ABR said:Since a lot of people keep posting about Zygarde and I was one of the main people pushing for it to stay A+, I'll offer my reasoning as to why I believe that.
While Zygarde is extremely splashable, it is simply not as good defensively or offensively as the other S rank mons. It isn't that scary of a breaker, and it certainly isn't hard to revenge kill. I don't think I need to tell anyone why CB is pretty easy to check, but I'll briefly list the reliable switchins to CB (mostly Thousand Arrows cuz outrage is hardly being clicked): Tangrowth, M-Bro, Defensive Lando (lefties preferably), M-Sciz, Bulu, M-Hera, Clefable, Mew, Alo, etc. CB isn't threatening enough by itself to warrant S, and it seems that most people are acknowledging this, but still see other sets like DD as making it S-worthy.
The thing with DD, however, is that it's still mostly checked by the same things defensively, and still easy to revenge. While Zygarde may end up killing something like Tangrowth at +2, this is a one time thing and it is still weakened in the process (like from hpice). So the tradeoff will involve something like using up a Z move once and ending up at 40%, only to not be threatening at all the remainder of the game. M-Bro will still fully beat it; Defensive Lando either beats it or does something similar to Tangrowth (but intims also), M-Sciz can get like 4 bullet punches off if it comes in on DD lol, Bulu obviously still beats it, both Clef sets beat it, Mew takes +1 drag-z and wisps/ibeams, Alo still toxics, and so on. Almost all of the checks to CB and DD overlap, so I don't get why you'd use the argument that scouting it's set is an impossible and important task - it's neither.
As for revengers themselves, there are the plentiful scarfers such as Latios, Greninja, Garchomp, and Lele that all revenge Zygarde with ease. And for CB sets, many pokemon like Zapdos also revenge very easily. Considering this, in addition to the aforementioned defensive counterplay, Zygarde just is not as threatening as people are making it out to be.
Now, if Zygarde is looked at in direct comparison to Lando/Magearna, it becomes even more evident why it shouldn't be S. Defensively, Landorus and Magearna are leagues better than Zygarde. Lando is a good check/counter to: Zard-X, Garchomp, Heracross, Marowak, Mawile, Mimikyu, Bulu, Tyranitar, Zygarde, and more. As for Magearna, the defensive utility of AV is pretty insane. It reasonably switches into: Zam, Clef, Gengar, both Grens, Hoopa, Kyurem, Latios, OTR/shift gearna, Mane, Nihilego, Lele, Koko, and so on. It even can volt on magma trans and take less than 45. Offensively speaking about these pokemon, there are probably 0 surefire counters to Lando besides M-Bro, Quagsire, and Skarmory (can still lose to smackdown sets). And for Magearna, both shift/otr are very powerful sets with about 3-4 possible z-moves, all hitting different targets. Mew is safe vs boltbeam fight-z, but loses to z-fleur. Heatrans safe vs the fleur set, but loses to fight-z. Celes is reasonable vs both of those, but fears elec-z. If anything requires multiple defensive answers and set scouting, it's Lando and Magearna, not Zygarde.
All in all, this pokemon just isn't on the same wavelength of potency as the current S rank mons.
i completely disagree with your reasoning
what makes zygarde S rank in my eyes is the fact that it combines both its offensive and defensive presence in one and always consistently puts in work no matter the match up. theres a variety of sets zygarde can run which necessitates different answers for it depending on the set which you're completely neglecting and so thats why i dont agree with the list of switch ins you specified
for instance you're referencing mega bro as a hard switch in to the CB set but if that doesnt have ice beam toxic + coil zygarde can just status it and then stall it out since scald cant even break its sub and you slowly die.... alomomola is clearly set up bait for the coil set... you actually dont even mention the coil set at all in your explanation which idk why since its one of its main iconic sets. mega hera may be a 1k arrow switch in but if it lacks SD and you're packing bulk (and not much speed) zygarde can just coil up and you actually struggle to break it with defense boosts. mega scizor is the shittiest answer to subcoil zygarde and if it lacks SD which a lot dont even carry nowadays its also set up bait as well. & obviously if we're talking about unaware clef it may wall dd/coil sets but MG ones actually fail to wall it considering moonblast doesnt even 2hko coil variants and then zygarde can still boost up and break past you. unaware does fine for the most part but if its CB and sr is up 1k arrows actually has a chance to 2hko that as well especially if theres some chip damage involved
now about your whole section about being able to revenge DD zygarde at +1/+1 this also fails to acknowledge the fact that you probably arent going to hard switch into your scarf latios/chomp/greninja/lele straight away since if its the prominent CB set all those mons get mauled. no, whats the most realistic scenario here? you're probably going to go into something like a tangrowth expecting CB/coil and then it reveals dragon dance. now, assuming its DD z-outrage, which btw only needs one boost to OHKO av tangrowth (
+1 252+ Atk Zygarde Devastating Drake (190 BP) vs. 252 HP / 4 Def Tangrowth: 349-412 (86.3 - 101.9%) -- 93.8% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock), it doesnt NEED to kill you right away, since zygardes bulky af and its a fucking tangrowth lol. it can just stay in, tank the HP ice which does laughable damage even with absolutely 0 bulk investment
(0 SpA Tangrowth Hidden Power Ice vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Zygarde: 196-232 (54.9 - 64.9%)), and then proceed to blow you back the next turn. now, your main 1k arrows switch in is dead, AND now you have a +2/+2 zygarde standing in front of you so your scarf latios/chomp/greninja/lele or whatever cant even RK it and you're fucked. i dont understand exactly how zygarde is easy to revenge kill when setting up isnt exactly hard at all considering zygardes natural bulk and plethora of resistances
also you're completely underselling all the defensive merits zygarde brings to a game while completely glorifying all of lando-t's & magearna's.... zygarde's natural excellent bulk and typing means it can be a defensive stop/check to a whole list of mons. for instance, its one of the most consistent and splashable switch ins to zard-y, it also deals with non hp ice volcarona easily while landorus-t obviously cant and gets roasted. the fire resistance actually helps a lot in comparison to landorus-t because it means its able to switch on the likes of heatran and marowak-alola much more easily and obviously threatens them both out. defensive coil ones can take on HP ices rather easily and so it can act as a halt to volt switching mons such as tapu koko & mega manectric. defensive coil zygarde is also an excellent and splashable switch in to gengar (we all know switch ins to that mon are incredibly rare to find), bisharp, mvenu, magnezone, nihilego, among others
zygarde can definitely compete with lando-t & magearna defensively, packs just as much versatility as them both which requires several answers to it, has significant breaking/cleaning power, and in general its just a top tier threat which exerts a lot of pressure in every game. it has transformed teambuilding as a whole and altered the metagame substantially enough and so i think a
rise to S rank is more than warranted