go ahead and reaffirm that I
vote no lynch
I know I pretty much said the same things i said in my previous posts with a little bit more information, but based on the posts after mine I feel the need to say these things again