-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Matrix 12 NOC - Game Over, Mafia Wins
- Thread starter Thetwinmasters
- Start date
- Status
forgot about this and subsequent posts. Turns out i pushed all mafia these days so them thinking I was the JK is more than likely, count urself disproved x
lol since when did you have to actively vote someone to present and maintain a scumread on them
still scumreading blazade bb
for clarification before this gets used against me i never voted blazade D1 or D2 because i read him as either PR or scum which is in my D3 reads wallpost
I skimmed all of your day 1-2 posts. Besides the "we're lynching Jalmont then Josh the town Vigilante will shoot Blazade" post, you never mentioned him, not even as a town read, no reason to suspect you to be jailer based on asek result, assuming Blazade would be the mafia's killer in that scenario. The other post you quoted is from day 3, which I literally linked, and is not relevant in the discussion of why scum would think you are the jailer.
I will however have to say I found something in your defense, in the scenario where they assume you are jailer, then fail to kill you with the same person who failed to kill Asek, it'd prove you are not Jailer, and explain why Josh I believe was killed next and not you retried.
Also I merely pointed out the vote, because it'd have been a done deal if you had voted Blazade, eliminating the need to skim the first 2 days for the info.
I will however have to say I found something in your defense, in the scenario where they assume you are jailer, then fail to kill you with the same person who failed to kill Asek, it'd prove you are not Jailer, and explain why Josh I believe was killed next and not you retried.
Also I merely pointed out the vote, because it'd have been a done deal if you had voted Blazade, eliminating the need to skim the first 2 days for the info.
this is all based around you being 100% sure of the fact blazade was the mafia's killer which i don't see how you can be
There is no day 3 wallpost either btw, just triple checked.
Also answer me this, who would be the killer for scum night 2 and 3? Former Hope, Hitmonleet or in the case we are arguing Blazade?
JK would know the setup by then and that the only town PR left is BPV. Scumread maybe, depends on who they thought was under more threat, FH or Blazade in the scenario.
My guess is Former Hope since there was no way Hitmon was performing that kill. Former had a bad D1 but most of town did put it down to his usual scumminess
Okay Former attempted to kill Asek, fails. They assume JK got him, attempt a kill on you with Former again. Why? You p much completely dropped FH for day 3, there is no reason to expect you to be the one who jailed him if you aren't moving on it at all, you'd think they'd kill anyone who suddenly has misgivings and pushes FH/ID hard, like Yeti.
are you not considering the fact they could think I was in the mindset that I'd jailed a townie and that's why i got off him? You're only presenting one side of the story here
oh this is D2.
- Status