In response to
1 True Lycan:
I agree that balance teams do not need switch-ins to everything. That doesn't mean it's okay for no team to ever have a switch-in to a Pokemon. When this Pokemon is sitting at a usable Speed tier because it doesn't even need a boosting nature to be powerful and has ridiculous Special Defense alongside great coverage, that's problematic. I understand your points about Steel vs Ground, my own stall Steel team suffers tremendously too, but there's play around Landorus. You have immunities and resistances and prediction can put you in a position to defeat it. Hoopa-U has none of that. For example, what counterplay is there to Hoopa-U other than sacrificing a Pokemon to bring in something else, only to see Hoopa-U run away to repeat it again later? That's the point I'm trying to make. You can't forever prevent Hoopa-U from getting free switches because you have to KO Pokemon eventually.
Mega Gyarados is also different because types that it threatens has actual answers to it and counterplay. For example on Psychic, preserving your Colbur + Grass Knot Slowbro, keeping Stealth Rock up to put Mega Gyarados in range of 2 hits KOing it, running fast Mew, using Trace Gardevoir, Mega Medicham Fake Out + Bullet Punch. There are ways around Mega Gyarados even if it "gets a free switch".
About your "no switch-in wallbreakers":
Mega Gardevoir has switch-ins. Chansey, Doublade, Jirachi, Mew, defensive Mega Scizor, etc. There are definitely switch-ins. All of these either have recovery or take such little damage that it's irrelevant.
Mega Heracross: Clefable, Gliscor, Doublade, defensive Landorus-T. All of these can technically switch into an attack and can cripple or damage Mega Heracross.
Mega Charizard Y: Politoed, Mega Latias, Latios, Dragonite, Chansey. All of these can easily switch into attacks and threaten Mega Charizard Y out.
Landorus: Mew, Mega Latias, Latios offensively can come in and attack / Roost later, Chansey, Depending on coverage: Zapdos is safe vs. no Rock Slide, Skarmory and Porygon2 are safe vs. no Focus Blast. Those that can switch into Landorus can immediately threaten it or use their various utility moves.
This is the difference between Hoopa-U and all other wallbreakers (including LO Kyurem-B which also breaks balance very well). Each wallbreaker does have switch-ins against certain types, Hoopa-U literally doesn't have any. If Hoopa-U had switch-ins for some X teams, then its ability to break Y number of types may be more acceptable, but it doesn't and speaking hypothetically about theorymons is pointless for our purposes.
Diggersby, I can admit, has no switch-ins I can think of (might not have any at all) but it has many other flaws that Hoopa-U lacks.
Dece1t said:Hoopa in itself has always been a controversial mon to begin with, and with good reason. It has amazing offensive stats that one could only dream of prior to its release, so it has the ability to effectively run a mixed set, or just go solely onto one side. It's also blessed with a plethora of good coverage attacks to fit teambuilding needs. These were some of the main reasons why it was suspected the first time around. Now, all the sudden Choice Specs gains usage, which on paper should be worse than running mixed, since you're limited to only Special Attacks for the most part and you're choice locked, and that's the different* reason as to why its being suspected again? I truthfully don't see the logic behind that, especially saying in the ladder thread to come up with good, different reasons as to why it should be suspected a 2nd time, and squat came up there. Either I'm missing something, or something else is up with that.
Now, I think the argument of "Hoopa having almost no switchins" is being exaggerated. If I was to come up with a few on the bat, I'd say Klefki (HP Fire atm is only at 13% usage, and towards the lower part of the list of moves it uses the most), Physical Defensive Chansey, Dragonite (who also has the ability to quite easily revenge kill it thanks to Extreme Speed), Gliscor (depending on the set), this is just to name a few. There's also the fact that Hoopa-U is not the only pokemon that has little to no switchins. Kyurem-B is someone that also has very little switchins (LO especially). You could also count Volcanion, Mega Medicham (especially when running Thunder Punch to hit Slowbro, and Psychic Coverage), Mega Pinsir, and if you didn't realize, they all have correlation. All of these examples (and I'm probably forgetting some) are all common Wallbreakers. How is Hoopa then any different from any of these? In fact, some of these are actually faster than it, and often carry priority. If they have the ability to break most walls, of course they're gonna be difficult to switch into! You'd probably have to revenge kill them in order to check them 9 times out of 10, correct? That's exactly how Hoopa is, there are plenty of Pokemon that have the ability to outspeed it (and mons that you don't have to run weird/strange sets for like some argued for Mega Sableye, they;re usually fast revenge killers you commonly see as it is) and easily revenge kill it. As for Psychic/Darks defensives cores that are often pivoted to to help keep Hoopa around, from there it's just how you play--none of them are overly difficult to break once so ever. We're talking about Hoopa and Hoopa alone, NOT Hoopa and team support.
There's also the fact that even if it was banned, as I've mentioned already, Psychic isn't gonna be affected (if you look at the stats prior to Hoopa's release, it shows that Psychic was, and still is, one of the most dominant types in the metagame). Dark is gonna be taking the major blow, and at what costs? So we lose a pokemon that is quote on quote "hard to switch into?" That's it? I think it is clear that there are much more minuses than pluses from banning it, therefore I believe it would be wise to leave it be.
Tl;Dr If you care about our metagame, you can take the time to read this.
Choice Specs Hoopa-U has the unique power to 2HKO every Pokemon in the game barring none. With Stealth Rock, every Pokemon is guaranteed, without, at worst it's a roll in very fringe cases that assumes 100% health. Life Orb and Choice Band trade that almost certain 2HKO for the ability to OHKO many more Pokemon. To claim that Choice Specs is inferior to Life Orb is simply a lack of understanding and knowledge. I'm blown back by how often people cite ladder statistics as a reason for Choice Specs being inferior. Just a few months ago back in the original suspect, Choice Scarf was highest in usage on the ladder. In spite of this, a lot of top tournament players would probably tell you a different story. (This is essentially the same as Choice Scarf Kyurem-B on Dragon, which is similarly suboptimal but a topic for another time)
Anyway, none of
Dece1t's checks are reliable against proper, well-built sets that aren't suboptimal and that are used in high ladder and tournament play. Here are damage calculations to show what I'm talking about:
Calcs
Physically Defensive Chansey:
252 Atk Choice Band Hoopa Unbound Hyperspace Fury vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey: 379-447 (53.8 - 63.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Choice Specs Hoopa Unbound Psyshock vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey: 318-375 (45.1 - 53.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock - Assumes the most important special wall on Normal is always going to be full health to check Hoopa-U in the first place.
60 Atk Life Orb Hoopa Unbound Drain Punch vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey: 294-346 (41.7 - 49.1%) -- 82.4% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock - Admittedly not so hot, but Chansey is not really not the wall you want to be risking against a Psychic team.
Gliscor:
252 Atk Choice Band Hoopa Unbound Hyperspace Fury vs. 244 HP / 8 Def Gliscor: 235-277 (66.7 - 78.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Poison Heal
252 SpA Choice Specs Hoopa Unbound Dark Pulse vs. 244 HP / 200+ SpD Gliscor: 219-258 (62.2 - 73.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Poison Heal
196 SpA Life Orb Hoopa Unbound Dark Pulse vs. 244 HP / 200+ SpD Gliscor: 185-218 (52.5 - 61.9%) -- 65.2% chance to 2HKO after Poison Heal - Guaranteed after Stealth Rock, of course.
Dragonite:
196 SpA Life Orb Hoopa Unbound Dark Pulse vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Multiscale Dragonite: 101-120 (31.2 - 37.1%) -- 79.5% chance to 3HKO
196 SpA Life Orb Hoopa Unbound Dark Pulse vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Dragonite: 203-239 (62.8 - 73.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Almost a guaranteed 2HKO assuming Multiscale is active. Choice Band Extreme Speed DOES revenge kill because of the -Def nature and Life Orb recoil, though, making this a 1 time potential switch-in to the weakest Hoopa-U set.
252 Atk Choice Band Hoopa Unbound Hyperspace Fury vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Multiscale Dragonite: 148-175 (45.8 - 54.1%) -- 52.3% chance to 2HKO - Guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Choice Specs Hoopa Unbound Dark Pulse vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Multiscale Dragonite: 120-141 (37.1 - 43.6%) -- guaranteed 3HKO - Guaranteed 2HKO
Extreme Speed cannot revenge kill even with 1 round of Stealth Rock damage because there is no -Def nature or Life Orb recoil.
I would be happy to provide additional calcs for any other check anyone can find.
Now, comparing Hoopa-U to other wallbreakers is actually quite strange. Mega Medicham (Using Jolly for calculations, but Adamant doesn't net any additional KOs in this section except 1 poor roll) does have many switch-ins for many types. Slowbro is a switch-in because Thunder Punch Mega Medicham is just suboptimal. Doublade and physically defensive Sableye are always switch-ins. Against Psychic Mega Medicham, which commonly drop Psychic STAB in exchange for Ice Punch, Mega Venusaur is a switch-in. Against Fighting Mega Medicham, which don't run Ice Punch, Mega Latias is a switch-in.
For Volcanion (Using Timid for calculations), Chansey is a guaranteed switch-in, as is Mega Latias. Without Hidden Power Grass, Gastrodon is a switch-in. And unlike Hoopa-U, many walls actually Speed creep Volcanion because it's in the base 70 Speed tier, of which Bisharp and Breloom belong to. So the likes of Zapdos gets a guaranteed OHKO with Discharge against 1 round of Stealth Rock and Mew can Knock Off the Choice Specs to make it far from powerful. Garchomp can actually take 1 attack and attack with Earthquake.
And Mega Pinsir is a sweeper not a wallbreaker. I can give a list of switch-ins, but it's so long because Mega Pinsir isn't a wallbreaker like the others.
Anyway, saying that Psychic doesn't get hit hard if Hoopa-U is banned is a pretty sentiment that may or may not be true, but I'm not sure why that's relevant. If Hoopa-U is deemed worthy of being banned (not going to assume this time!), then, regardless of its impact, it should be banned. If I use this logic, I can really just apply it to other problematic Pokemon such as Mega Charizard X and Mega Altaria. Flying is going to be top of the charts anyway, so why not just leave them alone? I think it's clear that is not the goal here, so I hope it's clear why Psychic's post-Hoopa-U state, whether it be good or bad, is not particularly relevant.
That should be enough to explain why essentially the entirety of that post was factually incorrect, I think.
On to other matters!
Dream Eater Gengar, I'm not sure where to start, so are there any specific flaws or questions you have about the ban argument? This would just help me know what points I need to clarify or expand upon. Otherwise, I'll just go on some tangential point that I'm not sure really benefits either of us.
I've also been writing this for a really long time, so I haven't even read the 3rd page yet. I'll do that at some other time...
Quick Edit:
Yeah just want to reiterate, the point is not to nerf Psychic but to ban a broken Pokemon.