-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Smalltown Hotel Mafia - Game Thread (MAFIA WINS)
- Thread starter CaffeineBoost
- Start date
saying that I "faked activity" is definitely you thinking I was maf at the time lol. don't bullshit
Reads atm
Town Tier:
skippergamez -- Far more content-filled ISO than I previously thought, and overall good vibes. Has been contributing pretty well actually. Gave a premature reads list that really wasn't thought through that well but this is a playstyle quirk Smogon is more anti than other spaces, and especially if we take him at his word that this is the most serious mafia game he's played I don't view that as too indicative. Everything else is good so far.
Townlean Tier:
Eli -- Good vibes, reasonably contributory. Eli is a pro at looking like town, though. Considering a large bulk of his own content is also commentary, don't love his push on me for doing the same thing that much lol.
LS -- Not as confident in this one because I actually think I just like LS' personality and that can def cloud my judgement, but I have found her to be useful in some of the more contentious and heated parts of the thread, attempting to provide some reason to things. Def posting on-meta, too, but I don't put that much stock into meta.
Tommy -- Bottom of townlean. Arguing with Psy is an effective way to accrue towncred at all times, but their other contributions to thread have also just been useful. Tommy is also just a pro at looking like town, though. Eager to see his reads.
Psy Tier:
Psy --
Neutral and Not Here Tier:
AG -- No AI content, really
realiti -- Is literally not here
Hydro -- No AI content, really
JALMONT -- Entirety of content is dissociative game theory stuff. Nothing to particularly read into alignment-wise at this stage.
Scumlean Tier:
apricity -- The skipper vote was really terrible. Threatening to gladiate over a self-admitted level-1 read is directly anti-town, especially one that was already debunked.
master oden -- Post quantity to content quantity ratio is dire. Probably do not gel with their playstyle at all considering Tommy said the crazy amount of defensiveness to a single vote is typical of them, but if they don't want that to happen they need to contribute more.
Maf Tier:
M24 -- Absolutely no progression this game to the extent that it is a negative amount of progression. Tiny content quantity so this is still entirely malleable, but when they have come in and made posts it's been largely irrelevant to threadstate (meaning they won't get picked up on it) and the vote following Hal is just, bizarre. Really needed to provide reasoning there one way or the other.
God damn are there really two players in this game who you can't make a passing comment on without them interpreting it as "I literally redchecked this player and will tunnel them until I die. Who needs gladiator when you've got narrow-mindedness"
Votecount v1.1.2
M24 [3] - Celever, skippergamez, realiti
master oden [2] - master oden
apricity [1] - Psypsypsypsypsythe
Lady Salamence [1] - JALMONT
JALMONT [1] - AG
Duskfall98 [1] - apricity
Ties broken by sneeze speed.
M24 [3] - Celever, skippergamez, realiti
master oden [2] - master oden
apricity [1] - Psypsypsypsypsythe
Lady Salamence [1] - JALMONT
JALMONT [1] - AG
Duskfall98 [1] - apricity
Ties broken by sneeze speed.
Last edited:
TBF I was also tired when I made that readslist and I don't agree with some of the ordering. Eli -> bottom of town leans bc the more I think about it the more I hate that he pushed me for mostly providing commentary (self-awarely, I was doing rands dev lol) while his own contrib is also predominantly commentary. If I'd thought about it more back then I prob woulda put him down bottom from the start lol.
Besides that not really besides Hal prob just moving to idk tier. I still think that "I will gladiate the newbie over a debunked level-1 scumslip" bluff was really dumb, though, and rather anti-town. M24 hasn't rlly raised their stocks for me that much but it can go to scumlean lol it was only a tier below bc of lack of content making the 3 AI posts more significant.
Don't forget master oden has 2 votes! The twins are fighting
Votecount reminded me realiti is in the game LMAO. Their entrance was theoretically fine they can be a minor townlean
AG minor scumlean for the AI posting they've done since, does feel somewhat contrived and like he's just trying to throw anything into a threadstate he doesn't care to understand much. Which is like, valid bc that's his own analysis of his POV rn but he also has no real issue drawing quick conclusions from searches when prompted. Which feels a little like he knows more than is letting on yk
Oh right, you're on hal I think from early D1
your reads are fine except M24 scumread for progression is kinda wild, what were they meant to progress on when RVS just ended
I mean they literally only made non-sequiturs hours apart (which is the negative progression thing), when their posts were irrelevant to threadstate, and jumped on the horrendous skipper push by Hal.
Like they've later said they didn't do it because of Hal's push but that's a little difficult to believe considering they didn't pressure skipper at all they legit just dropped a vote and dipped. They at least did it to double Hal's pressure which, the case was so bad that's never gonna actually work out yk it just feels like an easy fake content opportunity.
I guess we don't agree with what progression but your logic makes more sense like that
one day i'll post an accurate vote count.
will it be this game?
Psypsypsypsypsythe Are u entertaining a degree of caution over my slot or do you think you’ve just got a handle on how I play? Cos I feel like in the past you’ve never arrived to a tr on me so quickly so it helps to know why you’re thinking this atm.
Celever link ur most recent scumgame if you have one in the last year please (if you don’t id appreciate still having one but probably not gonna read into it as much)
apricity genuinely pls show ur work on oden (this can wait until I get back tho, I just don’t have a read atm)
Celever link ur most recent scumgame if you have one in the last year please (if you don’t id appreciate still having one but probably not gonna read into it as much)
apricity genuinely pls show ur work on oden (this can wait until I get back tho, I just don’t have a read atm)
I'm p sure my last scumgame you hosted, where my buddy was SB lol
Lame cos I knew that, just wanted to know if there was something more recent