:reshiram: Perfect Unova :zekrom:
Some of you may be familirar with Gen 8's PErfect Galar, which took every Pokémon in the SwSh regional dex and modified them with the goal of making every fully-evolved mon have some level in viability in OU. This Pet Mod has a similar idea, but with the BW1 Unova dex.
In other words, the concept of this mod is to make a meta that has every fully evolved Unova mon available in BW, with each and all of the 79 mons available being a viable pick - be it a meta mon or just through some sort of unique niche.
The Dex
:leavanny::scolipede::crustle::escavalier::galvantula::accelgor::durant::volcarona::genesect:
:liepard::krookodile::scrafty::zoroark::bisharp::mandibuzz::hydreigon:
:haxorus::druddigon::hydreigon::reshiram::zekrom::kyurem:
:zebstrika::emolga::galvantula::eelektross::stunfisk::thundurus::zekrom:
*
:whimsicott:
:emboar::conkeldurr::throh::sawk::scrafty::mienshao::cobalion::terrakion::virizion::keldeo::meloetta-pirouette:
:victini::emboar::simisear::darmanitan::darmanitan-zen::chandelure::heatmor::volcarona::reshiram:
:unfezant::swoobat::sigilyph::archeops::swanna::emolga::braviary::mandibuzz::tornadus::thundurus::landorus:
:cofagrigus::jellicent::chandelure::golurk:
:serperior::simisage::leavanny::whimsicott::lilligant::maractus::sawsbuck::amoonguss::ferrothorn::virizion:
:excadrill::seismitoad::krookodile::stunfisk::golurk::landorus:
:vanilluxe::beartic::cryogonal::kyurem:
:watchog::stoutland::unfezant::audino::cinccino::sawsbuck::bouffalant::braviary::meloetta::meloetta-pirouette:
:scolipede::garbodor::amoonguss:
:victini::musharna::swoobat::darmanitan-zen::sigilyph::gothitelle::reuniclus::beheeyem::meloetta:
:gigalith::crustle::carracosta::archeops::terrakion:
:excadrill::escavalier::ferrothorn::klinklang::bisharp::durant::cobalion::genesect:
:samurott::simipour::seismitoad::basculin::basculin::carracosta::swanna::jellicent::alomomola::keldeo:
* There will still be some discussion on whether the Fairy-Type will be included or not. More on that later.
Do note that as this is using BW1 dex only, the Therian forms, Black/White Kyurem, Hisuian Forms and Kingambit don't exist for the format.
My idea for how these would work is to have th mons as their most recent iterations - So for instance Beartic would have 130 Atk and Slush Rush, Bisharp would lack Knock Off, etc. My issue with that is that not every mon has even made it out of Gen 7 yet - in specific, Serperior, Emboar, Watchog, the Simis, Leavanny, Zebstrika and Swanna are all absent from any switch games so they lack "modern" movepools. I'll wait til SV's DLC comes out to see if it rectifies this issue with at least some of these mons, but its very unlikely that all of them would return in the DLC.
As such, I have a list of mons that I believe stand out after some short discussion in the discord:
The Big Boys
Big OU Players
These are the Pokémon that most likely would not need many changes (if any at all) to be viable on day 1 meta. Tried to order from most likely to be good to most niche ones.
:bw/conkeldurr::bw/mandibuzz: :bw/ferrothorn: :bw/amoonguss::bw/excadrill::bw/bisharp::bw/mienshao:
Reasoning: self-explanatory
:bw/darmanitan::bw/chandelure:
Resoning: Very hard-hitting Fires on a meta with not many bulky Waters available. Darm is the better out of the two but I'd still expect both to be used.
:bw/jellicent:
Reasoning: Its one out of two Water mons with recovery available. Pretty bulky on its own right and has good utility in WoW and Strength Sap
:bw/thundurus:
Reasoning: Easily the best Electric available, very good typing + wide movepool. Might even be a bit too good with Plot, but we'll see.
:bw/tornadus:
Reasoning: Similarly, Tornadus is easily the strongest offensive Flying we have available. Relying on Hurricane is unfortunate though.
:bw/cobalion:
Reasoning: Good Rocks setter and Pivot, mostly
:bw/reuniclus:
Reasoning: Generally really bulky Psychic that can either be really sustainable with Regen or be a wallbreaking force with Life Orb. Might struggle with the presence of a decent amount of Darks running around though
:bw/zoroark:
Reasoning: Notably fast hard-hiting dark w plenty of coverage available. Not much depth to why i think this would be good, but it does share competition with Hydra.
:bw/durant:
Reasoning: Hits insanely hard and has great utility in First Impression, but Hustle is also fairly unreliable
:bw/gigalith::bw/vanilluxe:
Reasoning: Our only Weather Setters available, and while they both have downsides, they could potentially be really good enablers. Gigalith had the edge here as the Sand abusers available are much stronger than Snow's, but I think both could end up seeing play.
:bw/galvantula:
Reasoning: Our second best Electric available, believe it or not. Nowhere as relevant as Thundy, but I believe Sticky Webs already gives it a valuable niche.
Miscelaneous stuff that I think could be easily viable with a few buffs
:bw/seismitoad::bw/beartic::bw/krookodile::bw/escavalier::bw/accelgor::bw/scolipede::bw/serperior:
Just some mons that I feel wouldn't need that much of a major rework to be made viable, rather just some small tweakings
Potential Nerf Radar
:bw/Haxorus::bw/hydreigon:
Reasoning: Whether Fairies are real or not, Offensive Dragons are a very strong presence in this meta. There are not many Dragon resists - Other than Whimsicott, only really Steels take them on (and even so, the only Steel with recovery is Ferrothorn and both of these mons get coverage to hit most Steels very hard). Both of them may be on the nerf watchlist.
:bw/excadrill:
Reasoning: This one depends entirely on how we wanna handle weather. If we do permaweather, Excadrill would need a nerf.
DEFINITELY on Nerf Radar
:bw/genesect::bw/landorus::bw/kyurem:
Reasoning: lmao
:bw/volcarona:
Reasoning: Shortage of bulky Waters, no Heatran and generally not many bulky Fires either
:bw/terrakion:
Reasoning: Genuinely cannot find a single mon that can safely switch into this dude
Now, of course this list may have some wrong takes - that's exactly why I'm posting this in the workshop afetrall, getting some discussion on how this would work out is important. That said, though, I do have a few other questions for the community:
- Most importantly,
how should we handle the mechanics? While discussing on Discord, there was the idea of it using the Gen 9 version of these mons (So their modern movepool, abilities and stats) but with Gen 5 Mechanics (Permaweather, Steel's resistance to Dakr and Ghost being kept, but still use Gen 9's data for moves and abilities). This is what I most need feedback on as its the entire basis for the mod.
-
Should Gems be allowed? They would make sense for a BW mod but they're annoying to play around and I don't like them
- Right now, the plan is to have every mon in the dex, incluiding legendaries, as well as alternate forms such as Basculin's, Meloetta's and Darmanitan's available as genuinely viable options, with the only exceptions being Zekrom, Reshiram and Kyurem. Should any other mon be left aside for this?
- how in the everloving crispy hell are we going to make watchog have a niche??
- As this is a Gen 5 mod,
should we even have the Fairy type? Only a single mon has it and its otherwise exclusive to coverage, which I think makes for an interesting but weird scenario.
- Might be repeating myself here, but generally speaking, what should we keep from current gens and what should we axe? Should the mod have Terrains? Fairy Type? Old Steel resists? All of this is valuable discussion as this meta will essentially mix Gen 9's mechanics with some of Gen 5's - Figuring out what we should use for each of them is the hard part that i'm asking for help with here