-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Harry Potter Mafia II - Game Over
- Thread starter Mekkah
- Start date
- Status
Hold on... if Percy is ministry then why dont we vote him out? I mean as far as I know, aamto isn't 100% mafia.... but according to you, Obi is 100% mafia.
Obi is clearly the better choice in that situation right?
Good question. Especially since it seems to completely go against what you said in your post. You make just that single mention, just enough to put reasonable doubt in our minds, but then continue to go on to say that toothache was the best lead we had, and that he was right while obi was wrong. You still supported the motion against obi.
Furthermore:
Found here. The inspector is an incredibly powerful role. How do we know you didn't want to make them 1) waste their inspection for the night, 2) reveal himself to one of your fellow mafia, and 3) ultimately die without revealing anything else to anyone, thus making him inspecting you a safe move regardless? If obi were indeed percy, then of course the inspector would believe that toothache were innocent.Kira said:
Ok... and for what reason could he possibly have for revealing who cornelius fudge is to us if he is in fact ministry? As I said before, if he were a mole-type character that won with the students, he would be able to reveal fudge to the populous, get him voted out, become ministry leader, then reveal the rest of the ministry to us, giving them absolutely no chance at winning. I don't think mekkah would put a role as broken as that into the game. Therefore, he must win with the ministry, and would not gain anything from eliminating fudge. Why would we want to keep him alive? And it's ironic that you say dak has a good point, when it basically confirms that we should be voting obi, as he would still be solidly with the ministry then.Toothache said:
Er... right. Because that's such a solid ground to make someone mafia. People who changed their votes may have changed them since they trusted you. And this only makes me further believe you and kira are mafia, especially since you claimed that you hadn't read the 7th book yet, so how would you have known that tidbit to change plans?
Btw, I'd like to know how I'm ministry when I've just accused you, obi, and kira of being mafia, and probably ministry. Why would I fight my own? And notice that I voted obi at the end, not aamto. Not you. Not kira. Obi. However I would strongly encourage for the inspector to investigate you, since as stated previously, you are by far the most suspicious person here, and have flipped sides again, even while I was in the middle of writing this post.
Perhaps you should make up your own mind. [edit] - late lol
The thing about Obi's role is I find it difficult to believe Mekkah would put such a role in were there not more too this. Surely if Obi knew the roles of his brothers he would have killed one. If they are twins who swap allegience after a death, or lovers who die when one is killed, either way it solves his problem.
There seem to me to be two possibilities. 1 is that Obi is so damn strong he needs to be exposed from the outset, the second is that he is a player with the potential for becoming a student if a certain circumstance arises (which fits with his role). If there were a hooker in this game perhaps we should leave obi alive, and then hooker and hermione him. If he turns to our side and has information on Cornelius Fudge he could be a very valuable.
But then again, the alternative might be scary enough that we should lynch him regardless. Maybe its a big red herring, but I dunno..
Also out of curiosity, do you have any information on any other of the weasley family?
I am just too curious about Percy. We have identified who it is and have hermione to check him out, Ministry will be able to kill tonight whatever we do.
I dont really think Aamto is Guilty, but with the lack of a better target..
Lynch Obi
Also to whoever it was that said no more spoilers: You are definitely going to get spoilers in this thread. Sorry. Snape kills Dumbledore.
[Edit]-changed vote
Have a nice day.
The thing about Obi's role is I find it difficult to believe Mekkah would put such a role in were there not more too this. Surely if Obi knew the roles of his brothers he would have killed one. If they are twins who swap allegience after a death, or lovers who die when one is killed, either way it solves his problem.
There seem to me to be two possibilities. 1 is that Obi is so damn strong he needs to be exposed from the outset, the second is that he is a player with the potential for becoming a student if a certain circumstance arises (which fits with his role). If there were a hooker in this game perhaps we should leave obi alive, and then hooker and hermione him. If he turns to our side and has information on Cornelius Fudge he could be a very valuable.
But then again, the alternative might be scary enough that we should lynch him regardless. Maybe its a big red herring, but I dunno..
Also out of curiosity, do you have any information on any other of the weasley family?
I am just too curious about Percy. We have identified who it is and have hermione to check him out, Ministry will be able to kill tonight whatever we do.
I dont really think Aamto is Guilty, but with the lack of a better target..
Lynch Obi
Also to whoever it was that said no more spoilers: You are definitely going to get spoilers in this thread. Sorry. Snape kills Dumbledore.
[Edit]-changed vote
Have a nice day.
leafgreen I'm suspicious of you mainly because you're the most argumentative person here. If you were Hogwarts you'd be trying to help me not hinder me.
aamto was only suspicious cos Obi called him out about his post, which is obviously a joke. I don't think Obi would be that dumb as to say 'oh yeah I'm mafia'. This doesn't clear aamto fully however, bear this in mind.
Also getting the inspector to check me is the oldest trick in the book, because then you'd get your mafia buddies to kill me so his inspection was wasted, when he could inspect who could actually be a mafia. Notice how no-one else has claimed to be Fred or George. Why would I bother doing anything, especially this early in the game unless I had some proof?
aamto was only suspicious cos Obi called him out about his post, which is obviously a joke. I don't think Obi would be that dumb as to say 'oh yeah I'm mafia'. This doesn't clear aamto fully however, bear this in mind.
Also getting the inspector to check me is the oldest trick in the book, because then you'd get your mafia buddies to kill me so his inspection was wasted, when he could inspect who could actually be a mafia. Notice how no-one else has claimed to be Fred or George. Why would I bother doing anything, especially this early in the game unless I had some proof?
Last time I checked, it's supposed to be your own vote, not what the others think it should be...
Seriously, are you guys just completely ignoring my posts?
To vote for me is to say Mekkah purposely put in a role that will die day 1 guaranteed. If you were making a game, would you make a mafia character but then give this character's role away to two students? It just doesn't make any sense. Even Filch is a better character than that.
I didn't respond to the PM about who Fudge is because I don't know.
I didn't just vote aamto because of what he said about me saying something that's a lie. My main thing is just reading the words he's used. You of all people should know how accurately I can read between the lines of what people write, Kira.
To vote for me is to say Mekkah purposely put in a role that will die day 1 guaranteed. If you were making a game, would you make a mafia character but then give this character's role away to two students? It just doesn't make any sense. Even Filch is a better character than that.
I didn't respond to the PM about who Fudge is because I don't know.
I didn't just vote aamto because of what he said about me saying something that's a lie. My main thing is just reading the words he's used. You of all people should know how accurately I can read between the lines of what people write, Kira.
i am lynching aamto (sorry bro) because i think it is to risky to kill obi, he might become a student, after all, since this is not based on the books canon-storyline. i mean, snape is a good guy until someone special to him dies, too. this is probably lilly potter, so that wouldnt fit into the books storyline at all. i basically agree 100% with hip, the storyline does not follow the books chronology, so it would not be wise to kill obi
- Status