Hi
Leeum8, I'm one of the people who helps design the Random Doubles sets.
In case you weren't previously aware, Smogon has its own 6v6 doubles format known as
Doubles OU. It's existed since around 2012 and became official on the release of X and Y, and I've been playing that format since just about the beginning. Additionally, I'm an active VGC competitor - money has limited my ability to play in majors for a long time, but I attended three regionals this season (with a day 2 at Pittsburgh), and I've also attended a regional in each of 2015, 2016, and 2017.
Leeum8 said:i think giving it inner focus would be much better bc it makes them a fake out pokemon that is immune to fake out itself (and intimidate obv). plus its already so frail that the regen health doesnt matter that much if at all, plus it frees up its item slot so that it can run something like sash instead of clear amulet... which it already kinda has as part of its secondary ability with a flinch immunity to boot so why not just use that
I like Regenerator Mienshao; it just does a thing I really enjoy. With that said, I'll keep my ears open and ask some more people how they feel about Regen/IF roll versus Inner Focus hard code.
Focus Sash is a tricky subject, and it mostly has to do with how all random battles are coded. Currently, sets are built into roles that define what items they can get and how their moves are determined; you can read about the role system
here. Currently, no roles will naturally generate Focus Sash - but there are a few other items that will generate that aren't naturally generated by roles. All of those items have specific rules that govern when they show up. For example, Clear Amulet will show up on Dragon Dance users and on some offensive Fake Out users when they aren't leads. Magnet will generate with enough Electric moves, and Mystic Water will generate with enough Water moves - you're going to see these particularly on Regieleki and Palafin, but these rules will extend to other Pokemon that meet the conditions. (Off the top of my head, I think Basculin will also generate Mystic Water, but I'd have to check.)
Focus Sash is a tricky one because the Pokemon that would really like Sash do a bunch of different things. You have your fast Fake Out users like Sneasler and Salazzle who might want it for one reason, then you have Chien-Pao who likes it for other reasons, and then Breloom, and then some Glimmora sets but not all of them... it's difficult to find a one-size-fits-all rule for Focus Sash, so for now, it mostly just doesn't exist. Currently the rules for Focus Sash look like this:
Hide
Glimmora without Meteor Beam will always generate Focus Sash.
Any generated set with the Doubles Fast Attacker, Doubles Wallbreaker, or Offensive Protect role will generate Focus Sash if it is in the lead slot, the total of its base HP, Defense, and Special Defense stats is under 230, and another item rule does not overwrite Sash. Sash almost always replaces Life Orb in these instances.
With natural generation and special rules out of the way, that leaves hard coding it onto Pokemon. Random Battles of all types try to avoid hardcoding when possible. They make the formats more difficult to learn for new players and they make code maintenance more difficult on the programming side. Hardcodes are a powerful tool, but we try to use them sparingly. Without a clean rule for general Focus Sash implementation, the only way to get Sash on everything that might want it would be a slew of hardcodes, which we simply don't want to do. Even Glimmora's Sash rule is tucked neatly into the conditional Sash implementation.
While we're here, there are some other coding intricacies that make certain sets incredibly difficult to design without hardcodes that are specific to sets, which is even more awkward than species hardcodes, if not downright impossible.
Sapphire and I tried to argue for the inclusion of Choice Band Tera Blast Arcanine-H for literal days before finally backing down and understanding that it more or less could not be done; the same applies to a set like Scarf Tera Blast Lando-T. There are a few other things that the existing code can make awkward, but we occasionally find ways around them by splitting one set of six moves into two or three sets of four moves each, for example; roles allow for a fair bit of flexibility by design.
Leeum8 said:i just mean that you take a singles approach to some of these sets when you build them
I am loud and annoying and literally will not let this happen.
We do occasionally borrow some things from singles though. For example, if you've ever rolled Assault Vest Grafaiai, that's a set pulled from random singles that's proven to be good enough to keep around. It's not stellar, but honestly, neither is non-AV Grafaiai.
Leeum8 said:i think you should remove hazards outright from every set
This is where the Doubles OU part comes in - hazards are good in DOU! Turns out that even if you don't switch very much, more Pokemon means more hazards damage over the course of a game. I'm feeling lazy, so I'll just copy paste what I said earlier in the development channel:
Hide
(responding to Celever proposing removing Spikes from Ting-Lu)
[5:32 PM]Arcticblast: Spikes Ting-Lu is one of its best DOU sets and that’s not really a meta thing so much as “it is a big lunk who gets free turns just by existing”
[5:32 PM]Arcticblast: I think hazards both here and in DOU are like
[5:32 PM]Arcticblast: actually let me make this a complete sentence
[5:32 PM]Arcticblast: Hazards are good
[5:33 PM]Arcticblast: Having hazards can often make a significant difference in a game
[5:33 PM]Arcticblast: However, they aren’t so singularly good that you include a hazard setter on every team, and outside of a couple Pokémon who can (sometimes!) free roll removal, you don’t really bother with hazard removal unless things are really dire
[5:34 PM]Arcticblast: like if you’re playing SM or NatDex and you want to use Zard Y
[5:38 PM]Arcticblast: Stealth Rock is great! Spikes are still pretty good! Neither are necessary, and not every Pokemon capable of using hazards actually wants to do so on every set
One of our goals on the dev team is to keep the frequency of entry hazards relatively low. However, we - or at least I - do feel that hazards have a place in the format. My personal goal is to keep hazards on the sets where they feel like a good addition, and remove it from sets where they feel forced. Hazards should be good to have but not imperative to click every game.
With that said, we can't really ignore Sticky Web when talking about hazards. Sticky Web can occasionally win or lose a game on the spot (if you've ever loaded lead Galvantula into a Kingambit or Slowbro, you'll know what I mean), but it's also really the only thing a select few Pokemon have going for them.
Please don't take away Kricketune's webs, they're all he has :(
Leeum8 said:and give every pokemon that does not have a choice item have a chance to have protect, if that is not doable bc of the randomization algorithm i understand but that is my suggestion
Like the reduction of hazards, one of our goals with the format is to increase the rate of Protect. It's something we've been slowly working on as the generation plays out; if you looked at the set list when we first made it and compared it to now, you'll see that the rate of Protect-enforced roles has gone up, and the rate of Protect on non-enforced roles has also increased (though a little bit less so). There are a number of situations where I would not want to give a Pokemon Protect, however:
- Pokemon whose only sets are Choiced or Assault Vest. A lot of Pokemon that can roll Choice items or Assault Vest will also have Protect sets available, but sometimes we get something as consistently good as Specs Inteleon and decide not to mess with a good thing.
- Screens setters. They have two slots dedicated to Reflect and Light Screen already, so their other moves need to pull some weight.
- Pokemon who always have Fake Out, or other forms of turn disruption like redirection or fast Encore. One of the goals of Protect on a set is to let you disrupt an opponent's turn; other ways to prevent moves can sometimes prove just as strong. Some of these Pokemon already forgo Protect in DOU or VGC; if someone tells you to run Protect on Incineroar, you're probably not listening to them.
- Trick Room setters. These Pokemon often drop Protect already in traditional formats. While many of them would be better off with Protect or with higher odds of Protect, it isn't strictly necessary on them, and removing it from the set allows for greater freedom in set design and technical implementation. Porygon2 is one of my favorite examples; that Pokemon has been dropping Protect for years now and it has stood the test of time.
- Support Pokemon with a variety of moves. This overlaps a lot with the last two categories because they tend to have speed control or disruption. Volbeat and Illumise both sit near the top of the format because they have Prankster Tailwind and Encore, for example.
- Pokemon whose sets are so powerful that they don't need Protect. Think of something like Registeel - the existing set of Body Press / Iron Defense / Iron Head / Thunder Wave is already really good; Protect on any slot here would probably just make it worse. (Registeel usually dropped Protect in Reg F and does so in DOU anyway.)
- Pokemon who are so bad that they can't afford Protect. There's only so much we can do for Pokemon like Blissey and Delibird; giving them four useful moves is the way to make them feel a little better. Fortunately, these Pokemon are few in number.
As previously stated by Cake and Celever, if you have suggestions for Pokemon that don't have Protect and should, or Pokemon that can sometimes roll Protect but should have it enforced, please let us know.
Leeum8 said:this is fair, obviously you cant rip the sets straight off of pikalytics, but i think it can be used as a good blueprint to see whats good for certain pokemon to run.
Celever mostly covered this, but I want to reinforce it too: VGC (and DOU) is a metagame. You can expect to play certain Pokemon more than others, and the choices you make are deliberate. Random Doubles is not. When I find a Random Doubles game, I can't predict what six Pokemon I'm about to face or the six I'm about to use. As a result, sets are designed to be stronger into as many things as they can, rather than geared towards specific threats. You'll generally see more coverage moves in Random Doubles than you'd consider putting into your teambuilder. Taunt Incineroar is great in Reg G, where you wall the dumb horses and can threaten Taunt into them or their partner, but I would rarely consider that in Reg F or DOU. Tera Ground Foul Play Farigiraf, Rocky Helmet Amoonguss, and Heavy Slam Iron Hands are more examples of things that are great in formats where you build your own team but don't translate well to a random format.
I hope I've conveyed some of the thought that goes into set design and why we don't just rips sets 1:1 from VGC. If you have any other questions or suggestions, you're welcome to post them here, or even find me on Showdown or Discord if you just want to talk about any of this stuff. (also play DOU, it's cool, we actually get to ban broken stuff and we can use cool mythicals like Diancie)