• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC New World NOC - GAME OVER

Can anyone give me NOC threads to read up on the following players:

waterlily3
m2h
caporegime

I think I know everyone else at least sorta well, but MoodyCloud threads wouldn't hurt too much either.
post that can come from both town and scum
im leaning town as in 9/10 cases its inquisitive town asking questions about meta

as scum i can see this being used as a headstart to look like town

Can I see a game thread where you were noc scum then? (WaterLily3)
further reinforcing the idea its inquisitive town trying to get to know everyone
i dont see scum pushing after this

I sent samoyed a "confessional" about Former that is almost identical to this.

Vote Former.
lazy reasoning to piggy back on a lynch

Former, I don't take you seriously enough in this game to restate something I've already said once, so you're getting c/p and that's it.
I can not confirm wether any player has actually sent me any confessionals however.

JALMONT hasn't posted much either (just irrelevant post count posts), but I've seen him lurking at the bottom of the page a ton. Can you give us a read instead of just keeping to yourself?
bad
i hate things like these, it draws attention to something that shouldnt be suspicious
to me thats just wolfy

A hannah vote isn't the end of the world even if she is town, but I'd want to see a bit more from a few other people before I'd seriously consider changing my vote.
"hannah being hanged is fine, but im not gonna do it"

Honestly, Former's vote being on Hannah is the biggest reason why I don't want to vote Hannah.
possibly heal/hannah is a combo to look at if former and m2h is in fact tvt

Glad to come back to this game and still see that it hasn't developed any further.

Can someone please tell me logically why Hannah would be a better lynch that Former? What are the arguments for not lynching Former? He's made questionable reads this whole game in between a ton of fluff, zero-content posts.

Also, on a sidenote, do we think it's 4 mafia 7 town? Because it's killing me to even guess 6 of my fellow townies.

I would tag JALMONT again but he's consistently shown he has zero interest in actually posting, so how about Whydon?
saying this even though you were perfectly willing to vote them but former is making you hesitate

MewtwoHidden seriously wtf why did you vote inferno? It made zero sense for you to. You literally agreed with me that inferno was town and then you lynched him?
towny agression

Still taking in the new content. On one hand I'm pleased that Former is mad at M2H, but on the other hand Former was the one who did the major pushing on Inferno. Still trying to parse all of this. Like ugh, actually that just makes me

MoodyCloud Hannahh Whydon JALMONT hi frens

Energy can we put our differences aside instead of throwing this game w/ a tunnel?

Anyway, M2H voting inferno sort of throws all of my reads out of the window, so I think I'm going to have to scrap almost everything and start from square 1. I'm hoping to make more posts later tonight after the debates.
lovely fencesitting
stepping out of the ring and letting former and m2h duel it out, only for you to jump back in to vote former when he was under pressure

Sorry, but who a dead towny was suspecting on day 1 doesn't mean much. Inferno was suspecting you, too, so why do you think only Lily's posts matter but not Inferno's? There's nothing logical about your post at all.

Okay, this post actually makes sense.
this is a nothing post

At this exact moment, I'm slightly more suspicious of former because he was the one who pushed so hard on inferno despite inferno acting fairly towny at a few moments. It's still a bit of a juggling act though.

The_Caporegime you were the third inferno vote. Can you explain why you voted the way you did?
tons and tons of fencesitting

At this exact moment, I'm slightly more suspicious of former because he was the one who pushed so hard on inferno despite inferno acting fairly towny at a few moments. It's still a bit of a juggling act though.

The_Caporegime you were the third inferno vote. Can you explain why you voted the way you did?
meaning heal genuinely went back to look at the votes and decide what to do

Lynch Former
what i said about jumping out of nowhere to vote former after fencesitting for awhile

My vote is now on Former because I don't think his playstyle on day 1 even remotely matches a doctor.
bad reasoning

Former, if you really are the doctor, you're the worst/weirdest doctor I've ever played with. You could have at least attempted to defend yourself or waited for other people to counter claim or something. But alas it's hammer and I can't talk, so hitting the draft save button for later.

---

okay, so it's not hammer anymore and I can finally post this.
bullshit
you didnt draft shit
lets be real

Anyone else going to counterclaim?
nothing post again
does nothing but draw attention to the matter as well as heal

Jalmont is on my scum watchlist now for suggesting that I'm scumbuddies with Former when I think any reasonable townie would know that at least one of former or me are town due to me voting Former that should have gotten him lynched. His day 1 was full of zero content card game posts and now that he's talking idk if it's much better.
heal as also spread a bunch of shade around and has taken the safe route in not voting the ones they shaded

Unvote.

Simply because no one else has counterclaimed. If Former's claim was false not 100% sure if it's even the correct play for the real doctor to claim, but it's been a while and idk, would rather be safe with my vote for now.
did you genuinely expect a counterclaim?
its a closed setup, as well as former wouldnt claim doc as scum without fully knowing what hes doing
 
my final decision on heal is neutral -1

theres lots of good and lots of bad
i would say the good outweighs the bad which has kept me from making it any lower than neutral -1
but there are a few posts in there that are very scummy
 
"bullshit
you didnt draft shit
lets be real"

Yes I 100% did, and anyone paying even half attention would have seen my lurking until Samoyed declared that hammer didn't happen because I didn't want to break the no-talking-after-hammer-rule that so many of you blatantly disregarded.
 
If all your accusations of fencesitting mean that I'm trying to listen and figure out what the heck is going on, then I guess I'm guilty?

Day 1 I was quite clearly agreeing with m2h and trying to find scum, day 2 (now) changed a bit because of m2h's illogical switch to voting inferno after he already assured me he trusted inferno.

I still think Former's behavior is super sketchy, and overall I'd say my entire pattern this game has been "I think it's Former" "I definitely think it's former" "Day1 lynch was sketch af so now day 2 is weird but I still don't trust former" "I definitely don't trust former" "I don't trust former but a scary near-2-day-early-self-hammer shakes things up and I want to be careful and get more info."

Which is basically to say I REALLY want to tunnel Former while still being as careful as possible. In terms of actually pushing for a vote, Former's the only one that I've pushed and so I think my general flow is really consistent even if I'm pausing at times to consider alternative theories.
 
If all your accusations of fencesitting mean that I'm trying to listen and figure out what the heck is going on, then I guess I'm guilty?

Day 1 I was quite clearly agreeing with m2h and trying to find scum, day 2 (now) changed a bit because of m2h's illogical switch to voting inferno after he already assured me he trusted inferno.

I still think Former's behavior is super sketchy, and overall I'd say my entire pattern this game has been "I think it's Former" "I definitely think it's former" "Day1 lynch was sketch af so now day 2 is weird but I still don't trust former" "I definitely don't trust former" "I don't trust former but a scary near-2-day-early-self-hammer shakes things up and I want to be careful and get more info."

Which is basically to say I REALLY want to tunnel Former while still being as careful as possible. In terms of actually pushing for a vote, Former's the only one that I've pushed and so I think my general flow is really consistent even if I'm pausing at times to consider alternative theories.
yes lets focus on super minor points
that makes me read you better
 
and now that you brought it up

former if you genuinely are doctor, and you were willingly gonna gamethrow because town wasnt reading you right
then after this is done you shouldnt play this game ever again

gamethrowing is such bullshit
 
"bullshit
you didnt draft shit
lets be real"

Yes I 100% did, and anyone paying even half attention would have seen my lurking until Samoyed declared that hammer didn't happen because I didn't want to break the no-talking-after-hammer-rule that so many of you blatantly disregarded.
"But alas it's hammer and I can't talk, so hitting the draft save button for later. "
this is not the line of someone who actually drafted a post
 
The people game throwing were the ones who decided to lynch after a doctor claim. I just didn't want to continue to be apart of such stupidity.

honestly the more I play the less I trust claims under duress and I can't really say the manner in which you claimed fills me with much faith.
 
To anyone who thinks M2H could ever be town, read his posts

He's not looking for scum. He's looking for who he can lynch.

This is honestly straight up false, and yeah I encourage people to go read my posts because then their paranoia of me would vanish.
 
The people game throwing were the ones who decided to lynch after a doctor claim. I just didn't want to continue to be apart of such stupidity.

stop posting please. u make it harder and harder for me not to vote you with every dumb word i read from you.

just trying to do both u and me a favor thx
 
Back
Top