-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread
- Thread starter NightEmerald
- Start date
i dont like how you tried to reason to us that mafia and werewolf both shot chickening, both me and fairy think that probability is REALLY low. felt like you were trying to keep the game less solved. more of a gut read right now
what questions??? are you complaining that someone hasnt been here in the last 45 minutes at midnight american time
i mean yes i do think that probability is low but which post of mine did you derive this from...?
i asked him about it d1 as well, and i never got a response
I would not characterize suggesting a mechanical possibility as trying to convince you of anything, the way I work through my thoughts in this game is first suggest possibilities second evaluate them
I agree it's unlikely that both kills happened to hit chickening specifically, but it's also weird that even one kill hit chickening so until we evaluate why the one kill hit them (or we find out other information) it's not something I would rule out yet
And there is no real solving to be done at the moment so I don't feel like it's possible to "try to keep the game less solved", my motivation at the moment is to clearly establish possibilities so that later solving can be applied to them rather than ignore things now by making assumptions and forget about them when it's important later
I agree it's unlikely that both kills happened to hit chickening specifically, but it's also weird that even one kill hit chickening so until we evaluate why the one kill hit them (or we find out other information) it's not something I would rule out yet
And there is no real solving to be done at the moment so I don't feel like it's possible to "try to keep the game less solved", my motivation at the moment is to clearly establish possibilities so that later solving can be applied to them rather than ignore things now by making assumptions and forget about them when it's important later
I'm not sure what you mean by this because fairy was the one who told me what the possibilities were
i think it was probability wise a werewolf rand
To expand on this, the possibilities for one kill are:
One kill was idled (90% ww because there's 0 reason to idle and 3 of 3 maf at least one would submit)
Town pretty lady blocked the mafia killer
Jailkeeper jailed the other kill target
Mafia kill targeted the werewolf
Both kills were targeted at chickening
I think this is it yeah?
ok, i think we can get rid of the first and last
a fairy i I get the frustration because I am equally frustrated and also a little checked out of the game now
But also what am I supposed to do when someone decides to not play until 3 hours before deadline that’s 2am for me right. My growing hatred of afks isn’t really such a throwaway thing to say, because the alternative to hating afks is condemn us all to never actually playing noc again, because we aren’t actually playing this game for real. We are just faking going through emotions.
It’s frustrating that the best fix has come to me trying to vote people in games so that later in the game after town takes on a huge disadvantage we might get one or two phases where whoever is left is allowed play because someone who doesn’t want to insist on ensuring no one else can.
We actually had a chance of clearing the afks and having a rerand this time around is the sad thing, when people weren’t confirming so it’s a shame that we are in this situation once again where every noc has to be unplayable for town. I am really trying to hold my emotions in and it’s once again not fair that the players have to try solve this issue. Anyways I’m mostly checked out now because I don’t think the game will be fully solvable for town with how it’s being played now, but maybe an earlier deadline will help a little who knows.
If you are a power role who is going to die in a game where town starts with 3 protectives, you should claim and try not to die please friends. Thank you!
But also what am I supposed to do when someone decides to not play until 3 hours before deadline that’s 2am for me right. My growing hatred of afks isn’t really such a throwaway thing to say, because the alternative to hating afks is condemn us all to never actually playing noc again, because we aren’t actually playing this game for real. We are just faking going through emotions.
It’s frustrating that the best fix has come to me trying to vote people in games so that later in the game after town takes on a huge disadvantage we might get one or two phases where whoever is left is allowed play because someone who doesn’t want to insist on ensuring no one else can.
We actually had a chance of clearing the afks and having a rerand this time around is the sad thing, when people weren’t confirming so it’s a shame that we are in this situation once again where every noc has to be unplayable for town. I am really trying to hold my emotions in and it’s once again not fair that the players have to try solve this issue. Anyways I’m mostly checked out now because I don’t think the game will be fully solvable for town with how it’s being played now, but maybe an earlier deadline will help a little who knows.
If you are a power role who is going to die in a game where town starts with 3 protectives, you should claim and try not to die please friends. Thank you!
No it was a pretty good kill for a werewolf so would indicate they are experienced in my head, or just they are playing with town (as they should be) and trying not to cross kill with mafia
