xJownage
Even pendulums swing both ways
Suicune can be paired with a pdon lure to beat a large number of threats, as can ogre. You say its bad, but I don't know how you used it. My experience is that it is pretty damn good, but I will probably be moving it down. The meta is getting more and more hyper offensive and i'm seeing a lot less setupdon, however.Realising now that Heloisk gains a boost form Whirlwind and Status. Which means I'm now fine with quick banning this thing
xJownage
How are you luring Primal don? I wouldn't say giving Primal Groudon a free switch in is something any A+ Rank mon should. And Hippowdown completely counters it with Whirlwind, Toxic and Recovery. Running ice beam makes you fodder for an entirely different list of pokemon.
I agree, it wouldn't be fair of me to judge Kyogre without using it beforehand, so I went ahead and added it to my team and ladder up to the high ladder. And I have to say I disagree with anything outside of D rank. If we could get the fact that we're both capable battlers and both our teams were atleast decent out of the way I'll continue. I played 15 battles with Kyogre, where I replaced Manaphy with Kyogre since they're both special waters.
First of all, this thing gets zero switch ins. Because of Water spouts mechanics and Kygores niche is basically water spout, being a very fast and strong move. But this set really does face competition from Pidgeotite Keldeo. Pidgeotite Keldeo isn't completely destroyed by Primal Groudon, nor is it beaten by the likes of Ferrothorn or Blissey. And it can also switch up moves making Keldeo stronger and demanding less support, it's also an offensive check to Weavile, which outspeeds Modest Kyogre.
Why would I use Kyogre over Keldeo/Manaphy/Suicune when all of these pokemon offer team support, require close to none and is far less predictable.
Kyogre is precitable and outclassed. Kyogre has one set that is not 100% outclassed, and that is Choice scarf Water spout. The unfortunante truth about this is that it means that you're honesly walled to death by Ferrthorn, Blissey and Primal Groudon. This is of course just the biggest counters, you also have Sceptilite Milotic, Sceptilite Suicune, Sablenite Suicune, Red orb Roserade, Red orb Raikou and Red orb Hippowdown. And that's just the counters, never mind the thousands of checks.
Easily exploitable. Kyogres lack of coverage renders it useless against common red orb users. Which means you can't even 2HKO Primal Groudon. So even if you revenge kill something like Gengar, which is why you classified is at A. But that also means Primal Groudon, probably the single best pokemon in the tier at the moment, can set up a swords dance/rock polish which RUINS offensive teams. Literally the only playstyle that justifies Kyogre. How is that something that's A rank? Yeah, I kill Gengar but now I'm forced out by Primal Groudon or I give Ferrothorn a free layer of spikes/stealth rock. When instead I could use Keldeo, which forces somebody to attack you because it's far less exploitable.
In practise this thing is even worse. I used this a lot, and it was honestly just a liability. Even though it got a kill every now and then it doesn't justifie anything, I can use any pokemon with the support of five others and it can be effective. Donphan is blacklisted in OU yet Pokeaim used it in his in video.
That's basically the jist of it, I though you just fucked up the sprite when it was in A rank. This thing really shouldn't be ranked higher than D. Tell me what it gains.
Zygarde should be S rank, the reason Lucario wasn't S in the beginning was because of it facing competition from Dnite, and also being fodder for it.
The council aren't really thinking of re-evaluating Beedrilite. We're currently discussing Manaphy. All the mons who can use Beedrilite become broken anyways, so why would we go out of our way to add more wallbreakers?
Regardless, Lucario wasn't originally in S the last time we did the viability rankings, which was long after the Dnite ban. We only moved it to say that it was better than most of the other espeeders, and that was it. We hesitated to put lucario in S at the beginning of the lucario suspect, and suggesting that Zygarde is better than Lucario was is just stupid. Quite frankly, Zygarde doesn't fit with manaphy/pdon in terms of its use/utility and as a result I don't feel comfortable putting it in S.
Manaphy isn't that broken, as its lack of coverage makes it manageable for all playstyles. I won't speak further about this atm, although I wouldn't be too heavily opposed to a suspect (for further discussion, mind you).
I will update the viability rankings either later this afternoon or tomorrow.