OM! said:I never see a Lapras defending a gym... Stone Edge and other type weaknesses/neutralities that Vaporeon do not have hinder it, regardless of CP
Many people would use multiples of the same top 5 than Go all the way down to # 10th best...
If you think it's too much to power up Donphan, isn't Lapras even rarer? How hard is it to power it up if you cannot get candy very often? Walking? Not efficient, may as well catch a common Eevee and pray for Vaporeon when you evolve it. Donphan at least has Fairy moves to take on Dragonite and Counter to hit Snorlax and Blissey and Rhydon. Lapras is hard to use against Snorlax, Blissey and Rhydon with Stone Edge.
Sure, if by pure water you mean Water as the only type. The other waters being compared are Gyarados and Lapras, which are 2 types. Gyarados has much higher Attack and can hit Vaporeon with neutral Dragon moves, (helping mitigate Vaporeon's superior bulk and Vaporeon's resisted Water moves off of a lower Attack Stat).
Lapras puts up a fight against Vaporeon, as Blizzard is hard to dodge, but Vaporeon can out CP it, which means a max Vaporeon vs a max Lapras will win in battle because the difference of 600 CP is noticeable when it includes higher Defense.
Anyways, Lapras was good for the sole purpose of Dragonite, it still had to be wary of Rhyperior's Stone Edge (something Vaporeon doesn't worry about), and was countered by the same Fighting Pokémon that plagued Snorlax (Machamp). I agree, it was a good Dragonite killer, but Vaporeon did everything else much better, and Gyarados can handle Dragonite with its own Dragon moves. Even legacy move Gyarados with Dragon Breathe and Dragon Pulse was often enough for Gyarados to take on Dragonite.
Lapras has 1 purpose, Gyarados and even Rhydon (Stone Edge) can take on Dragonite, while also handling other Pokémon
P.S. I never see Slowking or Steelix, both are easy to deal with as Slowking gets handled by Tyranitar/Gyarados with Bite/Crunch, while Steelix is hurt by Gyarados (like a perfect counter as it resists the STAB moves and packs Hydro Pump), and Vaporeon as well.
Lapras is okay Vs Steelix if it can get the Water Gun/Hydro Pump moveset, but it takes neutral from its Steel moves, and at that point why not just use Vaporeon?
I would rather have a gym of 10 max Blisseys than a gym of 10 max Tyranitars for my color team. A challenger can use so many Pokémon to handle Tyranitar, including Vaporeon, Rhydon, Donphan, Gyarados, etc. but Blissey takes so much time that the counter may run out. My gym would last longer with Blisseys and that's why Blissey is the benchmark.
While Lapras used to be good at Dragonite, Machamp and Heracross are good at Blissey and Snorlax, and typically are used because she is mandatory to take down.
Not sure why everything I said flew over your head, but...
Lapras
as a raw defender is good. It's top 10 statistically, and you can go run the tests yourself and see all the data on that if you want (this is where I also group Steelix, Slowbro/king, who suffer the same issue). Its CP is too low (as with the others) for the current meta, which means it will never place. This is the biggest issue with it.
CP means nothing in combat except in gym placement, so I'm not sure why you mention it as if a Pokemon with a huge CP difference is going to change anything. A maxed out Umbreon takes many more hits than a maxed out Dragonite despite the gargantuan 1000+ CP difference. In the same vein, Lapras's CP means fuck all when it is (once again, statistically) the best Dragonite stack killer in the game. You can use the aforementioned Pokemon (Gyarados and Rhydon) to tackle a variety of Pokemon, this is true, but Lapras' niche and specialty comes in killing Dragonite
stacks, which Gyarados and Rhydon can do but will ultimately die faster than Lapras will. Most top players that value their Potions will assuredly have a Lapras to murder these gyms in minutes.
I understand that Blissey IS the best Pokemon in the game defensively (and the most Potion efficient Pokemon offensively), but go take a look at evolved gym metas in places with many high level players. I guarantee you that you will not see Blissey, for the entry barrier of gyms is 3300+ and this is Dragonite / Tyranitar territory. They are easy gyms to kill, no doubt, but it means nothing when the current purpose of gym stacking is for players to cash out (rather than build sturdy gyms), and thus anything with a lower CP than the pseudos will be purged out. Hence why Vaporeon is the benchmark.
OM! said:How do you tell what level a trainer in a gym is?
I would say as long as you routinely beat a Blissey before the counter or before Blissey beats you (Dazzling Gleam is a powerful move when super effective), then that's all that matters.
I have even struggled to get my 100 IV Vaporeon to face Blissey before the counter expires. Sometimes it takes multiple Dragonites or Tyranitars over 3,100 because Dazzling Gleam hits hard. Dodging can't be done 100% of the time, and it shows!
Does Mahamp typically get the job done? If so, then that's all you really need, although I cannot wait for a damn Blaziken!
Tell me if you can face my best defender:
The Trainer Level is behind the trainer name.
The best Blissey killers are 1) the Fighters (Machamp and the inferior Heracross) who do it quickly but take a lot of damage and 2) the raw DPS people (Dragonite and Tyranitar mainly) who beat Blissey much more slowly but end up with more health and being able to take on Blissey stacks better than the Fighting-types can. Vaporeon does ok as well but you run the risk of timing out with it.
Broken image btw