drampa's grandpa said:The case for Transform:
The council has been discussing Transform recently.
I personally strongly disagree with a Transform ban, and I am going to lay out why.
The tl;dr of this post:
-Transform is not broken.
-Transform does not let you pick your targets and as such it is entirely feasible to build and utilize counterplay to it on any team.
-Imposter is a terrible analogy for Transform in a competitive scene despite the mechanical similarities.
-If your team dies the first time its up against a bulkier version of one of your mons (as in, ANY of your mons, you get to pick) your team is probably bad. The occasional Hyper-Offense might be exempt from this, and these teams should be ready to stop Chansey on any individual turn.
And now megapost!
I will start with a couple assumptions and clarifications:
- Chansey and Blissey are the main abusers of this strategy. Other viable users exist but do essentially the same thing, just less devoted to the strategy and potentially with more surprise factor.
- Players are competent and aware of the possibility of Transform. This is obviously wrong in many cases but, as every tiering argument should, I am focusing on higher-leveled play.
- Transform is indeed a powerful move and nothing I say here should be taken to mean otherwise.
- There is no war in Ba Sing Se.
1) Imposter, and why Transform is nothing like it
Transform is rather mechanically similar to Imposter and as such naturally invites comparisons. However from a competitive standpoint they perform completely different roles.
Imposter is used both in standard tiers and in Balanced Hackmons as an anti-offensive tool. It reverses momentum, punishes run-away boosting, and in general acts as a way to instantly reverse the flow of a battle.
Transform requires two very important things that Imposter does not. First you need to start as the base Pokémon and second you need to spend a turn Transforming. These may seem to be the same thing, and mechanically they essentially are, but I will break down how they are different competitively and the different types of counterplay they provide.
The fact that you do not instantly Transform on switch-in and instead do it afterward means you do not determine what you Transform into. Your opponent has the opportunity to switch if they wish. Imposter in Balanced Hackmons is done on switch-in, meaning that your opponent has to be aware that they could be facing a Transformed version of themselves the next turn, any turn, no matter what is in. In Sketchmons you are forewarned by the presence of a Chansey or Blissey on the field, and are able to switch into whatever on your team you are able to deal with.
Chansey and Blissey (and every potential non-Prankster user of this strategy besides Mew, who would not be effected by a restriction) are slow. Because you need to spend the turn they are first in and capable of moving transforming they will likely be outsped and take a hit before they get their new bulk and / or power. This means they need to either tank an attack or risk a status move in their base form. Chansey and Blissey have notoriously weak physical defense, and are almost as notoriously Taunt bait. A large number of the Pokémon they would like to Transform into can either heavily dent them, potentially providing them with no way to recover before they come in again, outright KO them, set up a Substitute, or Taunt them. If they are already set up you will likely die instead of stealing their boosts because, you know, set up mon hit hard.
In short: Imposter steals momentum in situations Transform cannot.
Transform can occasionally gain momentum through forced switched, but for the most part the cost of using it is that it is a momentum drain.
2) What it would take for Transform to be broken
How can Transform potentially perform in the metagame to a broken extent, and why doesn't it do that:
There are four possible ways for Transform to be broken given current mechanics.
- The first, and most realistic, is by utilizing the 20 PP from every Transform in order to stall out the PP of the opposing Pokémon. Chansey and to a lesser extent Blissey are absurdly fat after Transforming into almost anything, and by stealing recovery PP, dealing damage, and forcing recovery on walls you otherwise could probably not, all while using 1 PP from your actual pool, you have a major leg up if the battle comes down to PP.
However the current fast pace of Sketchmons means that most battles do not go into PP stall, meaning that this potential issue has not arisen yet. It's also notable that it is perfectly possible to force Chansey to Transform into Pokemon with no Recovery, forcing it to take chip damage or remain in its
- The second, least discussed, and frankly most ridiculous is by acting as a scout. Sketchmons is a metagame based around non-static movepools, lures, and unpredictable sets, and you could argue that because Transform reveals the opponents moveset you are removing that element of the metagame putting the side using it at an unfair advantage. However this advantage, while certainly more useful than usual here, is not extreme.
While certainly an advantage it is a huge stretch to argue that knowing one of your opponents sets is unfair, particularly when 1) Sketch moves often get revealed as the battle goes on 2) Ditto can do this exact same thing with less risk and more momentum.
- The third is by stealing offensive power from offensive Pokemon. This has been the most discussed so far and is the primary reason the council is looking at it. By Transforming into offensive Pokémon you can threaten the opposing team without being immediately threatened yourself. Because of their absurd HP stats Chansey and Blissey will be able to 1v1 almost any offensive Pokemon they get the opportunity to Transform into.
However this complaint overlooks two key factors. First is that Transform users, as I said above, do not get to choose what they effect with Transform. They cannot choose to Transform into an offensive Pokemon, and if the opponent lets a Transform user turn into something that can break their team then that opponent made a tactical blunder, to put it mildly.
The second is that many offensive Pokemon have the capability of threatening Chansey. A Chansey that transforms after tanking a powerful hit is a Chansey that lost its main asset: its enormous HP pool.
The fact that this is the most discussed and alluded to issue comes out of the fact that we are looking at Transform too much like we do Imposter; as something to steal offensive momentum from the opponent by instantly replacing yourself with a superior version of the opponent, whether it be superior in power (Pikachu or Lucky Punch Chansey in BH), Speed (Choice Scarf Imposter in anything), or bulk (again Chansey). Transform cannot effectively or reliably provide counterplay to offensive Pokemon that the Transformer (robot in disguise) did not already counter.
- The fourth is through memes like Imprison-form and these honestly don't even warrant discussion.
Not to be rude, but you never had your physical attacker get 1v1'd by transform chans and it shows
Hi! I'm Don, leading cause of pleads to ban transform and high ladder player using a team that looks a bit like
this, and I believe that this post, at the very least, doesn't give Transform full credit for what it can do. Let's start with this:
Transform is more powerful than Drampa gives it credit for :chansey: :blissey:
drampa's grandpa said:The fact that you do not instantly Transform on switch-in and instead do it afterward means you do not determine what you Transform into.
While technically true, people don't throw a dice when deciding what mon to switch. Chansey and Blissey invite a certian type of crowd to switch into them: physical attackers. This mean to most of the time you can reliably predict what is coming, and while it doesnt mean you can instantly turn whatever is in front into a danger for your opponent, it does mean that you can plan ahead with transform. You can come in on a special attacker, force it out because you are Chansey, and where in normal play it would have meant that a physical attacker gets in and chansey gets a status off, a chance to heal, a bit of damage, rock, or to pivot out, Chansey can now turn the matchup on its head and become capable of at-worst, turn the matchup into a speed tie, but most commonly beating the opposing pokemon. Unlike the previously mentioned outcomes this is instantly and near universally threatening and has no inmunities or counterplay that arent running taunt/sub on every special attacker. You can send in something like excadrill that is inmunne to thunder wave and toxic, or just accept them and still be able to force out Chansey. You can stay on chansey instead of switching out when tries to pivot, racking up damage for the next time it tries to comeback. You can just accept that rocks are a part of the game and have your rock weak mons run boots.
To not get into a bad position due to Transform you have to just send a fairly non-threatening wall into Chans, which cant actually threaten Chans beyond knock off most of the time, and Chans use this forced switch to pivot out, all the while never being in much danger herself.
This is what makes Transform good:
it makes putting Chansey in danger hard.
Taunt and sub do reliably protect you from Transform, but taunt isnt a widely spread move, and Chansey can still seismic toss and break subs from most pokemon, even if they run max hp.
drampa's grandpa said:Chansey and Blissey have notoriously weak physical defense,
While partially true for Blissey, Eviolite Chansey has as much physical bulk as Weezing. Weezing is not notoriously frail. Chansey can somewhat take some physical attacks if they arent extremely strong such as:
252 Atk Excadrill Earthquake vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey: 223-264
(31.7 - 37.5%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
Fun fact: Excadrill can't reliably 1v1 Chansey without prior damage, a free turn to setup, or band, as chansey is capable of Transforming if excadrill tries to setup and turn the matchup into a speed tie
drampa's grandpa said:A large number of the Pokémon they would like to Transform into can either heavily dent them, potentially providing them with no way to recover before they come in again, outright KO them, set up a Substitute, or Taunt them. If they are already set up you will likely die instead of stealing their boosts because, you know, set up mon hit hard.
True for everything said here, but the bolded part should have a disclaimer: "Only applicable for physical attackers, Secret Sword users and Psyshock/Psystrike Psychic types)
Proof:
+2 252 SpA Thundurus-Therian Oblivion Wing vs. 248 HP / 8 SpD Eviolite Chansey: 180-213
(25.6 - 30.2%) -- guaranteed 4HKO
Highest SpA from all viable special mons and it barely does 30 at best at +2.
It might learn knock off and taunt, but my point still stands: being at +2 isn't enough to threaten Chansey.
Now onto another issues the meta has
Ghosts :gengar: :blacephalon:
Ghosts lack a reliable check in the current meta
Asstral Barrage is of course the poster boy for this issue, as it allows ghosts previously limited by the fact that they only 3hko and 2hko most of the meta to turns those 3hkos into 2hkos and those 2hkos into Ohkos. Bulk is no longer a reliable check to it. You need to use bulky checks such as: Tyranitar (the other darks are either not viable or not bulky enough), the blobs, and porygon 2 (only viable in TR). Those are the only viable mons that can take an Asstral Barrage without having their butts blown up. Now this would be already banworthy but you wont believe what little secret they have to tell you:
252 SpA Life Orb Gengar Secret Sword vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey: 322-380 (45.8 - 54%) --
44.9% chance to 2HKO
+2 252 SpA Life Orb Gengar Secret Sword vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey: 640-754 (91 - 107.2%) --
43.8% chance to OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Gengar Secret Sword vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Tyranitar: 447-530 (110.6 - 131.1%) --
guaranteed OHKO
252 SpA Blacephalon Secret Sword vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Tyranitar: 384-452 (95 - 111.8%) --
68.8% chance to OHKO
252 SpA Blacephalon Secret Sword vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Chansey: 410-484 (58.3 - 68.8%) --
guaranteed 2HKO
Nothings sacred in this meta.
As to what to ban? Tough choice. Asstral might be the easy one to point, but Secret Sword does make many more special attackers harder to deal with such as Volcarona
Urshifu :urshifu:
Urshifu has no reliable checks, you arent safe.
To even think of "reliably" checking urshifu you need a Fairy. Everything else can and will drop to a boosted CC or Wicked Blow. Fairies have a high chance of getting dropped by gunk shot, or a Poison jab if urshifu opted for a stronger boosting move such as SD or DD. Nothing comes close to the level of universal thread of ursh due to how broke Wicked Blow because is a 120 bp move inmune to all power dropping strats but burns. Urshifu could run a cartidge legal set and id still cause this situation. Please remove this from the meta.