It’s posts like Lonelyness’ that really get on my nerves. There’s nothing wrong with stating your case of course, just so long as your arguments can actually be backed up and are not completely baseless or just plain outright false.
Stuff like this:
LonelyNess said:Abomasnow: If it didn't have Snow Warning, then I wouldn't be at all impressed with this guy, but the fact that it does is the one reason we should send this guy to BL. Being able to support Stallrein, as well as Substitute / Spikes Froslass @ Brightpowder for an entire game says gg to the majority of teams not dedicating a significant amount of their team to stopping it. Although my first sentence isn't to be misleading, it packs a huge punch with Wood Hammer / Blizzard, dual Base 120 STAB is nothing to scoff at, and with the correct EVs it can be incredibly bulky from the Special Side.
What exactly do you define as “a significant amount of their team”? I mean I’ve been able to demolish Hail teams single-handedly with a Clefable and a Moltres, on two different teams. In fact they cover so much of a typical Hail team by themselves that I barely even need to consider the threat of Hail stall anywhere else. Except for possibly a spinner or a Poison type, but they are useful for so much more besides countering Hail. So forgive me if I haven’t had trouble with Hail teams due to the fact that (gasp!) I’ve actually prepared for them when building my teams. And since when is having to prepare for a threat overcentralizing?
LonelyNess said:Spiritomb: Let's face it, with its defenses, resistances, status attacks, ability to stat up and sweep, this thing is probably THE biggest defensive threat to the tier. I equate it similarly to something like Lugia would be to the OU tier. It's not at all difficult to get 6 Calm Minds and completely destroy a team, and with the only real way to hit being hard, and from the Special side (considering you could very well be completely neutered by Will-O-Wisp) it's just too much for the tier.
Ok, so you’ve mentioned stuff it can do. Doesn’t really tell me why it’s broken. It sure as hell can’t do all that stuff on the same set, and comparing it to Lugia is just laughable. How exactly? The only thing they have in common is Pressure. And don’t give me that crap about it being impossible to kill either, as that is just completely untrue.
LonelyNess said:Gallade: With the above gone, there is nothing stopping this at all. Ice Punch / Shadow Sneak / Close Combat is all you need coupled with a Swords Dance and you're golden. This, along with the Pokemon below is probably the #1 offensive threat.
Wait a minute? Did you just say “With the above gone…” and tried to get away with using it as an argument? First of all, Spiritomb is not going anywhere yet, nor is it guaranteed to be gone any time soon. But even if we assume that it was, how could you possible know that it would be unstoppable? You’re making it sound as if every team carries a Spiritomb to deal with it, which would also be false. I’ve used various Pokemon to beat Gallade; Arcanine and Moltres are two that I’ve used to great success. But you don’t even need a reliable counter to deal with it. At 80 base speed it is easily checked and revenge-killed by faster Pokemon like Staraptor, Crobat and various others. A powerful threat? Yes. Unstoppable? Absolutely NOT.
LonelyNess said:Staraptor: Ok, this is why you need 2 Normal resists MINIMUM per team, as well as a Fighting resist who isn't neutral to Normal. This thing is single handedly destroying teams, and it doesn't even need to wait for the team surrounding it to help. Its own unique movepool allows it to take its own counters out all by itself. The only Pokemon I have seen counter this beast 100% is a HEAVILY defensive Luxray used by Eo Ut Mortus. Brave Bird / Close Combat / Return is all this guy needs and with U-turn to scout out your opponent's "counter" it's just a matter if when, not if, this Pokemon sweeps you.
This argument is so bad I don’t even know where to start, it is just full of completely false and meaningless statements. No matter what you might think, you DON’T need two Normal resists, it DOESN’T take out its own counters (how does that even make sense?) and it is certainly NOT guaranteed to sweep a team. I’ve used various things to deal with it; I’ve managed to counter it with an Arcanine on one of my teams. On another I’ve used a combination of Spritomb and Raikou. Those are just a couple of examples among others that have worked for me. One thing it definitely can’t do is switch in and out freely. Something I can’t help but laugh at some people that try to use choiced Staraptor against me. It is so easily predicted, and with SR and Brave Bird recoil it has a very short lifespan.
I could go on and refute your entire post, but I don’t have the time right now. The main point I want to make is that people here seem to be looking for things to ban without adopting an open mind and considering the possibility that maybe, just maybe, nothing needs to be banned at all. My current opinion on the tier? I don’t see anything in need of a ban right now. About a week ago I was 50/50 on Shaymn, but have since changed my mind after seeing that most people have now found ways to comfortably prepare for it, myself included.
So in conclusion, I urge people to adopt the mindset that a Pokemon should not be banned unless it is absolutely necessary, and to take into account that it has only been 2 and a half weeks testing so far.