The scarfer argument is something that has been brought up for literally every offensive pokemon. It applies to them all, from Mewtwo to Sawk, and so really can't be used as a point in MLuke's disfavor.
Its not my intention to disregard lucario or something. Photofluid said that once he has setup its unlikely that anything will hit him and that statement is just wrong. There are a lot of things that are faster, can take an priority hit and ko back, scarfers are just a part of those things.
Problem is, most of MLuke's checks lack recovery and MLuke double resists SR, so it can just switch in multiple times in a match and weaken it's checks over time. Also, when the only other way to deal with MLuke is a scarfer that can only come in when something else dies, that creates a big problem. Namely, that something will have to die every time MLuke comes in so you can send in you scarfer, only for MLuke to switch out...
Given Lucarios frailty i realy doubt that he can switch in and out multiple times like that, he will also be worn down very quickly and the lower his health gets the more checks he gets because the amount of dmg needed to take him out drops with every switch in.
I realy dont want to get involved with that ban discussion, mostly because i simply dont care if he stays or not.
But the arguments against him are kinda one sided from my point of view. Ur saying he can wear down his checks while ignoring the fact that Lucario cant switch into all that many things without taking significant dmg on the switch.
I ve just read through Tabuu's Post in the suspect testing Thread and its somewhat the same with his argumentation. He is completely fixated on countering Lucario, which is very difficult if not impossible, i agree with that. I dont know the criteria for banning something, if not having solid counters or only very few then Lucario should be banned.
However, from my point of view, as long as there are several reliable ways of dealing with a pokemon, then the pokemon is fine for me and thats a given in Lucarios case. There are lots of things that can check him, he can be revengekilled and its quite difficult to switch him in and set up even once due to his frailness not to mention multiple times.