NOC JOAT 10 Game Thread [Completed, GG Mafia]

JALMONT said:
in his scum game, his partner told him to post less and that eased a lot of pressure
Click to expand...
This is a lie, when did this happen in mafchat?????

JALMONT said:
if you thought my comment was "BS," why did it concern you so much that it caused you to unvote?
Click to expand...
I was concerned considering you pinged me while I was reading telling me I was getting voted. I kinda panicked and unvoted, hoping that there was a better train to hop on, to prevent me from dying. And considering the Ehmcee train was kinda slowing down, I wanted to have a better gauge.

Aura Guardian said:
That leaves... me and JALMONT? Or is that just a "they're all on the same tier as each other" thing?
Click to expand...
It means y’all are mafia, considering the last two pages y’all have “worked together” to “find out who’s mafia”
 
JALMONT said:
so you're basically saying you don't think skip is mafia or that skip and I are bussing each other. that's an interesting defense.

it just seems totally crazy to me that we can't consider 1 guy not because we don't think he's mafia...but because we think voting him out EVEN IF HE IS MAFIA will cause us to LOSE the game ??????????? so we are just giving low posters a pass now ?
Click to expand...
I think skip is scummy for sure. I dont have a good enough read on him to confidently say one way or the other. There are towny parts about him. He's not entirely far removed from his town game I think. There is like, less of a sense of desperation.

I'm mainly making the argument because if we lynch Skipper and they're mafia with someone other than you, then we are going to have a tough time finding them because we'll have no spew targets.
This basically mean's we're going into F3 blind. I know that I will die tonight or tomorrow night, so I won't be around for that F3 and frankly I think every other player here is likely to throw in F3.

However! With that said I did not really consider that we can force some interaction between mafia partners today, in terms of making everyone comment on Skipper like you or maybe it was LS or AG was talking about.

But! i still think Neon is the more likely to hit scum and he has more interactions with people (and also more non-interactions with people he may have been online with at the same time a lot but did not interact with much).
 
Aura Guardian said:
I've been thinking about this conversation a bit... but I was mentally hanging up on some things. I think "EVEN IF HE IS MAFIA" jostled my thoughts loose. Skip and Zippy were both on my list... gonna plug a "Zippy is covering for skip" idea about this.

Especially since Zippy said skip had equity with you, JALMONT. At this point, I'm afraid of hammers taking away time to talk, so I'm leaving my vote as-is for now. But I like voting either one of them much more than my previous belief that they were just our best bet.
Click to expand...
Huh?

Dude I thought you were town whats going on?
 
Day 2.3 Votecount
ZippyDoo200 (1) - ImaginaryNeon
Aura Guardian (1) - skippergamez
Lady Salamence (1) - JALMONT
skippergamez (1) - Aura Guardian
JALMONT (1) - ZippyDoo200

Deadline in 11 hours 34 mins.
 
JALMONT said:
ImaginaryNeon please post your spreadsheet of your notes keeping track of what's happening in this game or else i will be forced to conclude you are mafia unless you have another way of showing you are

if you need something to do, please go back thru this game and make a list of who thinks who is mafia. start with day 2 and you can go back to day 1 if youre bored/want to. i'll give u a couple hours and check back
Click to expand...
Holup, I need to read what happened while I was asleep first.
 
Lady Salamence said:
hm let's see

you: gave up the game multiple times, has given up on trying to solve, despite the game still going
jalmont: one of the few people putting energy into solving the game and arguably the only one trying to motivate/convince people to work towards solving the game

one of these is town behavior
Click to expand...
ImaginaryNeon said:
You're not gonna make the scummiest post ever conceived and then say it's "time to do some thinking".
Click to expand...
 
1656332843307.jpg
 
ZippyDoo200 said:
ImaginaryNeon in this game has had some egregious fence-sitting.
Click to expand...
Yay! Something to talk about!

ZippyDoo200 said:
While they have a jokey attitude, in Assist Trophy Mutiny there was genuine solving/trying to pressure scumreads.
Click to expand...
The reason I haven't been solving as much yet is because I guess I just kinda don't yet know what my opinions on half of these people are thus far.
Additionally, I feel that my play here is much more reminiscent of Werewolf Mafia, for whatever that's worth.

ZippyDoo200 said:
Voting everyone aka "finding everyone scummy" (done by mafia to not step on anyone's toes)
Click to expand...
I don't care about people's toes. I only care about the inherent comedic value of voting everyone at once.

ZippyDoo200 said:
in fact, Neon's EoD1 was to vote me, but then clarify in the next post this

Giving them an excuse to stay off the Emchee/Haruno wagon, and also preemptively downplaying their vote on me.
Click to expand...
Okay fuck it, you want to see me try and solve and shit? Well then here:
Zippy.
Is.
Scum.

There.
You said we should give up on DAY 2.
DO YOU NOT REALIZE HOW OBVIOUSLY SCUMMY THAT SHIT IS?!
THINK, ZIPPY, THINK!
NO TOWN WOULD TRY AND GIVE UP ON
DAY.
MOTHERFUCKING.
TWO.
There.
ARE YOU FUCKING HAPPY NOW?!


(Also, please note the thing about WW Mafia, because this setup is much closer to that one than to Assist Trophy.)
 
Alright I'll give Werewolf mafia another look. Since you did not read all my posts I should inform you that I never once "gave up."

My actions speak for themselves. My words have a lot of lies and memes.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top