A few people have pitched the idea of "what if you swapped Pokemon with your opponent" here in the workshop, and every time I give the same feedback. I have no idea if those people have gone on to actually submit this take on the idea, so before I do it myself, there's one kink I want to iron out.
Red Rover
The common pitfall that ideas like this fall into is that unloading a bunch of Magikarp-tier garbage onto your opponent as they do the same is neither fun nor interesting, but it is the optimal way to play most permutations of this idea. I seek to get around that idea by putting the opponent in control of what Pokemon you give them. This delivers a hard nerf to the "dump garbage onto your opponent" strategy, and opens up new ones.
If a player wishes to use the garbage strategy, there are now several roadblocks that make it significantly harder. First, because the opponent must pick the Pokemon themselves, the garbage Pokemon must appear enticing. This means that even if the sets are bad, the Pokemon themselves are still decent. Second, and more importantly, because the opponent is in control of what Pokemon they receive,
the garbage strategy is unreliable. If your opponent doesn't pick that Volcarona with Sleep Talk, Rage Powder, Snore, and Harden, you're stuck with an awful Volcarona for the rest of the game. That isn't to say that variations of the garbage strat are without merit. For example, you might put your best sets on Pokemon that appear at a glance to be subpar, or you might use sets that are good but still suboptimal. Which brings me to the strategy I think will end up dominating the meta.
Anyone who is remotely familiar with Balanced Hackmons will know the term "imposter-proofing". Because Imposter is an ever-present threat, measures must be taken to ensure one of your own Pokemon doesn't sweep your whole team. Does this sound familiar? Because any one of your Pokemon might be turned against you in the meta, I predict rover-proofing to be the dominant strategy. Just like in BH, there are a few different ways one can go about rover-proofing their team. The most straightforward way would be to make that no matter which Pokemon get taken, your remaining Pokemon can handle them. A more duplicitous method, and one that ties back to the modified garbage strat mentioned earlier, would be to put sets that are incapable of sweeping your team
onto Pokemon who look like they could sweep your team. For example, let's say your opponent has a team with Volcarona, Latios, Tyranitar, and Slowbro. What luck! You snatch up Volcarona, and- uh oh! This Volcarona doesn't have Bug Buzz. Looks like you've been baited.
The way games would play out goes as follows:
- Start by selecting which Pokemon on your opponent's team you wish to use. You are not given any more information than you would be able to glean from regular team preview.
- Once both players have made their decisions, the Pokemon are swapped.
- Only now does each player see the sets of the Pokemon they took.
- Both players choose their lead and the battle begins as normal.
It's that first step that I need feedback on. How many Pokemon should be swapped between players? The less Pokemon are exchanged, the more emphasis is put on rover-proofing. The more Pokemon are exchanged, the more emphasis is put on adapting to your opponent's team and creating a team with many smaller cores instead of team-wide synergy that can easily be disrupted
(it's also farther removed from standard play, which is always a plus for OMs). The options are one, two, and three. Any more and you're no longer building most of the team you use, which just makes the garbage option more viable.