-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon NOCfia DX
- Thread starter SB.
- Start date
major story spoilers, but I've been reading all about team meanies here https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Team_Meanies
gengar is actually a human?
honestly
I think one major incongruity is your relationship to team meanie. First you say team meanie has to be town,then you say there's a 5% gengar isn't town, and now you phrase it like gengar is very likely not town. I don't really know wut's going on.
Can you clarify / paraphrase your role PM's flavor? Don't want to be suspicious of you for much longer so I'd prefer things just are made more clear sooner than later.
Host aren't supposed to give Townies info except in specific regulated circumstances. Being a VT is not one of those circumstances. This is why the 5% is not longer a consideration to me. It's not just about thinking Caff is Town, it's about thinking SB wouldn't make this kind of mistake.
so then why are you doubting caff now? or am I misreading that?
I'm not doubting him. Caff is in my Towncore.
It's not. Both scum Role PMs mention Squirtle.
Panic makes a fair argument about TBZ and Fenrir. So if that's the case, then either Heal, Lrr or Schia is lying about their role. And out of the three of them, Schia to me seems the most suspicious, so...
##Unvote
##Vote: Schiavetto
So far nobody in ACT has said if their role PM mentions other ACT members. That detail hasn't been considered relevant before now, whereas my role PM became relevant when Caff claimed. Most people aren't going to get this reference, but it's kinda like the MU game hosted by catgode where I hard defended the Town Miller Gladiator because I knew catgode has used the role before. When something becomes relevant, don't just keep it under your hat.
Thunder~BALLZ Schiavetto could confirm now if there's a similar namedrop in thier own PMs.
~~~~~
I was trying to parse through info earlier. Particular the points where 1) it looked like there was some symmetry between roles that I would totally be tempted to do as a host myself because it'd be aesthetically pleasing and 2) when Schia took that thought and flipped it one it's head by breaking the symmetry with her claim.
Thunder~BALLZ Schiavetto could confirm now if there's a similar namedrop in thier own PMs.
~~~~~
I was trying to parse through info earlier. Particular the points where 1) it looked like there was some symmetry between roles that I would totally be tempted to do as a host myself because it'd be aesthetically pleasing and 2) when Schia took that thought and flipped it one it's head by breaking the symmetry with her claim.
you realize that I specifically said the only TOWN role pm, right?
Oops lol, missed that part.
A pokemon is mentioned in my Role PM other than my own, but it's not any that have been claimed.
Well, which mon is it?
You don't get to do this without engaging with anything outlined in my previous post, btw.
Groudon.
Okay, I'm gonna be a hypocrite and look at the wiki Heal linked like I said I wouldn't.
Groudon is not part of the town square, so no one can really be groudon. hrmm
Yeah, it's a big part of my initial (annoyance? skepticism?) with the flavor claiming
I assume Groudon comes after the Fugitives arc? The ACT wiki page seems to suggest as much.
What if SB decided to solve issues with flavor by giving people flavor details that aren't relevant until later in the game...
Yes, you don't fight Groudon until you manage to clear your name. So why Schia's PM would mention Groudon is sus as all hell.
Apparently Tyranitar isn’t as cool of a leader as Alakazam but is less of a goon than Charizard