• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

okay i am alive, have been super busy last few days and just in general but ill try my best. I think fairy is likely town based off her eod1
joey said:
7: Evie - I didn't catch this first time I was reading through but I am really interested to know why she is okay with massclaiming but not with hypoclaiming? (#166). I also think calling for town pretty lady not to be used is kinda weird? I feel like the general rule is that using your role is always going to benefit town more even if you do end up blocking a town PR, because it gives credence to your claim later on. There's a scenario where this is a Werewolf POV because she wants to use the 1-shot werewolf block later on to claim town pretty lady who idled at the beginning. And even outside of that scenario there's also the mafia angle where the kill being blocked is one of the worst things that could happen to them.
Click to expand...
I didn't think hypoclaiming was good because i think it gives scum more info than it does us; however i was not aware that massclaiming is throwing so i think the best play is neither for the moment.

Does blocking a town role actually give credence to your claim? as you said both the werewolf block and the maf pretty lady can be used for a similar result, and the odds of blocking a maf role are way less then blocking a town role; while yes getting the kill blocked is bad for mafia, so is a cop or a protective - though now doc #1 is dead its probably slightly better to use it now

apricity said:
Wolf just shot chickening you bonehead.
Click to expand...
wdym? chickening was town

joey is giving town vibes but im not confident enough to say yet
 
I have backread a bit, will need to read more later tho, however I don't see how why joey votes like this at the end of day like this especially when most people aren't here to vote someone else
 
The post (I think from joey) that had the “accusation” (not really lol) of a perspective slip from me isn’t right. I just misread how the werewolf operates which is my b. I mistook the “become strong” part of the role as only getting one factional kill for the whole game. So I thought since there was only one kill it had to be mafia because there was no way wolf would blow their only kill on night one. So again, sorry for the confusion, not a perspective slip just a reading comprehension slip haha

Agreeing with the sentiment that it is in town’s best interest to always vote someone rather than no vote/abstain/whatever. It sucks that a doctor was hit in what seems like could be something preventable but hey, them’s the breaks in mafia sometimes

Something I’m not necessarily a fan of is “pressure votes” because I feel like in forum mafia it’s too easy for people to go afk or just get busy IRL so then you have either someone that doesn’t defend themselves from the pressure votes until it’s maybe too late OR the person that applies the pressure vote afks and then you’re stuck with a bad vote. I’m not going to bandwagon with any of the votes so far because of this

As for calling me one of the afks I did say in one of my earlier posts that I was purposely hanging back on day one, but I understand I still probably didn’t maintain level of activity that yall want. I’ll do better and not miss a deadline this time

As for who I scumread I feel like apricity and liquidrelief are my top suspects. I think being overly hostile (and I know yall aren’t being mean on purpose or anything) is detrimental to town. We should be more constructive in our discussions other than just saying “no this is awful” or whatever. I understand not everything is going to be kumbaya but the aggressiveness that I’m perceiving raises a red flag for me for these two
 
Also sorry if it’s offputting that I always show up with paragraphs, I get it’s more the culture here to make many short posts in a row but I just don’t do that, not my style lol
 
phoopes said:
As for who I scumread I feel like apricity and liquidrelief are my top suspects. I think being overly hostile (and I know yall aren’t being mean on purpose or anything) is detrimental to town. We should be more constructive in our discussions other than just saying “no this is awful” or whatever. I understand not everything is going to be kumbaya but the aggressiveness that I’m perceiving raises a red flag for me for these two
Click to expand...
im not trying to be hostile im just finding patterns
 
Tommy said:
Evie do you have anyone you think is mafia
Click to expand...
im a little suspicious of dbd/liquidrelief(?) for immediately hopping on the lynch afk wagon - reminds me of me last game when i just kinda agreed to let the afks be shot cause it was either beneficial for mafia or inevitable and doing so gave town cred.

i did scumlean you cause of the pulsar vote but what joey said about the werewolf discussion at the start of the game was really smart

i could definitely see hal being scum but im not super sure of it
 
liquidrelief said:
im not trying to be hostile im just finding patterns
Click to expand...
no worries I know you’re not trying to offend anyone or anything but I see you and apricity’s posts as less constructive which makes me lean scum on you

I also forgot to mention I think the DBD/fairy interaction on day one was weird with the vote/unvote thing so I’m keeping an eye on that
 
Evie said:
im a little suspicious of dbd/liquidrelief(?) for immediately hopping on the lynch afk wagon - reminds me of me last game when i just kinda agreed to let the afks be shot cause it was either beneficial for mafia or inevitable and doing so gave town cred.

i did scumlean you cause of the pulsar vote but what joey said about the werewolf discussion at the start of the game was really smart

i could definitely see hal being scum but im not super sure of it
Click to expand...
well im not fully in the lynch mindset but i do kinda agree with hal
 
Evie said:
im a little suspicious of dbd/liquidrelief(?) for immediately hopping on the lynch afk wagon - reminds me of me last game when i just kinda agreed to let the afks be shot cause it was either beneficial for mafia or inevitable and doing so gave town cred.

i did scumlean you cause of the pulsar vote but what joey said about the werewolf discussion at the start of the game was really smart

i could definitely see hal being scum but im not super sure of it
Click to expand...

if werewolf shot dbd or liquid and they flipped town, do you think werewolf was working with town or mafia?
 
phoopes said:
no worries I know you’re not trying to offend anyone or anything but I see you and apricity’s posts as less constructive which makes me lean scum on you

I also forgot to mention I think the DBD/fairy interaction on day one was weird with the vote/unvote thing so I’m keeping an eye on that
Click to expand...
well its kind of too early to make “constructive decisions” we barely know anything
 
phoopes said:
no worries I know you’re not trying to offend anyone or anything but I see you and apricity’s posts as less constructive which makes me lean scum on you

I also forgot to mention I think the DBD/fairy interaction on day one was weird with the vote/unvote thing so I’m keeping an eye on that
Click to expand...
tbc i didnt interact with dbd on day 1, dbd interacted with me
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top