NOC Smogon Rewind Night 3

[apricity]

Why does caff and thunder have to be the same alignment*

 

[apricity]

There is literally no corroboration of tbz being a jail keeper.

 

[Panic Station]

Okay. What do you think scum!Thunder could have been doing to a guy the scum decided to kill, then?

 

[Thunder~BALLZ]

i claimed out of being annoyed at whoever redirected me, some people are reading way too deep into it and some people arent reading at all. pretty simple if you ask me

 

[Panic Station]

There's not much I can think of there that wouldn't be pointless and/or counterproductive.

 

[Thunder~BALLZ]

might as well claim this now even though people will probably scum read me for it anyway lul. my jailkeep doubles as a neighborize, tonight i should be able to talk to jordan

 

[Former]

Well, ty hal for letting us know there are only 3 mafia left.

 

[Former]

And those are probably

M2H/Hal and probably Vigvig

Although when it comes to vigvig I'm a little less certain. Both M2H and hal have done things to defend them, but they are also both the kind of player to fake defend someone to set them up for a lynch

 

[Thunder~BALLZ]

my role got hotfixed cause neighborize used to be same night so i could use day talk with someone too i guess? maybe tommy thought it was too busted. either way u guys are being so dumb about everything rofl

 

[Thunder~BALLZ]

now im out bc this day is gonna end being more baseless bashing, hf!

 

[Panic Station]

Hal, the least you could do right now is say whether or not you care about using logic in a mafia game.

 

[apricity]

Okay. What do you think scum!Thunder could have been doing to a guy the scum decided to kill, then?

???? We don’t know thunder actually targeted Eli???????????

Knights I need you to just try to answer the simpler questions yourself ok?

 

[Panic Station]

That's a possibility. It's not a possibility I like, becuase it doesn't do much for solving the game. But it's a possibility.

 

[Former]

Eh, I believe it. There's a very strong possibility that M2H's mafia kill is strongman so it makes sense for town to have two protective roles.

 

[apricity]

I don’t think I would lynch tbz before former in any world and I think there’s a lot of thinking to be done as to whether former would suggest that tbz is scum immediately after the JK claim.

ah why am I still in thread

 

[apricity]

Talking to scum and scumsiding idiot

 

[Former]

Let me translate hal's post here
"I refuse to make any reads besides on Former, so when he flips town and 'proves me wrong' I can go back and say "haha, oh well" without actually being tied to any reads"

 

[Panic Station]

strongman disregards protectives though right?

 

[Panic Station]

Also, not talking to everyone regardless of alignment is bad form. You gotta get statements from everyone to make your reads.

 

[apricity]

Also, not talking to everyone regardless of alignment is bad form. You gotta get statements from everyone to make your reads.

I feel a strong need to follow your recommendations on how to make reads because of your accuracy and consistent, reasonable methodology in doing so

 

[Former]

strongman disregards protectives though right?

Yeah, it ignores them

 

[realiti]

M2H is here! please claim

 

[M2H]

one shot watcher.

moody didn't use yet.

 

[apricity]

Lynch

 

[Whydon]

guess he didn’t take the time to check the full results?