NOC Rand+++ Mafia [GAME OVER | Zombies/Jester/Lyncher/Survivor Win]

[M2H]

When were you wrong before?

d6 where i was right and then backtracked you to null.

 

[Tommy]

but also being dissapointed bc dusk was my biggest tr

This progression is awful but Mewtwo is still town

 

[M2H]

and then DS vig shot me even though he admitted that I obvtowned

 

[Tommy]

tbh this is a slip the way its worded though. Texas says if Dusk's alignment informed him, he would have enough information to scum read Texas.

Oh nice go mewtwo

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

tbh this is a slip the way its worded though. Texas says if Dusk's alignment informed him, he would have enough information to scum read Texas.

What?

 

[Tommy]

and then DS vig shot me even though he admitted that I obvtowned

You would've just been mislynched the next day though so he still saved a mislynch

 

[M2H]

ugh dusk why did your tone have to become so bad all of a sudden lmao

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

ugh dusk why did your tone have to become so bad all of a sudden lmao

I'm trying to follow your logic and it makes no sense

 

[Tommy]

ugh dusk why did your tone have to become so bad all of a sudden lmao

Because I don't care about my tone you'll know I'm town by the fact I'm lynching scum

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

You are the scum dumbass

 

[M2H]

You simply don't have enough information to form a scum read on me based on your thought process except when your alignment informs you of mine.

if duskfall was scum and you were town then how would more information allow dusk to form a scum read on you?

 

[M2H]

if dusk were town then wouldn't his alignment inform him that you are... town?

 

[Tommy]

Tbf not the first time Texas has hard slipped

 

[M2H]

unvote

for now

 

[Tommy]

One time he posted a readslist with his partners in red text and no one noticed lmao

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

if duskfall was scum and you were town then how would more information allow dusk to form a scum read on you?

That question doesn't make sense, my statement is a proof negative, because he doesn't have enough information to form a scum read on me as town he must be informed of my alignment via being scum

 

[M2H]

That question doesn't make sense, my statement is a proof negative, because he doesn't have enough information to form a scum read on me as town he must be informed of my alignment via being scum

but your statement directly infers that if duskfall were informed of your alignment, he would be able to form a scum read on you.

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

There is no slip here, this is just twisting an interpretation with scum dusk egging you on

 

[Tommy]

That question doesn't make sense, my statement is a proof negative, because he doesn't have enough information to form a scum read on me as town he must be informed of my alignment via being scum

You're saying my read on you only works if I'm scum insinuating it's right. You aren't saying I'm wrong, you are saying my path to find out your allignment is incorrect.

 

[M2H]

your statement makes sense if you substituted "town read" for "scum read" but as it stands ig I can see how its a slip even if I'm not sold on it being a slip myself.

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

but your statement directly infers that if duskfall were informed of your alignment, he would be able to form a scum read on you.

That statement doesn't make sense! You can't form a read on someone whose alignment you know!

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

your statement makes sense if you substituted "town read" for "scum read" but as it stands ig I can see how its a slip even if I'm not sold on it being a slip myself.

Do you also see how this is a classic scum tactic? Picking at one questionably ambiguous part of an argument to straw man the whole?

 

[Tommy]

Texas Cloverleaf how am I forming a read too early on you when you posted a read on asek way earlier than I did on you?

Do you not see the contradiction?

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

Texas Cloverleaf how am I forming a read too early on you when you posted a read on asek way earlier than I did on you?

Do you not see the contradiction?

There is no fucking contradiction dipshit, I am not you and the same standard does not apply to us both

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

There are 3-5 games of town you developing a read on town me and in every single case your approach to building a read on me does not match what you've done in this game.

This does not in any way relate to or contradict my having a specific piece of metal information on asek that informs a clear read.