Lady Alex said:The argument for the anti-SR side is not that SR is broken because it is on every team, but that it is on every team because it is broken. Two very very different sentiments. The rest of your post has already been talked about in previous posts.
You still have to give a reason as to why it is broken though. And if you say that the rest of my post has already been adressed then i guess that there really isn't any real reason as to why SR should be banned.
Wizarus said:Are there really plenty of ways to deal with SR? Compared to the wide, wide distribution of the move, there are a grand total of 4 viable Rapid Spin users in OU; 2 of them losing to Jellicent, and the other 2 needing rain support to beat it. There are only 2 Magic users, both have horrendous defensive stats requiring heavy prediction to stop SR from getting up. Offensive pressure may stop spikes, but it's not stopping SR from getting up. Just look at suicide leads like Custap Skarmory, which dies happily knowing it managed to lay at least SR down, and Deo-D, which was banned in part because it almost guaranteed SR was put on the field. Building a team that doesn't care about SR in OU limits your options against threats in this metagame that already limits your options.
I don't see how you can ignore the huge impact SR has had in OU. There are only 3 Fire, Ice and Bug type pokemon weak to SR in OU. 1 of them has Uber stats, and the other 2 have access to the best boosting moves in the game. This has nothing to do with fairness; certain types will always be superior to other types in this game, but SR takes this fact and magnifies it to the point where pokemon weak to it that would normally be viable in OU aren't anymore.
When did i ever ignore the huge impact that SR has had in OU? Just because i don't want it banned means that i don't think it is a centralizing force in OU?
As for ways to deal with SR, you already mentioned some of them but there are more. You say that 2 of the spinners that beat Jellicent need rain up, which isn't true. LO Starmie can beat Jellicent even outside of rain with the correct move (Psyshock 2HKOes SpD Jellicent and Thunderbolt 2HKOes PhD Jellicent). Furthermore, you didn't mention the teams that are not particularly affected by SR, such as teams that have no Pokemon weak to it and don't make a lot of switches, such as HO teams. So while the ways to deal with SR are not as much as we would want, the same way that the ways to deal with Terrakion are not as much as we would want, SR is absolutely manageable.
youngjake93 said:The last two paragraphs address the notion that the "SR is broken" group hasn't talked about why SR is broken. I also made the comparison that you have to run rocks yourself to win in a SR metagame, just like people felt they needed to run Excadrill to win in an Excadrill meta. There is one "reliable" stealth rock counter in OU that can fit on a variety of teams, starmie. But for starmie to do its job, it has to switch in safely, possibly beat a ghost type, not get pursuit trapped, and then waste another turn spinning. And somehow do all of this without losing momentum. Good opportunities to spin are extremely rare. Yes you can spin whenever if there is no blocker, but usually the cost of wasting that turn(two counting the swtch in) is far too high.
Combine the fact that SR is reeeally good to the fact that it is hard to counter and SR fits the idea of broken. Consequently, every team uses it because you must use an equally broken strategy to compete on a level playing field if viable counters to the strategy aren't cost-effective. The argument is not that it is broken because everyone uses it. The argument is not based solely on the type-centralization effect. It's mainly based on the fact that SR actually is broken. And if this is the case, suspecting a move shouldn't be seen as taboo.
The comparison with Excadrill is invalid because of one big difference: there are many ways to deal with SR, as has been mentioned plenty of times in this thread. While SR may be a necessity to most teams, it is not imposibble to deal with, or not even really hard, as long as you prepare for it, as you do with most big threats in OU.