Adrian Marin said:I know many will probably disagree with me, but hear me out.
Arena Trap may not be the most useful ability, but it appears to be quite unhealthy. As someone stated earlier, Arena Trap users are capable of disposing of walls with ease. While this alone isn't a good argument, let's remember the sheer variety and unexpectedness of this metagame. Arena Trap performs ideally against stall and balanced; as such, Arena Trap's apparent unhealthiness is rather unexplored. One may even choose to use a Grass-type such as Shaymin or Roserade to use Arena Trap in conjunction with Giga Drain (inheriting from Trapinch) to defeat walls such as Suicune, Rhyperior, and Diancie. Let's compare Gothitelle to Arena Trap: Gothitelle rose to OU with just Shadow Tag alone, and while many may find Gothitelle to not be centralising enough to warrant a ban, it's very different in Arena Trap's case; let's just call this Gothitelle's legacy, as trap abilities seem to be viable everywhere. Arena Trap's variety, unpredictability, and capability of dispatching walls with ease justifies a suspect in my opinion.
But thats the problem. You say that Gothitelle rose to OU, but it is now NOT centralizing enough to warrant a ban. Meanwhile, Arena trap has a very small movepool and it is even more predictable once you determine the set, and its even worse. Therefore, the only factor we have to justify a ban is the unpredictability of when it could happen.
Thats it. The capability of it to dispatch walls can be comparable to running iron tail on your azelf*; except that
Iron tail on Azelf costs one moveslot; arena trap costs a teamslot. This is inheritance. There are all kinds of mons we can ban if we can call them "too hard to predict viably." This is the one thing that makes inheritance stall balanced and not overly powerful, and is also keeping the metagame balanced right now. The current metagame's unpredictability troubles all teams, and makes it that much more difficult to be truly successful.
Rhayader said:Allow me to disagree; While Arena Trap's presence on a mon could be unexpected, the movepools of both trappers are hideously shallow, being entirely physical with some very insignifcant exceptions (Trapinch gets Giga Drain, Signal Beam and Gust while Dugtrio gets Sludge Bomb+Wave and Tri Attack, great coverage moves just putting this here), and Dugtrio having a relatively small niche in Final Gambit, which can be barely be run on offensive mons, you're saccing and it has to switch in safely unless you want to risk it even further. I don't really think there's "unhealthiness to explore", its just another threat you have to account for, and guess what, if you're running stall in the first place that's a big threat for you just like an Unaware wall is a threat to offense.
Exactly my point. Its a big threat, and the versatility when using mons such as azelf and excadrill mean they can be called uncompetitive for their versatility themselves. Exca can use blaze kick to beat MB skarm and Levi Doublade. Awesome. Well its unpredictable, lets suspect it. While that seems facetious and inaccurate, it holds truth -- they are both unpredictable in the same way. What this means is that Final Gambit Arena Trap is a glorified lure; although it comes in on stallmons instead of stallmons coming in on it, it serves the same purpose: Lure out a mon's counter and kill it with x move. Arena Trap doesn't even enhance this; if I have iron tail on my azelf that diancie isn't switching out anyways.
Jaguar360 said:I highly disagree with this. Rapid Spin is needed on teams that needs their hazards up on the opponent's side, but not theirs, especially on teams with Pokemon that need Stealth Rock to get specific 2HKOs or on Sticky Web / Spikes teams. And there are very viable Spinners in Inheritance that are difficult to spinblock. For example:
Good spinners
Greninja @ Life Orb
Ability: Mega Launcher
EVs: 252 SpA / 4 SpD / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Hydro Pump
- Dark Pulse
- Rapid Spin
- Aura Sphere
Inheriting from Blastoise, this Greninja set beats spinblockers with ease thanks to STAB Mega Launcher Dark Pulse. Greninja's speed and ability to force switches also allow it spin pretty much whenever it gets in.
Slowbro @ Leftovers
Ability: Natural Cure / Analytic
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Def / 4 SpA
Bold Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Scald
- Psyshock
- Recover
- Rapid Spin
Slowbro is a more bulky approach on spinning for balanced teams. With reliable recovery, it can stick around throughout the match to spin hazards away while checking physical attackers. It doesn't have many specific anti-spinblocking tools, but its Psyshock will beat Gengar on the switch and other Ghosts must be wary of Scald burns.
Tyranitar @ Leftovers
Ability: Battle Armor
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Atk / 4 Def
Adamant Nature
- Rapid Spin
- Stealth Rock
- Rock Blast / Stone Edge
- Knock Off
Inheriting from Armaldo, this T-tar set provides a mix of bulk and power while giving both Rapid Spin and Stealth Rock support. STAB Knock Off beats any spinblocker not named Mega Sableye (which doesn't seem that good in this metagame anyway) and is both a useful utility move and strong attack.
The Drapion set inherited from Cryogonal from last page was pretty good too.
tl;dr Spinning is good
I never meant to suggest spinners are bad, but that offensive spinners are mediocre in this metagame, especially compared to the defoggers. For example, out of the sets you listed, Greninja lacks power without life orb and cant switch into basically anything; Slowbro is on the passive side (unless analytic) and is status weak if it doesn't run NC, and it also doesn't really deter spinblocking since ghosts hit it super effectively (and specially); and T-Tar is just too slow in this metagame. TBH T-tar I have been finding just too slow to be efficient, it surrenders too much momentum on offensive teams and can leave your teams out-offensed as a HO player. This isn't me saying those mons are BAD, but it is to say that they have substantial flaws, enough so that most teams will prefer a defogger rather than a spinner. The reliability of defog also makes hazards much less common in this metagame, adding on from the fact that many stealth rockers are lacking as well.
Lcass4919 said:first off: who cares if it doesnt have taunt, trick, or whatever else. just because it doesnt have a rainbow of options, doesnt mean its suddenly "terrible", it basically "forces"a pokemon of your opponents choice to lose. all trapinch needs is EQ, Superpower, crunch, and rock slide(dont think it gets stone edge) and you have a wallbreaker that shits on stall. sure say "run shed shell" all you want, but then why not unban shadow tag for the same reason? why dont we give everything access to wonder guard, and just tell people "run phasing+leech seed" yeah. because that suddenly makes it okay.
I never said it was terrible, and I never said run shed shell. The reason arena trap isn't that good is because against stall, it really only can final gambit anyways.
Lcass4919 said:now, for final gambit, do you know how convenient it is to eliminate an offensive players checks? for example, i have landorus therian with gale wings, and on your offensive team, you run idk..diance as a check. i send lando in, and you switch into diance as i u-turn into wailord with final gambit. bam, you lose. horrid example, but it has happened to me many times with my wailord team. and run protect...yeah..."its not OP, running ---- stops it!" protect is a horrible "filler move" to put on offensive teams. also lets not forget running protect on 6 mons is pretty counter intuitive for stall. since you know...they have control over what dies and all...
Eliminate an offensive players checks? Thats called a lure. You have your lan-t with gale wings and you try to check it with diancie, right? Oh wait, its actually packing bullet punch / random ass steel move. Its harder with Lant because levitate Diancie is such a good check, but it really is just a glorified lure since it can't and won't set up. If you run blaze kick on your exca while I switch in my skarmory, then get my skarmory killed so x other mon can sweep, that does the same thing you describe. If you u-turn out on the skarms switch-in and send out your arena trap user, there is a negative difference in 2 ways. The first; You lose a mon. That lure is still alive, and in fact it just slapped something and is still at full health to wreak havoc. In the case of the arena trap user; you kill something in exchange for yourself. Not only that, but it takes an entire teamslot to trapkill that skarmory for x mon, but it takes your excadrill one moveslot.
The opportunity cost for using arena trap is HIGHER than just using a lure for what you need, while they both get the same job done.
Lcass4919 said:and lastly, assist isn't broken! just run taunt/flash fire! and it only has access to assist! not banworthy! god. before you counter argue, think about what your saying. assist falls into your categories just as easily. "not many options?" check. "one simple way to stop it" check. "horribly gimmicky" check. yep you sure convinced us to not ban it.
God I hope you are joking. First off; taunt dosen't shut down assist unless its prankster and outspeeds the opposing prankster for one; and flash fire doesn't shut down assist AT ALL. That much has been gone over a multitude of times, and I'm not going to go through it again. Only has access to assist? No, they have access to more than enough moves to crush opposing teams, there was a team I saw several times in the pre-ladder days that absolutely shit on EVERYTHING. Falls into our categories? My categories have nothing to do with that. Assist is so unbelievably efficient that you have to over prepare for it, and I mean OVER-over prepare. One check isn't enough; pinsir + Flash Fire Aegislash isn't enough, hell, I saw assist run through a stall team consisting of FF Doublade, Intimidate suicune, and defensive gyarados. Lcass, before you respond, please bring back experience against GOOD assist battlers. I'm warning you, there are a lot of bad ones, but the good ones plow over almost everybody with ease. The point I'm making is this: It was proven earlier by a user of assist and several others earlier in the thread that assist teams have the ability to plow over all of your supposed checks.
lordmagecar said:Okay, here's my opinion:
A+-----A
Suicune really isnt A+ material in my opinion. There are no stall mons in A+ other than suicune, and Suicune really isnt as good as chansey or cressila. A more offensive QD suicune is still much easier to take care of than other A+ threats like Pinsir.
Also,
B------B+
Mamoswine is REALLY powerful with refridgerate. It's an amazing wallbreaker, with very strong dual-stabs with return and EQ. WIth how common lando-T is, I feel Mamoswine is a step ahead of its "collegues" in B, such as celibi and mega pidgeot.
Mamoswine has one main problem for me, and its a question that I have to ask myself: Is it outclassed to some extent by weavile; and if so, is that notable enough for it to warrant a significantly lower rank, or do its differences give it a niche seperate enough that we can rate it for what it is?
- Mamoswine is significantly more bulky than weavile, and has a marginally better dual stab combination, but can struggle against offense (despite revenging lant which is huge). Mamo is SLOW, and that is a huge problem. The power drop from mamo to Weavile isn't too noticeable either. Crunch provides great super effective coverage for weavile as well, while earthquake isn't ideal with all the levitaters around. Weavile also DESTROYS unprepared offensive teams. Mamoswine does not do so. it destroys balance, but so does weavile. It does well against stall, but so does Weavile. While certainly not outclassed, I fail to see the factors that would make mamoswine influential enough, and how the checks it has are less than that of Weavile despite the lower speed and therefore higher opportunity cost.
Idk if I feel comfortable moving it beyond B+. I see it moving up to B+ as a possibility, but beyond that seems unfitting from how Weavile is notably better. Ultimately, I may support this nomination, but future ones I really don't know about.
lordmagecar said:While Suicune is incredibly versatile, none of its roles really stand out as A+ worthy to me. I find Unaware Cressila to be better than Unaware Suicune, and with Poison Heal, it loses reliable water STAB. Quiverpass is its best set in my opinion, and even then I don't find it A+ worthy. Stall can obletarte suicune with taunt/unaware, and offensive teams have priority spam that deals massive damage to suicune. Too much pressure can constantly be applied for its quiverpass set to be A+. I think that A is a better fit for it.
Suicune is WAYY too versatile and checks such a large portion of the metagame that it really can't go anywhere but A+. Adrian and a few others pushed for this and I fully supported it. Suicune is so good because it has the tools to check so much of the physical metagame, and it is a must have on stall teams at this point. If you look at the viability rankings, it serves as a check or counter to 90% of the mons threatening to stall atm, and is also a great blanket check for the myriad of weird sets we all know are possible here in inheritance.
*I apologize for ever suggesting iron tail azelf is even good at all in my anti-ban argument for arena trap. Its not, and don't use it. I used it to illustrate a point.