reqs
Crystal isn't the only one who can get reqs using exclusively his webs team. I'd like to say ggs ez, but the 24 other alts prove it wasn't :)
I would like to start off by saying that while there are valid arguments presented by the pro-ban faction, those arguments are imo not enough to ban Machoke. Despite some of them seeming flawed to me, I think it is important to mention that I take no issue with people voting ban after they have thought it over. Regardless, here is my reasoning for dnb: (boiled down, since I don't have days to write this)
First off, it should be said that the scary set here is Flame Orb. The other Machokes both check things like Klang and Piloswine and get walled by Gloom, Corsola, Dartrix, Mudbray (and the Fairies if Resttalk). A frequently brought up point is that Forb Machoke has no hard counters (unless no Facade, in which case Koffing walls it) like Bronzor for Pilo or Chinchou, Wooper and Palpitoad for Klang. This is, however, not as big a problem as some people make it out to be. These are some pro ban arguments I have seen a lot:
'Its checks can't come in more than once.': A lot of checks like Dartrix, Gloom or Corsola can heal on the switch allowing them to be used again. Even if your opponent has a Hattrem, the switch into Strength Sap is predictable and can be exploited.
'Its bulk allows it to survive revengekillers': While its bulk isn't horrendous and looks good on paper, it's not enough in practice. It has no eviolite, takes chip damage from the burn every turn, and CC drops its defenses. Btw that doesn't always mean a ko, since baiting out a CC is definitely possible.
'Its not even that slow for this meta': In NFE, there is basically a fast group (Torracat and above), then a huge gap with little viable mons and then the slow group. Machoke is relatively high up in the 'slow' group, but a simple scroll through the teambuilder can show you that a lot of viable 'slow' mons are still faster than Machoke. (granted, they don't always run max speed, but neither does Machoke) When I personally used max hp max atk Forb Machoke on my balance team on my earlier nfema alts, it was without a doubt the worst performing member. It wasn't until I changed it to Jolly max speed that it worked on par with the rest of the team.
'You have to sack something every time Machoke comes in if your check(s) aren't at full health': With proper predictions you can sometimes avoid this, and even if this is absolutely inevitable, this is not a situation unique to Machoke. It's relatively common to be stuck in a situation where you have to sack a mon. Other mons like Pikachu, Piloswine and setup sweepers can force you to do the same.
Another returning argument is that Machoke promotes "unhealthy predictions". Predictions are definitely important when dealing with Machoke, but I fail to see how these are unhealthy. The more skilled player has a better chance of getting the right prediction. Imagine Linoone vs Machoke (as a common but not all-representing example). The Machoke usally clicks Knock on the 'obvious' switchin, but lets say Linoone stays in and D-edge's. Machoke is now a 2hko. (this is eviolite btw, Forb is 2hko and would have to switch out) Now the costs are higher and the Machoke player is more inclined to click CC. But now the Linoone clicks P-shot and goes into Gloom to catch the CC. Machoke now has -1 in everything but speed, unable to touch Gloom. This is ofc a pretty optimistic situation, but when I personally used Machoke, I found myself getting screwed over with these kinds of predictions more than my opponent.
What I also noticed a lot when discussing Machoke checks is: "It clicks Knock on the switch and kills it next turn". For this to actually happen, the mon in question needs to be slower than Machoke, it needs to be 2hko'd (granted, this criterium is very easy to fulfill), and it also actually needs to switch in. Or it could, but the Machoke player under- or overpredicts and clicks CC or even something else. A lot of people will say that these "50-50's" are unhealthy, and while I already discussed the unhealthy part, these predictions, although sometimes having too much at stake, are poorly named. the chances of Machoke clicking Knock or CC (or even something else) depends on the players and the situation.
Something that was heavily debated in chat was the upcoming DLC. There were a lot of vastly different opinions flying about, all with reasons backing them up. A post I made a while back mentioned the DLC and how we shouldn't ban or suspect stuff right before it drops. Three days later, the suspect was announced lol. Some people stated that voting for a meta that doesn't exist yet is a bad idea, which makes sense. Then again, some people stated that it's ridiculous to vote for a meta that's dead in two days, while the meta the potential ban actually affects is a meta which Machoke has never set foot in and this also makes sense.
If you're feeling Gloomy right now, read these on-point remarks by one of the best and rudest nfe players:
facts
ArcticBreezeX: but if u vote ban or no ban bc of the current meta
ArcticBreezeX: then ur voting for the next meta
ArcticBreezeX: so ur opinion is also bad
ArcticBreezeX: either way everyones opinions suck
reality tbh
ArcticBreezeX: just push it back
%Ho3nConfirm3d: so like a day of voting, maybe one day of implementation on PS, then DLC
ArcticBreezeX: and quickban mons before they can even be added
not a hot take
%Ho3nConfirm3d: hindsight 20/20, learning experience if anything
ArcticBreezeX: wow ho3n so inspirational
ArcticBreezeX: really help
ArcticBreezeX: i think the best idea is to cancel the pokemon company for removing pokemon
These made me laugh a lot more than they should have btw.
Also, if you're not convinced yet, this is by far the best argument to not ban Machoke
best argument
broken phobias: i leik big muscles pokeman because it is purple
I kid, of course :)
I would also have liked to reply to a lot of the things said in the thread since some of them kinda triggered me (seriously, asking for a Raboot ban?) and added more details to this post but it's 2am and I'm tired. Massive shoutouts to everyone trying to save Machoke or at least considering it, as well as Crystal (even though he's kind of on the dark side of the force) and Thimo for making that great Lampent team.