it does, and i keep getting not even a nibble. ive checked all the other frames around mine intended one, and they all say "landed a pokemon" too. so im very confused. i can even give you the frame and stuff from the rng reporter
I'm sure you remembered but I'm just throwing it out there: Did you remember to use the Super Rod and not Old Rod or Good Rod? Also, when you checked to see if it says landed a pokemon on the encounter slot, the one with Super Rod said Landed a Pokemon and not, say, Good Rod or Old Rod?
You should only have to fish the one time, if you don't get it then, then you did something wrong (not that I can know what that is right away, I'd need more details).I always get "not even a nibble" like a million times until this same damned relaxed dratini eventually comes up.
EDIT: Did you also remember to account for the fact that fishing advances your frame by 4? So, say the pokemon that you want is on frame 8, you'd have to do only 2 journal flips then fish.