NOC Small Street Game Thread - Ended- TOWN wins!

[DS.]

we always lynch ds today, if he flips town that would speak strongly in favor of hannah being town
then you can go ahead and vote me if you want or whatever but this dude's never flipping town

I'll definitely want to go after csyager next atp

"If he flips town"

If the mod confirmed to you that i didnt have a bpv then why would you even posit on this?

 

[DS.]

Also see how Apricity conveniently flipped to town on Hannah as she's bout to be lynched

 

[MoodyCloud]

why would scum nk me if it gives town one more ml

 

[DS.]

Apricity/Jordan/Samoyed/Moody?

That's optimal I think?

 

[M2H]

okay quick case :
1. he has displayed an unreasonable amount of defensiveness when being called out as not doing much in the way of scumhunting, as well as when ds was being pushed
2. I do not really see how anyone can read the pages where I case DS a dozen times over and debunk his bs and come out thinking "stop harassing this poor townie"

3. After isoing cs I found that he had claimed to believe that DS/former was TvS around mid-day1
My first instinct would be to take this as unlikely to come from DS' teammate since he'd be implicating him rather heavily for seemingly no benefit
But then it has seemed like that implication had disappeared altogether when DS/former were locked in a 1v1 on day 2
And csyager was defending DS instead of pushing him after FH had flipped town, leading me to question whether his stated d1 read was really something he had believed in

I could go on and add his overall passivity, defensiveness and weird tone but I think there's already more than enough to warant him being in the poe

The biggest thing that makes me think DS./Hannah/CS is NOT a thing is the fact that DS openly and obviously communicates with those two in a way to try to pocket them. I don't think DS. openly implicates his partners when he's caught, unless its some kind of weird gambit.

For your points;

1. Yeah, CS has been really defensive and hasn't really contributed much. He gave that one weird really long post, got attacked for it, and after that hasn't really suggested much of substance. I don't see that as an issue in and of itself--he's new, so obviously he might be reluctant or have trouble making sense of what is going on. I know CS--he isn't the type to spend a lot of time analyzing the situation in a game like this. For the record, he has made posts suggesting various things, but they haven't made much coherent sense such as this;

I still think MoodyCloud is town. MoodyCloud has a very similar thought process to MewtwoHidden, but he is just more confident and aggressive, whereas MewtwoHidden is more laid back. I feel much more confident in voting someone relatively inactive, as we all agree that's where most of the scum are, and Nuxl is the only one who hasn't claimed.

2. This is your opinion, but its not really true. DS. is very convincing--even to me honestly. It makes sense that CS and Hannah would fall for it, and both of them come off very genuinely--Hannah to a lesser extent.

3. Ftr, CS renounced that opinion D1 after DS. and Former responded to him... for whatever reason. CS suggested that we shouldn't lynch DS because Hannah could clean DS--then CS started sheeping my Nuxl/Samo reads.

The weird tone you are hearing just sounds like extreme innocence to me

 

[apricity]

why would scum nk me if it gives town one more ml

they wouldn't. but that's what was being wack in my calculations

all right, so you're guaranteed to live then. you should lynch ds->jordan/cs in some order

and then you can decide between josh/drookez/sam

can we agree on the order of the first three lynches?

 

[MoodyCloud]

the truth of the matter is that we mislynched afk town two days in a row, lost one more to a godkill and then no lynched because people wouldn't agree to going after cs/jordan the day ds was 90% likely to have self targeted with governor

we are not out of the woods yet

 

[M2H]

eod1

bd and sb were both scummy town ftr. I wouldn't be surprised if DS. is just associating himself with town people on purpose so when he dies we mislynch people.

 

[apricity]

MewtwoHidden the fit that hannah threw is very towny

hannah, moody, jalmont all never get lynched this game ever, period the end.

 

[M2H]

the truth of the matter is that we mislynched afk town two days in a row, lost one more to a godkill and then no lynched because people wouldn't agree to going after cs/jordan the day ds was 90% likely to have self targeted with governor

we are not out of the woods yet

dont act like the no lynch wasn't your fault when you told hal to gladiate lmao.

 

[DS.]

Can't believe yall are actually buying this shit

 

[apricity]

lynching ds was correct there. you return to odds parity, and you guard against the disastrous scenarios of DS not actually using his self govern which would've literally just lost us the game

 

[MoodyCloud]

we are not in day 1 anymore you can't give a pass to shit with "they're new" as a reason and expect me to take them out of the poe

 

[MoodyCloud]

dont act like the no lynch wasn't your fault when you told hal to gladiate lmao.

you were literally going to lynch samoyed over ds at one point

 

[DS.]

Duskfall is confirming in pms that he would never confirm out my role so Hal is just blatantly lying about the question he asked

 

[apricity]

we are not in day 1 anymore you can't give a pass to shit with "they're new" as a reason and expect me to take them out of the poe

hey is there a reason you're ignoring me

 

[M2H]

you were literally going to lynch samoyed over ds at one point

In hindsight, wouldn't that have been the better decision?

 

[DS.]

you were literally going to lynch samoyed over ds at one point

still the best decision for town

 

[M2H]

Duskfall98 isn't answering that question by the way.

I c/p'ed exactly what hal posted here.

 

[MoodyCloud]

lynching someone else over ds would have been good assuming we could have agreed on lynching ds last, which we couldn't

 

[apricity]

if DS self governed AND received a BPV



would boyuer on DS get the result that he was targeted by two protective actions?


this is the exact phrasing of what i asked dusk to which the answer was yes

tommy's being a little bitch about semantics, try this phrasing

 

[MoodyCloud]

seems naive to take hannah out of the poe but I guess we don't have enough lynches so we'll have to ride or die hannah town

 

[MoodyCloud]

they wouldn't. but that's what was being wack in my calculations

all right, so you're guaranteed to live then. you should lynch ds->jordan/cs in some order

and then you can decide between josh/drookez/sam

can we agree on the order of the first three lynches?

ds =>cs=>jordan at the moment, I guess I would lynch josh before I lynch drookez/samoyed

 

[apricity]

seems naive to take hannah out of the poe but I guess we don't have enough lynches so we'll have to ride or die hannah town

hannah is 100% town here

the whole anger and sulking is in line with her personality and I don't think she's capable of faking anything close to this

 

[M2H]

lynching someone else over ds would have been good assuming we could have agreed on lynching ds last, which we couldn't

Literally the only people resisting were Hannah and Josh bc they wanted to confirm--and Josh could have confirmed whether DS. used govern or not so it would be fairly safe.

I was literally just talking to DS. in the forum, but I always had my vote on him or at the very least stayed unvoting.

You literally said there was a 90% chance DS. used his govern shot and yet you forced hal to gladiate him anyways--thats honestly a terrible decision.