Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

[a fairy]

Everyone should listen to me I’m always right why is mafia not helping us help them a fairy

You want us to vote you so your partner can get shot and get put to 1 left tomorrow instead of that one guy getting auto f3 and no voted on you today what’s the strat what’s the thinking

Can we discuss this or are you just content to play against wincon

you're right im gonna trust you over myself when examining our endgame!!
any "oh you can get to f3" stuff is totally bunk lol

 

[Tommy]

What does this mean!!!!!

I swear if airc or scary end up as werewolf it’s gg if we vote town today

 

[Tommy]

you're right im gonna trust you over myself when examining our endgame!!
any "oh you can get to f3" stuff is totally bunk lol

You can but you auto lose if you don’t vote werewolf before then, so like you can and will get to endgame to lose it

 

[a fairy]

its simply just not the case

 

[Tommy]

Im the only one within this game that can do maths

 

[a fairy]

and we're the only one within this game that can understand it

 

[Tommy]

We should just end this phase tonight thought near the deadline so we don’t get an extended deadline

 

[joey]

I still find it hard to believe that the wolf was obvious to the Mafia during day 1 but none of the town has picked up on it at all

 

[AirC]

Legit if I was scum why would I want to vote out Celever, it doesn't make sense, if we just random someone we have way greater odds of winning

 

[Tommy]

I still find it hard to believe that the wolf was obvious to the Mafia during day 1 but none of the town has picked up on it at all

This is valid

 

[Tommy]

Legit if I was scum why would I want to vote out Celever, it doesn't make sense, if we just random someone we have way greater odds of winning

Can you elaborate on this, are you assuming you are maids or werewolf here? Either way the answer is you don’t have the votes

 

[a fairy]

i wish i were maids

 

[joey]

Maybe they did find the wolf through role cop and do know them but at least the day 1 part I doubt

 

[apricity]

tommy. Your posts make no sense to me. This is the last time I will try to establish a conversation between us. Otherwise postgame is fine.

I am convinced that voting within the POE is optimal today. You are not, which is why you voted fairy. Yet, you say:
Hal pretending 1-2-1 is the same as 2-1-1

I have NEVER pretended this. Where have I said this?? Where have I even mixed up the two in this thread??

Then you say:
I agreed with to do this you just wanted to do it in a way which could make town lose

I have not seen you agree to this! You voted fairy then fucked off. I haven’t seen you actually try to build a case on who within the five we should vote. This is important for town players to do right now!! If we get the werewolf we are in a very good spot!

In addition, “I just wanted to do it in a way which could make town lose”
-how can town lose? I’m wholeheartedly UNCONVINCED that anyone who drew wolf would, goinginto 3-2-1 night with the whole thread shouting at them, shoot town. TOTALLY unconvinced. It’s EASY to see why they had to shoot mafia there.
-what “other” way is there?

 

[Tommy]

You can be a maid if you want to a fairy

 

[AirC]

What is maids

 

[a fairy]

You can be a maid if you want to a fairy

would solve this unemployment problem i have ):

 

[apricity]

tommy. Your posts make no sense to me. This is the last time I will try to establish a conversation between us. Otherwise postgame is fine.

I am convinced that voting within the POE is optimal today. You are not, which is why you voted fairy. Yet, you say:
Hal pretending 1-2-1 is the same as 2-1-1

I have NEVER pretended this. Where have I said this?? Where have I even mixed up the two in this thread??

Then you say:
I agreed with to do this you just wanted to do it in a way which could make town lose

I have not seen you agree to this! You voted fairy then fucked off. I haven’t seen you actually try to build a case on who within the five we should vote. This is important for town players to do right now!! If we get the werewolf we are in a very good spot!

In addition, “I just wanted to do it in a way which could make town lose”
-how can town lose? I’m wholeheartedly UNCONVINCED that anyone who drew wolf would, goinginto 3-2-1 night with the whole thread shouting at them, shoot town. TOTALLY unconvinced. It’s EASY to see why they had to shoot mafia there.
-what “other” way is there?

If you want to sit and pout and not play the game that’s fine but you would be exactly the kind of player that you complain about all the goddamn time to me because this behavior is not consistent with a town win condition and I’m kind of over it!

 

[apricity]

just wanted to do it in a way which could make town los

If you have an intelligent thought that would be an improvement over my current plan by all means suggest it!! What other way is there??

 

[Tommy]

apricity you don’t try to engage in conversation is my problem but rather you tell me what you went to do when I’m perfectly capable of thinking for myself and your method is not optimal as much as you want to believe,

If I would vote werewolf yes I would vote today but there is a legit chance it backfires

I’ve already given you chances this game to vote people I townread and it backfired, so you aren’t really running in a lot of positive credit here with your read on the game for me to rely on

I’m more than happy to engage with you if you genuinely want to engage but earlier on your engagement was telling me that you want to essentially vote myself or Joey and I’m not getting into a 1v1 with Joey on a day phase where I am essentially cleared to any reasonable player

You are more than welcome to push me, you are more than welcome to try work with me

What I am not going to do is let you try cash in goodwill while trying to vote me out for not agreeing with you in a game you’ve been off base on, because I’m obvious town and if you weren’t super biased against me you would see that

So like you can choose to have me permanent Poe even when I’m obviously town, or you can choose to work with me and not be hostile when I’m obviously town but not both

 

[Tommy]

I agreed to vote scary or airc then you rage baited and egoed me lmao

Because I wouldn’t engage in a 1v1 you wanted to set up with ME in it I’m so obviously giga town it’s crazy this game

 

[Evie]

i think tommy is not wolf at least, im not sure why in particular he cant be 3rd scum

 

[Tommy]

And who doesn’t understand like the two players who have I said might not understand have already shown their confusion in thread so like

Yes they might not understand

 

[Tommy]

i think tommy is not wolf at least, im not sure why in particular he cant be 3rd scum

Look how celever spoke to me all day

 

[AirC]

Can you elaborate on this, are you assuming you are maids or werewolf here? Either way the answer is you don’t have the votes

So idk what maid is and I'm still vt but I feel like scum just need to push any random townie and they have the best chance of winning, if they try to kill werewolf now they'll just end up in a coinflip