• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Harry Potter Mafia II - Game Over

Status
Not open for further replies.
@ Ghandi - I don't think you should be putting people in the spotlight for jumping on the bandwagon really, but rather look at the suspects we have an argument against, like Aamto and Obi, for example.
 
I think people with no hesitation to jump on the bandwagon without stating reasons is instantly defending themselves as they have something to hide.

This is basic human defense mechanism
 
DA is dumbledores army, a society set up in the 5th book by Harry to practice defence against the dark arts without anyone knowing. Mekkah had it as a society for the students in HP mafia I. Nevil(sp) could invite one person into it per night, and only students could join. they knew each other in DA
 
porygon3 said:
I don't see how it's a "stupid stunt" that he did. Saying "hey fellow death eater" is one thing, but when the person you're talking to turns out to be a student (I know he could be DE later but right now he was a student), I think it's kinda obvious he's joking.

edit: to leafgreen
Click to expand...
...what? I didn't catch whatever you were trying to say. I thought I made it abundantly clear that if toothache were mafia, that it would be stupid to call someone out for being a role they are not early on in the game, as regardless of what group he hits, be it the other mafia or a student, unless he were taking out a particularly powerful role, he would be doing his side more harm than good, since each mafia is already in the minority from the start.

toothache said:
Actually I hadn't read the last book so I didn't know about Percy turning back to the good side (no other spoilers please).

If Obi really wants to help the students then he knows who Fudge is and should share that information with us. Also, I'm changing my vote.

Lynch aamto
Click to expand...
Ok.... now I'm confused. You said you knew he was with the ministry. Were you specifically told that obi was allied with the ministry or were you making a guess off of what you knew of the books? Furthermore, this seems sorta fishy now, considering obi completely denied having any affiliation with you before. If he were on the students' side (as a mole-type character or otherwise), I would expect him to give away his fellow mafia members, rather than provide no evidence that he was actually allied with the students (all he has done so far is attempt to prove that he isn't ministry). Of course, if he were a mole-type character allied with the students then he would have the single most broken role in the game, and leave the ministry with no way to win, as once he gained control of the ministry, after fudge has died (assuming you were correct in that statement), then everyone else in the game would know who the ministry members were, which kinda rules that possibility out. You need to clarify what you supposedly know about obi's role.

Also, wait, what's this about aamto? I need to reread the posts, but I apparently missed something that incriminates him?

For now I've removed my vote, and will not vote again until more information surfaces.
 
Wait, so is Obi really with the Ministry or not? It would really help to define the context of Percy's role, specifically the time frame that is assumed.

EDIT: Never mind, I think I get it... I think.
 
Fine, but if I get killed for this it'll be everyone's fault!

I know who Hermione Granger is. Last night she researched Neville Longbottom in an attempt to try to get some information that could help her get his trust and build up Dumbledore's Army. We're working as a duo to retrieve as much information about the game as possible.

The person who plays the role of Hermione Granger is also a good friend of mine, and he couldn't help but tell me right away.
 
To anyone who changed their vote to aamto:

You are now suspicious. Subtly trying to protect your teammate by voting aamto. This does not mean aamto is above suspicion, but it does mean you are now in the firing line for votes. I've checked through and already made a note of who you are.

If I die my brother will see to it you are also voted, so don't think you can escape that easily. I will be watching.
 
Toothache said:
To anyone who changed their vote to aamto:

You are now suspicious. Subtly trying to protect your teammate by voting aamto. This does not mean aamto is above suspicion, but it does mean you are now in the firing line for votes. I've checked through and already made a note of who you are.

If I die my brother will see to it you are also voted, so don't think you can escape that easily. I will be watching.
Click to expand...
Hate to break it you, but you just put yourself in the line of fire for votes. You have so far been the most wishy-washy player here, originally stating obi was percy, and that he was ministry. Then you said after finding out about the 7th book that he was actually good (which, btw, you STILL haven't clarified his role for us). And now after rallying support for voting obi, you say to others to vote aamto, instead, and after doing that, and several people change their vote to him, you say they're now in the line of fire for votes. I think you're actually mafia, along with obi, who you brought attention to and then diverted away from just as quickly, and Kira, who brought up that percy changed to being good in the 7th book.

Kira said:
No Obi, I am sure Toothahce is right and you are wrong.

What I find odd is that Percy joined the good side again in the last book. Maybe you aren't mafia, but right now our best lead is what toothache said.
Click to expand...
Post found here.

This is just a theory, but you're acting far too suspicious for me not to vote one of you. It's entirely possible that obi is in fact percy. You might have figured that should this little scheme fail, you still wouldn't have given up any other mafia members, and if it succeeded, even if aamto were a villager, you had created a safeguard from that last post to reduce suspicion on yourself.

Perhaps I'm reading too much into this, but I STRONGLY RECOMMEND for the investigator to check what role toothache is tonight. For now, as he's our most likely suspect, regardless of whether toothache is mafia or not, lynch obi.
 
Leafgreen: I am not mafia. I pointed out taht Percy changed because he did. I mean why the fuck would I let Obi die if he was actually innocent? This is HP mafia. It is true that Percy did work for the Ministry but this is after/during book 7 (I assume) which means that Percy is no longer working for the Ministry.
 
Dak has a good point.

leafgreen386, I already suspected you because of your earlier votes, but this convinces me more and more that you're Ministry.

Alright you wanted me to clarify Obi's role. Here's what information I have (since you'll find out in a short time if you're smart enough to change your votes):
Obi is Percy Weasley
Percy is Ministry
He knows who Cornelius Fudge is.
He will also replace Fudge in the event of his death.

And yes while I have been acting suspiciously, I did it for the good of Hogwarts. I have several suspects so far, and quite frankly you are at the top of the list leafgreen. Seeking to argue with me further will just prove my point more.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top