GSC UU Cup signups are now up. If anyone's thinking about joining but doesn't have any teams, there are
sample teams here. However, I'd encourage everyone to try building their own teams!
Sage doesn't seem to be around so I will take the liberty of updating the OP myself if there aren't many disagreements with the below:
:gs/nidoqueen: Leave in S and at #1 for now. If its usage continues to stay around 60% or lower, maybe we can consider bringing it to the level of the other top tier Pokemon.
:gs/scyther::gs/slowbro: I think these should also stay as they are for now. While Scyther had slightly higher usage, Slowbro had the higher win rate, a trend it has maintained in all stats to date. Slowbro is ridiculously strong for something so tanky, and the Electric-types that threaten it the most are losing viability.
:gs/qwilfish: Qwilfish is a very convincing #2 in the usage stats and has remained that way. I think it should be near the top of A, if not #5. Nominating it to move up to #6 below Hypno for now.
:gs/ampharos: Agreeing that it's too high. I suggest its new position be right above Kabutops.
:gs/dodrio: While it is very strong, it is facing issues due to Omastar's massive increase in popularity. I am tentatively suggesting it drops to the bottom of A.
:gs/bellossom: It pains me to move this above Jumpluff (which I firmly believe is better) but following the stats and nominations I'll move this to A, above Slowking.
:gs/omastar: Omastar has been performing for a while now, having ridiculously good stats in the GSC UU tournament and emerging as a mainstay in this year's UUPL. I suggest its new position be the top of A-.
:gs/electabuzz: I'm fine with dropping him to just above Kabutops, below Ampharos's new position on the back of his 28.5% win rate in UUPL. Thinking of making it the top of B+.
:gs/magneton: I want to be cautious with Mag due to its poor past performances, so I think below Haunter but above the other Electrics is the right spot for it for now.
:gs/sandslash: This did terribly, only winning one of the five games it was used in. Drop to below Kadabra.
:gs/blastoise: Blastoise clearly had quite an extraordinary rise to popularity in UUPL. I am thinking this should move up to above Haunter in A-, which will put it below Omastar and Jumpluff.
:gs/politoed: Another big underperformer. It seems like a lot of people see its potential as a mini-Vap, and it indeed does well against a decent portion of the metagame, but the ubiquity of Qwilfish and its mediocre defensive utility is really ruining it. Suggesting this moves to top of B.
:gs/pinsir: Had a reasonably strong showing at 60% WR, recommending just above Kadabra in B+.
:gs/chansey: Chansey performed quite well this UUPL, with a departure from the usual Curse sets to more varied sets like Counter, Ice Beam, and Present. Given its strong results I suggest moving it up to just below Gyarados.
:gs/piloswine: So I don't really get why this thing is doing so well considering all the Blastoise, Slowbro, and Slowking, but I suppose a rise to the top of B+ looks appropriate based on the stats. A 66% win rate is pretty good and it was also used 12 times. A big improvement on its previous mediocre performances.
:gs/flareon: I'm happy to move this into C+, although hesitant to move it higher when it was only used once and is shut down so hard by so many common Pokemon. It definitely suffers from the same issues as Politoed, and has even worse defensive utility and a lot more bad matchups. Should be very hit or miss, and more often miss.
:gs/victreebel::gs/quagsire::gs/girafarig::gs/electrode: Victreebel did well this UUPL, whereas Girafarig and Electrode did very poorly. Victreebel to move above Lanturn in B, and Girafarig and Electrode to fall to B-, below Pikachu. As for Quagsire, I am thinking of redefining the cutoff for B such that it appears right below Politoed in it instead of in B+.
:gs/crobat::gs/graveler::gs/magmar::gs/shuckle:Crobat only won one out of the four games it was used. Magmar went 0-1 and the metagame changes do not favour it at all. Graveler and Shuckle both won the games they appeared in. Crobat down to C+, above Magmar, and Graveler and Shuckle to remain top of C+.
:gs/arcanine::gs/poliwhirl:As for Arcanine and Poliwhirl, I am not too convinced on these since neither were used in UUPL. I also think that Arcanine has more utility defensively than you are giving it credit for, considering it has pretty good defensive stats all around and takes hits from Electric-types and Psychic-types neutrally. Poliwhirl I am going to put above the two that dropped down further into C+ (Crobat and Magmar) for now.
I'll also redefine the cutoff of C+ / C at Flareon / Wigglytuff and C / C- at Pineco / Sudowoodo.
If all of the above changes were implemented, this is what the changelist would look like:
Hide
01. Nidoqueen = (1 -> 1, S -> S)
02. Slowbro = (2 -> 2, A+ -> A+)
03. Scyther = (3 -> 3, A+ -> A+)
04. Granbull = (4 -> 4, A+ -> A+)
05. Hypno = (5 -> 5, A -> A)
06. Qwilfish +4 (10 -> 6, A -> A)
07. Mr. Mime = (7 -> 7, A -> A)
08. Bellossom +6 (14 -> 8, A- -> A)
09. Slowking = (9 -> 9, A -> A)
10. Dodrio -2 (8 -> 10, A -> A)
11. Omastar +9 (20 -> 11, B+ -> A-)
12. Jumpluff = (12 -> 12, A- -> A-)
13. Blastoise +12 (25 -> 13, B -> A-)
14. Haunter -1 (13 -> 14, A- -> A-)
15. Magneton +1 (16 -> 15, A- -> A-)
16. Ampharos -10 (6 -> 16, A -> A-)
17. Electabuzz -6 (11 -> 17, A -> A-)
18. Kabutops -3 (15 -> 18, A- -> A-)
19. Piloswine +7 (26 -> 19, B -> B+)
20. Gyarados -2 (18 -> 20, B+ -> B+)
21. Chansey +2 (23 -> 21, B+ -> B+)
22. Pinsir = (22 -> 22, B+ -> B+)
23. Kadabra -4 (19 -> 23, B+ -> B+)
24. Sandslash -7 (17 -> 24, A- -> B+)
25. Quagsire -1 (24 -> 25, B+ -> B)
26. Politoed -5 (21 -> 26, B+ -> B)
27. Victreebel +7 (34 -> 27, B- -> B)
28. Lanturn -1 (27 -> 28, B -> B)
29. Gligar -1 (28 -> 29, B -> B)
30. Pikachu +1 (31 -> 30, B- -> B-)
31. Girafarig -2 (29 -> 31, B -> B-)
32. Electrode -2 (30 -> 32, B -> B-)
33. Arcanine = (33 -> 33, B- -> B-)
34. Vileplume +1 (35 -> 34, B- -> B-)
35. Graveler +1 (36 -> 35, C+ -> C+)
36. Shuckle +2 (38 -> 36, C+ -> C+)
37. Poliwhirl +2 (39 -> 37, C+ -> C+)
38. Crobat -6 (32 -> 38, B- -> C+)
39. Magmar -2 (37 -> 39, C+ -> C+)
40. Flareon +6 (46 -> 40, C -> C+)
41. Wigglytuff -1 (40 -> 41, C+ -> C)
42. Feraligatr -1 (41 -> 42, C+ -> C)
43. Weezing -1 (42 -> 43, C+ -> C)
44. Lickitung -1 (43 -> 44, C -> C)
45. Raichu -1 (44 -> 45, C -> C)
46. Poliwrath -1 (45 -> 46, C -> C)
47. Pineco = (47 -> 47, C -> C)
48. Sudowoodo = (48 -> 48, C -> C-)
49. Xatu = (49 -> 49, C -> C-)
50. Raticate = (50 -> 50, C- -> C-)
51. Persian = (51 -> 51, C- -> C-)
52. Dewgong = (52 -> 52, C- -> C-)
53. Dunsparce = (53 -> 53, C- -> C-)
54. Ariados = (54 -> 54, C- -> C-)
Looking forward to hearing everyone's thoughts.
kaori Diophantine