Obviously biased as a gen 8 main, but I'd like to chime in on why I think SM/SS should be added to RoAPL.
As mentioned by goldmason, RoAPL is supposed to be a team tournament that rewards oldgen players for doing well in their respective gen PLs (or circuit even though it was not mentioned), and I think it can fill that very niche for SM/SS even with the team tour representation they have that others have brought up. Larry mentioned Masters League as an example of how the Masters gens have their own team tour that approximates RoAPL, but this tournament is actually meant be a league for players a couple of rungs down from what RoAPL targets (take a look at the signup restrictions to see what I mean). Also saw a lot of OUPL mentions and I think that tournament has been stronger than than the level of players that people in this thread want the tournament to reward - last year's edition had 4 players who started in SS OU for SPL this year (Hayburner, Ox the Fox, SpookyZ and ChrisPBacon) and Fc + Eternal Spirit who started in 2024 playing in the SS slots with other fairly entrenched/established players like Yone/emforbes/QWILY/Suzuya/etc filling out the rest of the cast. The up-and-coming circuit/gen PL enjoyer who's looking to make the next step after some good results is almost certainly not going to get the chance to spread their wings with this tournament. RoAPL would be a real opportunity for players who've shown some results but aren't particularly entrenched in the tournament scene to potentially get exposure, or at the very least build connections of their own for future team tournaments.
Also somewhat confused as to why people think that SM/SS having more representation on team tournaments that are either organised by the relevant RoA subforums themselves/held in other subforums means that they have the right to exclude them out of RoAPL. There is nothing stopping the classic gen RoA subforums from forming a Masters League of their own or to lobby for classic gen representation in side PLs: I recently organised CNPL and it involved ADV/DPP/BW with the possibility of adding RBY/GSC in the future due to feedback from classic gen players that I know - do something if you want representation elsewhere! Like it or not, SM and SS are members of RoA and popular vote does not mean that minority rights can be infringed upon - the RoA community/hosts have a responsibility to ensure that the PL for the RoA community has sufficient representation for all RoA gens. Whether is that done by creating another PL organised and backed (in terms of the CA prize) by the RoA forum to represent fairygens or including SM/SS in RoAPL can be discussed, but since RoAPL is likely the only PL designed to represent oldgens by the RoA subforum this year, I would strongly urge RoA staff to add them to the tournament this year.
Note: no particular comments on how to exactly implement adding SM/SS to RoAPL, but suggestions from MANNAT and violet river seem pretty palatable to me.
As mentioned by goldmason, RoAPL is supposed to be a team tournament that rewards oldgen players for doing well in their respective gen PLs (or circuit even though it was not mentioned), and I think it can fill that very niche for SM/SS even with the team tour representation they have that others have brought up. Larry mentioned Masters League as an example of how the Masters gens have their own team tour that approximates RoAPL, but this tournament is actually meant be a league for players a couple of rungs down from what RoAPL targets (take a look at the signup restrictions to see what I mean). Also saw a lot of OUPL mentions and I think that tournament has been stronger than than the level of players that people in this thread want the tournament to reward - last year's edition had 4 players who started in SS OU for SPL this year (Hayburner, Ox the Fox, SpookyZ and ChrisPBacon) and Fc + Eternal Spirit who started in 2024 playing in the SS slots with other fairly entrenched/established players like Yone/emforbes/QWILY/Suzuya/etc filling out the rest of the cast. The up-and-coming circuit/gen PL enjoyer who's looking to make the next step after some good results is almost certainly not going to get the chance to spread their wings with this tournament. RoAPL would be a real opportunity for players who've shown some results but aren't particularly entrenched in the tournament scene to potentially get exposure, or at the very least build connections of their own for future team tournaments.
Also somewhat confused as to why people think that SM/SS having more representation on team tournaments that are either organised by the relevant RoA subforums themselves/held in other subforums means that they have the right to exclude them out of RoAPL. There is nothing stopping the classic gen RoA subforums from forming a Masters League of their own or to lobby for classic gen representation in side PLs: I recently organised CNPL and it involved ADV/DPP/BW with the possibility of adding RBY/GSC in the future due to feedback from classic gen players that I know - do something if you want representation elsewhere! Like it or not, SM and SS are members of RoA and popular vote does not mean that minority rights can be infringed upon - the RoA community/hosts have a responsibility to ensure that the PL for the RoA community has sufficient representation for all RoA gens. Whether is that done by creating another PL organised and backed (in terms of the CA prize) by the RoA forum to represent fairygens or including SM/SS in RoAPL can be discussed, but since RoAPL is likely the only PL designed to represent oldgens by the RoA subforum this year, I would strongly urge RoA staff to add them to the tournament this year.
Note: no particular comments on how to exactly implement adding SM/SS to RoAPL, but suggestions from MANNAT and violet river seem pretty palatable to me.
Last edited: