• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

Shane the Shroomish said:
yeah, sorry for falling off so hard, i joined a mafia game when i had covid and as soon as i went back to work for the first time (yday) the my motivation dropped like a brick

i have a few hours right now to find who i'm going to to vote for going into EoD, i can field some questions, otherwise i'm just going to be reading
Click to expand...

mostly me problem with you is your self solving dropping off etc, if that's to due to irl that sucks, but best way to increase your read in my head is having a good catch up or w/e independently since I don't feel like you're someone who's going to be easily "caught out" in a live posting back and forth period
 
Duskfall98 said:
mostly me problem with you is your self solving dropping off etc, if that's to due to irl that sucks, but best way to increase your read in my head is having a good catch up or w/e independently since I don't feel like you're someone who's going to be easily "caught out" in a live posting back and forth period
Click to expand...
i was still engaged at the start of d2 and any drop off in solving compared to d1 is just naturally how it is for me, once i have a worldview d1 it needs to get shaken up by some flips for me to be able to reassess anything

the flips that we got were both very inconsequential and this just feels like the continuation of a d1 i already played with a bit more mechanical information and i'm just waiting for the ball to drop

it's unlikely i do a lot more work right now other than decide who i'm voting

and on that, i'm trying to locate the current vote count
 
Duskfall98 said:
higher level scum play does normally have more townreads, than lower level scum play who can tmi their teammates, ro rely on distancing ad a crutch

idt it's impossible for people to be partnered together just because they townread each other
Click to expand...
Yeah, I just kinda doubt that ALL 3 would do basically the exact same thing in that regard, y'know?
 
##Vote Celever
i have my doubts on genisu and bluedoom voiced them kinda well, he's one of my strongest townreads so as long as he doesn't want to vote genisu i also don't want to do that

i could also move to AF depending on what's more likely to go over, think i want to be voting in celever/AF
 
Duskfall98 said:
laurel, I personally do think Joey's role can be mafia but I'm curious

you are someone who tries to angle clears based on roles right, you think your role was obviously town for example

do you think Joey's role is not towny?
Click to expand...

i think joey’s role is implicitly town if he is telling the truth. but i think there is a possibility he used an ability that was actually hooked by m2h and he’s covering it up.
 
Shane the Shroomish said:
yeah, and she took something i said into account for one of her reads list, i generally think she was legitimately sideways about saber dying, and i just don't really get any bad vibes in there

she's low activity in thread but not sure what she's done to really warrant a vote
Click to expand...

I'm struggling to find a good vote rn, so it's more who has not done something to warrant living than who has done something to die for me
 
M2H said:
Neon: Seemed to agree with me on Neon being town if he copies town roles even saying he would never vote that on role if confirmed, but disagreed on HH being similarly clear on role. To be clear Shane the Shroomish, do you still town core Neon for that? Why is backup a good enough reason to clear somebody, but a revealed mayor is not. The resistance on setup spec from others such as Celever read as a more principled stance against absolutism than yours, to my eyes.
Click to expand...
i think his role is likely to be town, and i linked you a game where i've seen a scum doublevoter recently, so i am unsure what the confusion is here

i've never said that he's 100% ride or die confirmed town to me but i generally agreed with your assessment that that role is very likely to be villa, independent of some major information incriminating him i don't see myself voting there, i think that's pretty simple
 
Duskfall98 said:
who are you happy seeing die here?
Click to expand...
af/laurel/hh tbh

af hasn't even voted one of shane/cel despite saying that there's 1 scum in there so I have no idea what she's been doing this phase and is hard for me to read here.

laurel just feels likely in a world where all the wagons in D1 were town. and tbh I'm trusting your read there since it seems like you've read laurel correctly.

hh I probably feel the strongest about; the guy doesn't say a lot of words but I can tell he's a solvey guy, and he hasn't done that this game. I didn't see any reads from him LD1, he thought of doing wagonomics on EoD1 and never followed up on it, he wanted to flip one shane/celever and then went from that to wanting to flip me/jalmont and then went to wanting to flip Alice...and I just don't understand the line of reasoning here.
 
*it seems like you've read laurel correctly before consistently

I'm unsure on genisu/Alice/Neon but I wouldn't oppose wagons on them. I have the opposite problem to you where I feel like there are many reasons to scumread/not townread people here, which isn't a good thing lol
 
a fairy said:
would it do your heart good if i placed a meaningless vote on celever. it's just as valuable as an unplaced vote bc it's got a good chance of moving
Click to expand...

is there a reason why you’re trying less than usual? Like it feels consistent to your usual tone but you usually make a few solid posts, i’ve seen none this game
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top