Cynthia said:I have used hail teams and faced many hail teams and found it to be a very effective strategy overall. Both offensive and defensive hail teams have a lot of potential and it is a fairly easy strategy to execute.
Snover would not necessarily be banned if Abomasnow was. Abomasnow is good for more things than just Snow Warning, it has a large movepool and a solid statistical spread. Snover has very limited offense and if the weather were to be changed, has trouble switching into anything with its low defenses. I would be interested to see if forcing hail teams to use Snover over Abomasnow would significantly decrease their effectiveness.
As for my part, I've found that there are counters to hail teams, but most of the counters are fairly highly centralized and without them beating hail teams is extremely difficult.
This is a much clearer and much less frusterated and angry way of saying what im trying to say. Thank you Cynthia :D.
While i disagree with your snover comment, I think its definately closer to what im trying to say, than the words people are putting in my mouth.
SHUCKLE MAN said:Seeing people with ban lists that are 10 Pokemon long is actually quite terrifying. There is one thing that I don't think people understand; we need to ban as little as possible, not as much as possible.
Ideally, we shouldn't have to ban anything, but some people just want to ban things, just for the sake of it.
Check out this thread.
http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=11508 This is what we do NOT want to happen ever again. Some posts there are absolutely cringe-worthy. Some posts here are steering towards that direction, all over again.
Anyway, about Abmoasnow, etc, some people are providing fairly decent arguements as to why it might be broken, others aren't. At any rate, I'm personally leaning towards 'It's not broken', but, obviously, I'll be changing my mind if I have reason to in the future.
And, I'm really worried that people will try and ban things unneccessarily. Did we not all see the Shaymin-S vote?
While i agree, we should ban as little as possible. We should definately not hesitate to ban things that need to be. If this list IS 10 pokemon long(which i doubt), than so be it.
Also, the Advanced should be a guideline, not something to avoid, they are near-flawless imo.
Bologo said:Just because something has high usage doesn't make it a suspect. There's no definition for "overcentralizing", so you shouldn't be trying to throw it around as a well-known term, because it really isn't. Your definition of it isn't very good. If something's strong and is used a lot, of course you might have to change your team. That goes for any good pokemon.
Point taken, this is to a certain exctent that it will become a suspect is what i mean.
But my point still stands "if something is too strong, and many people are using it making it effect the metagame in a negative manner".
Bologo said:Also, you're still saying that if we don't agree with you that "these teams are quite dominant, if not broken, or at least a suspect based on usage", then we're wrong. I don't know where you're getting that idea from, because we're not even halfway through the first part of the test, so I don't know how you can already say that something is so broken that no one can ever convince you otherwise.
Yea, how long did it take for people to realize Rayquaza was Uber? It doesnt have to take a long time to realize something is broken. Especially since i have played alot of this new UU. Refer to Cynthia's post as its a much clearer version of what im trying to say. The statement "Hail is no easier to use effectively than a standard team, and does not have a fairly clear advantage against standard teams.", i believe that to be wrong, yes.
Bologo said:I'm sorry, but that's ridiculous. They're used too much so they should be banned? I don't see us banning Sandstorm teams in Standard, even though they're used quite a bit, so why in the world should we be doing that in UU?
The answer is simple, because they arent broken. Thats really not to hard to understand. To add to this, pokemon in OU are strong enough to deal with these Hail threats.
Bologo said:A well played team in general SHOULDN'T lose, but they do because people can either gimp their team to carry a counter...etc etc etc.
Thats really not clear at all. A player of equal skill with a standard team vs another of the same, should be 50/50. Hail makes it more to the effect of 60/40, or even 70/30.
I am dropping this topic of Hail Teams.