i think its indicative that they didnt want to vote wolf at the very least, or do you think they legitimately did not care at all what happened and their wincon?
-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread
- Thread starter NightEmerald
- Start date
i think its indicative that they didnt want to vote wolf at the very least, or do you think they legitimately did not care at all what happened and their wincon?
trying! airc is very hard to read as a player or playstyle because theres hardly anything there though
bluedoom i do think was towny today
Like I said, I assume theyre perfectly fine going into MYLO bc I am a potential misvote but also took into consideration how being screwed over as a WW would feel. Bc of that they chose to stay back and let whatever happen, happen
hmm i see
AirC day 3 does not read scum to me.
He seems incredibly suspicious of the plan to go for Joey, uncooperative, combative, and misunderstands what we are doing and why we need to do it
Stubborn wrongness reads town to me
I’m more inclined to revisit Bluedoom than AirC
It is weird that both realiti and Bluedoom want AirC
This genuinely reads as frustrated, ignored town to me.
well if airc is town the reason they are both pushing for airc is that only one town is pushing airc and the mafia smeels blood
so the mafia is also pushing for airc in that world, making him town
but also i do get the paranoia of betting a game on a low posting slot, like i get what youre saying theres moments of trace amounts "this leans town" but its very hard to bet a game on this because no matter what you tell me i can never have a confident read on airc, i can go with the consensus of what everyone said but id never bet much on being right
so the mafia is also pushing for airc in that world, making him town
but also i do get the paranoia of betting a game on a low posting slot, like i get what youre saying theres moments of trace amounts "this leans town" but its very hard to bet a game on this because no matter what you tell me i can never have a confident read on airc, i can go with the consensus of what everyone said but id never bet much on being right
After a reread I think he was just listing out some options, I dont see anything combative on his end
this post is probably one of his more town AI posts I will acknowledge that
this doesnt seem like partners right
I'm going to recap the information in your post:
If airC is town then that means mafia is pushing for airC which makes airC town
^This is useless
"its very hard to bet a game on this because no matter what you tell me i can never have a confident read on airc"
^Regardless, you have to make a read on airC. If you make that read based on your estimated alignments of bluedoom+realiti, that's fine. But you are not excused from reading airC because they are a lowposter. We have to find a method to determine his alignment.
I think he reads as frustrated town, do you agree?
its moreso, i think the fact two of the poe are pushing the third isnt that interesting, so it seems useless because the comment you had made which im piggybacking on isnt thast useful in the first place
I want to revisit whether cel/cary could have been a bus on day 2 and why we think bluedoom now is town
I really want to just veto airC out from consideration i don't think that's it
in that post you just cited i agree, a lof of the time he looks clueless and in the one post where he lists out the mech options it seems a bit busyworky
if i had to gun to head i guess i would call him town not confidently
No. You are not thinking correctly.
Realiti pushed AirC day 3, bluedoom is now thinking airC is scum day 5.
So there is an ordering here.
Your hypothesis is that mafia is jumping on airC as a mislynch. But that only makes sense if bluedoom is mafia. Because bluedoom scumread airC second. Realiti scumread airC two full days ago.
But then this is a weird hypothesis as well!!!
If realiti is mafia, bluedoom is town:
-realiti pushed airc for a mislynch to divert us from joey, ok, fine. Why's bluedoom scumreading airC now then -- he got snowed?
If realiti is town, bluedoom is mafia:
-why would bluedoom not just continue pushing for realiti, it doesn't matter to him which mislynch he gets?
i think a lot of posts CAN be a bus from celever like the inactivity calls and blaming scary for pulsar (?) stuff but
the posts i just quoted where its saying he doesnt understand the rules (nicely) and should be subbed, i feel like he doesnt make that about a partner, its quite awkward on celevers part to make that call out if scary is reading it right, hes more likely to interact and try explain stuff in mafia
and its not even like a heated level where it seems distancing, it seems like a genuine call to get him out of the game and someone explain shit to him, stuff celever couldve done if they are both mafia
I guess the conclusion is that we're both town :)
Yeah, I dont see why celever can't coach scary in scumchat
Scum were dominating the game so there was no reason to be frustrated either
yeah and celever is also not the type to do that type of call out about a partner in thread i think he would feel guilty, so like unless its preplanned distancing which is possible but doesnt read like it then shrug