NOC D6 Mafia Game Thread [Day 4; Deadline June 1 at 6 PM EST]

[Clarinet]

previously, I thought Caffe's wagon is of huge purity, I no longer think that

a scum might have to sacrifice and buss in that situation, can't see Hannah doing it, but Xnadroj

 

[Clarinet]

someone stated how Hannahh couldn't possibly NK apricity so I also take that into consideration

 

[Clarinet]

you deserve a gold metal, whoever gets the scum in whydon/vooper

I'm loving Whydon atm but it's not final

 

[Clarinet]

that bugs me and I wanna point this again, why did Caffe care so much about Zest's absence, Caffeine had a post where he explicitly encouraged Zest to give thoughts, why didn't he do that for Whydon? I feel like both Whydon/Zest/ are not that talkative, yet Caffeine was interested in making Zest speak

 

[Clarinet]

also like to add ZestOfLife to the list of people worth looking into. From the games I've played with Whydon, seeing him drop into the thread, say "hi", then just leave is really not surprising nor meaningful. Zest however I expected more from. So ZestOfLife mind sharing your thoughts on the proceedings thus far with us?

 

[vooper]

that bugs me and I wanna point this again, why did Caffe care so much about Zest's absence, Caffeine had a post where he explicitly encouraged Zest to give thoughts, why didn't he do that for Whydon? I feel like both Whydon/Zest/ are not that talkative, yet Caffeine was interested in making Zest speak

w/o going into partner stuff in the post u quoted right after caff literally explains why not whydon?

 

[Athena_57]

that bugs me and I wanna point this again, why did Caffe care so much about Zest's absence, Caffeine had a post where he explicitly encouraged Zest to give thoughts, why didn't he do that for Whydon? I feel like both Whydon/Zest/ are not that talkative, yet Caffeine was interested in making Zest speak

I don't really think we can read much into this bc it's both very easy shade on a townie / an easily retractible bus so I can see caf doing this regardless of voopers alignment

 

[Clarinet]

You can say he slightly defended Whydon and shaded Zest, but it's hard to tell what was his plan

 

[Athena_57]

Also what vooper said ya

 

[Clarinet]

what's to do? vote vooper or whydon, then sort from there?

would Xnadroj buss like a maniac, both his partners? if Whydon is scum, I'm clearing Jordan, if Whydon is town, Jordan is insta-scum for me

 

[Athena_57]

Okay I'm trying to build like a lynch flowchart I'm sort of okay with, where I'm currently at:

 

[Athena_57]

Assumptions: Dusk/Hannah town
Jordan/Clarinet never w/w

Lynch whydon+vooper
not t/t by assumption
s/s => we win
whydon scum, voop town ==> whydon's mewtwo vote looks bad on clarinet + we trust vooper on jordan ==> lynch clarinet
whydon town, voop scum ==> trust whydon on clarinet, lynch jordan

teams we catch: why/voop, why/cla, voop/jor
teams we dont catch: dusk/x, hannah/x, jor/cla, why/jor, voop/cla

 

[Athena_57]

Most iffy part here is the jordan lynch if whydon flips town

 

[Athena_57]

I feel like I never budge on these assumptions and I also feel comfortable about a clarinet lynch after a voop townflip

 

[Athena_57]

So I suppose either my flowchart above or just the simple poe of whydon/vooper/clarinet are my preferred plans as of now

 

[Clarinet]

so you suggest Whydon today?

I already have my team Jordan/vooper if Whydon is town

if Whydon is scum, then we got both vooper and Jordan cleared!

I think we get a lot with with either a Whydon or a vooper lynch

 

[Athena_57]

so you suggest Whydon today?

I already have my team Jordan/vooper if Whydon is town

if Whydon is scum, then we got both vooper and Jordan cleared!

I think we get a lot with with either a Whydon or a vooper lynch

how is vooper clear if whydon is scum

 

[Clarinet]

do you think both whydon/vooper are last 2 scum? both absentees and not talkative?

 

[Athena_57]

do you think both whydon/vooper are last 2 scum? both absentees and not talkative?

It's not my best guess for a team but I also don't think it's impossible

 

[Clarinet]

both of them have a similar style to me, Whydon becomes more flashy when he needs to defend himself, but they've been one-sentence players

 

[Athena_57]

If you think there's only 1 scum in them and also think whydon/jordan are never a team (which you posted above) which scumeams are you considering rn? Just jordan/voop or one with hannah?

 

[Athena_57]

Also can you answer my question in post #1183

 

[Clarinet]

yes, I think Jordan can be sly, but not buss his partners to a real detriment. I want more certainty on Jordan and this depends on Whydon's flip

At this point, I'm leaning towards voop/Jordan because of what people stated about Hannahh, however I see the importance of Whydon in this equation

If I were to be honest and listen to my inner voice, Hannahh is still in my poe, I'm abstaining because I trust others who have more experienced with her and if vooper/Jordan is scum, Hannah is cleared because both seemed to have given her the town alignment with great reassurance.

 

[Clarinet]

What is the point of this comment? As in, what are you implying?

trying to figure if vooper is saying Hannah is town because of TMI,

 

[Clarinet]

unless you have practical experience with Hannahh, there's no way she's out of POE. I think vooper knows more than all of us and Jordan also gave Hannah a townlean way too early, that's why I think Hannah is not with either vooper or Jordan

if Whydon is scum, I'm preparing the noose for Hannah