Upside said:The Bible only gives evidence of what people around the era of it's writing and compilation believed. It's not evidence of God's existence or nature. The Bible's value in terms of evidence is circular: We believe the Bible because it is the word of God, and we know it's the word of God because the Bible says it is. This is logically invalid; you are assuming your conclusion and using it to justify itself.
It was my understanding that Brain and I were discussing the Christian God, in which case, the Bible is a shining example of what God is like. In fact, the Bible says (Perhaps metaphorically), that God is the Bible. It's in John 1. It's rather lengthy. Primarily the first verse, although it mentions it later. Also, I realize my reasoning is circular, and a touched on it in a sentence.
Circular reasoning is a logical fallacy and doesn't actually support an argument. You can use the Bible being true as an assumption, and then derive properties from that in a logical fashion (e.g. "The Bible says X, and from the observation Y we observe, we can deduce the conclusion Z.), but you can't say "We know what the Bible says God is like is true because we assume the Bible was written by God and therefore he told the truth."
Also, justification for taking the assumption that the Bible is true is worthy of debate too. If, as Brain has done earlier in the thread and elsewhere, someone points out an inconsistency with the Bible and observations of reality, you can't fall back on "The Bible is true as an assumption", you have to give a reason why the Bible is actually consistent with observation.
Again, citing Bible proves nothing about the reality of the situation. You can't say the Bible accurately described something that can't be independantly verified, but that's not really the problem here. You're also misunderstanding the words 'flaw' and 'mistake'. They are not the same thing. A mistake is an action that has unintended and unwanted consequences. Even if God cannot make mistakes, that means he can't do something that has an outcome he did not intend or anticipate. He could intentionally create flaws in his creation. He could intentionally do something and blind himself to the outcome, leaving it to be observed and not foreseen (indeed, for free will to exist, this sort of process has to be the case). Then it is a question of guessing at his motives for doing so.
He could. He definitely could. He is, after all, omnipotent. It's a debate as to whether he would. From what I can understand from the Bible (If you're still going to address the "circular reasoning" argument, I'll go from what God has shown me through experience; however, you have no way of verifying that, so I doubt you'd want that as an argument.), God had specifically mapped-out everything about us and everything that would happen to us before we even came to be (I'll find the verse later, not exactly sure where this one is). Because of this, I don't believe that God would intentionally "blind himself" to the outcome of anything. Not a very strong argument, but that's the best I can do. Free will has its own topic, and I'll put a post in there if you request.
The problem is if you take as read that God would not intentionally prevent himself from foreseeing the outcome of something, you run into inconsistencies. First, there can be no free will. You seem to have accepted this, and this is valid; you can logically believe there is no free will. However, it also means that parts of the Bible are incorrect; God could not have tested Adam and Eve with the tree of knowledge, because he would have known the outcome of the test before he set it, which means that he would have not created the trees in the first place, or would have created Adam and Eve differently, and that way he would not have been unhappy with the result.
All of your arguments are illogical, because they're structured around the fallacy of appeal to incredulity. "I believe X, .: I believe it." Faith
without reason is valid, but
faith in the face of reason is not;
If you believe that 1+1=3, it is not simply a matter of personal opinion, you are factually wrong.
In your case, you are basically justifying every aspect of your worldview with "I believe it to be true, so it is." This is a problem because there are contradictions within your source material itself, let alone between observation and the source material; for this reason, Bible Literalism is not practiced by any of the mainstream Christian churches, and instead heuretics are debated.
The reason that religious parties are often (but not always) the 'bad' parties in these sorts of debates is because they will accept no alternative to their personal worldview regardless of the illogic of their beliefs or the evidence presented against them; they are not willing to critically examine their own worldview when presented with contrary evidence, and science is. Indeed, that is one of the fundamental components of the scientific method.
And the next post...
ORLY? This is probably way off topic but Jesus' fallibility is somewhat subjective. If I'm right, according to the Bible Jesus once got angry with a tree for not bearing fruit when he came along. Not quite a mistake but by your logic we can also see that God clearly hates unripened plants as well. Actually, God is rather angry in general with people in the Old Testament.
That is definitely in the Bible; however, Jesus doesn't simply curse the plant because it doesn't give him fruit. Plenty of times in the Bible, Jesus describes people who follow him as "bearing fruit" (I'll get a verse upon request), and says that those who do not bear fruit will be cut away and thrown out. I believe that Jesus is using the fig tree as an example, as the many people following him would have undoubtedly recognized the connection between the two and gotten the message. Also, you have to understand that the Old Testament is vastly different from the New Testament. In the Old Testament, there was no permanent redemption. You could temporarily redeem yourself by offering a sacrifice, but once you sinned again, you weren't clean. God still loved us; however, we weren't perfect in his eyes, and he was indignant (Righteous anger) with most of Israel.
An inconsistency; you said above that God made us perfect (indeed, he made us in his own image, and his own image was perfect and his ability to create was perfect), and yet we weren't perfect in his eyes?
More relevant, you're assuming that anything with a divine purpose cannot be a flaw. However, if you follow your argument that a God can be perfect, then he could easily create something that He deems a flaw for whatever reason or lack of reason. Essentially it amounts to what I was saying before about the naturalistic line of thinking and Brain so brilliantly reminded me was called Occam's Razor (I'd forgotten it even had a name, thanks!).
If this is the case, then I was wrong to use the word flaw in my initial argument. Perhaps, as we mentioned, mistake would have been a better word. Either way, I'm failing to see how a flaw, if intended, would actually be a flaw. I think I'm thinking of a flaw and a mistake as too closely related.
Definitions (Taken from dictionary.com)
Mistake: an error in action, calculation, opinion, or judgment caused by poor reasoning, carelessness, insufficient knowledge, etc.
Flaw: a feature that mars the perfection of something; defect; fault
I was going to look up "Perfection", but most of the definitions that are relevant to this debate use the word "Perfect", so I look that up instead.
Perfect: conforming absolutely to the description or definition of an ideal type
By these definitions, and what I've argued so far, it doesn't seem to me that God could make either of those; however, this again comes down to the fact that how I defined perfect was rather vague. I hope I cleared that up, if I didn't, feel free to bring it up. I'll do my best to help you out.
It's a matter of semantics here, I think. Most people define flaw and mistake different to each other, as I posted above. A mistake is something nonintentional, whereas God could choose to make something less than perfect (i.e. flawed). Indeed, he must have done so, since Adam and Eve failed the test of the Garden of Eden; humans are not perfect. This leaves only the options that God intentionally made humans imperfect, or he is not capable of doing otherwise.
As I was typing, I recalled something that I found fascinating, and I figured you guys might want to take a look at it. It's called Bible Numerics and was originally discovered by Ivan Panin. I googled a short article on it, and some of the numbers aren't really the result of math, but the math part of it is absolutely amazing. I'm sure there's a better article somewhere or potentially a book, and if someone could find those, I'd be very grateful.
Article
Bible Numerics is a sham, and is considered so by most mainstream religious groups. It defines a pattern in such a way to generate a desired outcome. It predicts outcomes after the fact (i.e. after you get outcome X, you show how it predicted outcome X), rather than prior, so it can't be tested.
EDIT: Here's a question for you. Why do you choose the sources you follow? You pick obscure and unsupported sources as truth, and do not follow those that have monstrous amounts of evidence to back them up? I'm not really looking for an answer here, it's more of a philosophical reflection I think you should do; why do you believe what you do and why don't you believe what you don't? How do you choose what sources to follow and which to reject?