fickle beam seems so fair and balanced
fickle beam seems so fair and balanced
Id put aqua ring instead of steam eruption cause water sguriken hits alreDy like a bomb and u dont outspeed anything To want To make Even more damages.
Araquanid (M) @ Loaded Dice
Ability: Water Bubble
Shiny: Yes
Tera Type: Water
EVs: 248 HP / 252 SpA / 8 SpD
Modest Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Tail Glow
- Water Shuriken
- Bug Buzz
- Steam Eruption
Step 1: Tail Glow
Step 2: Profit
252+ Atk Araquanid First Impression vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Ogerpon-Wellspring: 252-296 (83.7 - 98.3%) -- 75% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
Araquanid? What's that?
the last two are just fillers mostly, all u need is just tail glow+shurikenId put aqua ring instead of steam eruption cause water sguriken hits alreDy like a bomb and u dont outspeed anything To want To make Even more damages.
Giagantic: Interesting slate ahead if you are all okay with it, I've discussed it before but I want to go over old bans of certain moves to ensure they are broken or not. These moves are things that predate many of our times on the council and were legacy bans basically from last gen (regarding Wicked Blow) or were part of another now banned Pokemons potential kit (Clangorous Soul + Roaring Moon) .
One important thing to note, I believe the right direction for STABmons is to ban Pokemon before moves, it is a move based meta which should mean that moves have a much higher threshold to meet in regards to being banned. Only moves that are explicitly broken beyond any hope such as Shed Tail should realistically be banned or those that are simply uncompetitive (Dire Claw, Acupressure, etc...).
First move is Wicked Blow, unbanning it will definitely get Kingambit banned, potentially Weavile but both of these mons are already borderline in their own way, only held back by various attributes such as Weavile's frailty and rock weakness and Kingambits slowness and reliance on priority. I think we should unban it as aside from these potential two collateral Pokemon it'd not effect the meta much since it now has the same BP as Flower Trick and some Dark's would appreciate access to it. Also, the meta is not lacking for pokemon, losing a few outliers is not a good enough reason to keep it banned IMO.
Next would be reviewing old bans/restrictions that I find some questionably fine, namely, Triple Arrows, Clangorous Soul, and Gigaton Hammer.
Triple Arrows I pushed and voted ban because it had characteristics that were uncompetitive with high Flinch and Def drop + unblockable higher crit chance which made defensive counterplay iffy. I want to be sure everyone is on board with it's ban / unban.
[12:38 PM]Giagantic: Clangorous Soul is in many regards inferior to Dragon Dance, the damage you take using it effectively means it is net neutral gains compared to DD, potentially net negative. Course this is only true for those that lack recovery, for those with access to healing it is a potent weapon which would include Gouging Fire and Salamence but aside from these two it is simply another option neither entirely better or worse then DD. (edited)
[12:40 PM]Giagantic: Finally Gigaton Hammer's primary claim to fame is Kingambit, outside of this it was always questionable whether it'd be all that good, and Kingambit has barely dropped at all in terms viability since then and if it is getting banned with the release of Wicked Blow then I don't see why we should keep it banned. We can access this later if we have too.
2. The Meta
As the #1 pex hater, I can say pex is fine rn. So many things can bully pex that I honestly don't care about standing on my soapbox to advocate for a pex ban that I always preach for every gen. This is one of the most offensive and cheese-able STAB metas imo. Every water type is a problem. Surging strikes being practically a bp of 113, water shuriken being 60-75 bp priority with dice, Jet punch being Aqua jet if Sam Sulek used it, and even the occasional aqua step to help sweep even better. S to A- on the VR is 24 mons with Water being 8 of them...1/3 of the top 24 is one type. The next common type is dark at 5...and 2 of those 5 are also water types. At some point we gotta ask ourselves, do we ban all the broken water moves or all the broken water types. Priority as a whole is broken. All of the good mons in the meta also get a good priority move (weird huh). Gambit is broken because of its dual priority in sucker (which it naturally gets) and bp (which it doesn't naturally get). I've already talked about the broken water prio so we can keep going. Rillaboom I am okay with. We have a good amount of grass answers and it just comes down to terrain teams being annoying, but objectively fine in the meta. I guess thunderclap is a thing, but having a prio move lose to like dragons and grounds in a dragon and ground heavy meta kinda sucks, but hey it is nice to have. Everything seems to setup. Kingambit, Great Tusk, Iron Moth (yes I count torch as setup), Iron Valiant, Gholdengo, Greninja, Urshifu-Rapid strike, Volcanion (torch again), Volcarona, Ogerpon-Wellspring, Gyarados, Heatran (whoa is that a torch mon again), Meloetta, Rotom-Wash, Sneasler, Crawdaunt, Blaziken, Deoxys-Speed, Gouging Fire, Kyurem, Araquanid...just to name a few. But everything meta relevant is a setup mon. If the HO one-trick guy is complaining about HO, you know something has got to change. Also to single out Meloetta, this thing can do too many things. It can be specs, it can be scarf, it can set up, it can be defensive, it can be offensive. Boomburst is 140 bp and this thing has base 128 sp.attack. It has decent bulk and its speed tier is good enough.
3. Tera
I don't care what y'all do since I no longer have any skin in the game, but tera has got to go. Having most games come down to "God I hope I have the right tera to not get swept by my opponent" or "God I hope I have the right tera to sweep my opponent" is not a good feeling for anyone.
4. WWFD (What Would Fissure Do)
Surging strikes ban, Jet Punch ban, Torch song ban, Volcanion ban, Kingambit ban, Meloetta ban, tera ban.
I must sleep. Goodbye till next time~
View attachment 585834
Echoing thoughts with Fissure here past a Tera ban since I believe that's because of the broken moves and not because of the mechanic. A LOT of the issues I've had with STAB this gen are still present in DLC2, with the most egregious being Loaded Dice Water Shuriken, Jet Punch, Meloetta, and Volcanion. If Wicked Blow wasn't unbanned then I'd argue Kingambit is like mostly fine? But now you literally need Great Tusk to not autolose to it. Water Shuriken alone has led to bans like Manaphy and the otherwise godawful Araquanid (seriously this was never really good until this gen, i wonder why?), and Jet Punch is really stupid on a ton of Pokemon like Urshifu-RS, Ogerpon-W, Poliwrath (yes that thing), and a stupid number more, with only really Tera to consistently answer? It doesn't help that offensive Tera compounds this issue, but removing Tera wouldn't help in the slightest since you really need something like Beak Blast or a specific check to somewhat handle these anyway. I somewhat agree with Giagantic's stance of banning moves only when they're egregious, but surely with all the proof of how stupid TSong/WShuriken/JPunch is I'd hope that some action is taken on them.It's TIME TO RUMBLE the meta a bit more... The council brings a few changes for the New Year!
First off,
Is banned from STABmons
One important thing to note, I believe the right direction for STABmons is to ban Pokemon before moves, it is a move based meta which should mean that moves have a much higher threshold to meet in regards to being banned. Only moves that are explicitly broken beyond any hope such as Shed Tail should realistically be banned or those that are simply uncompetitive (Dire Claw, Acupressure, etc...).
Echoing thoughts with Fissure here past a Tera ban since I believe that's because of the broken moves and not because of the mechanic. A LOT of the issues I've had with STAB this gen are still present in DLC2, with the most egregious being Loaded Dice Water Shuriken, Jet Punch, Meloetta, and Volcanion. If Wicked Blow wasn't unbanned then I'd argue Kingambit is like mostly fine? But now you literally need Great Tusk to not autolose to it. Water Shuriken alone has led to bans like Manaphy and the otherwise godawful Araquanid (seriously this was never really good until this gen, i wonder why?), and Jet Punch is really stupid on a ton of Pokemon like Urshifu-RS, Ogerpon-W, Poliwrath (yes that thing), and a stupid number more, with only really Tera to consistently answer? It doesn't help that offensive Tera compounds this issue, but removing Tera wouldn't help in the slightest since you really need something like Beak Blast or a specific check to somewhat handle these anyway. I somewhat agree with Giagantic's stance of banning moves only when they're egregious, but surely with all the proof of how stupid TSong/WShuriken/JPunch is I'd hope that some action is taken on them.
As for Meloetta and Volcanion, my issues stem with just how well they abuse the broken moves, though Meloetta comes mostly from just how limited our special walls are so I wouldn't immediately ban it along with the three broken moves. Volcanion would also become a lot worse without Torch Song or Water Shuriken and so would be generally more bearable. It was really clear just how crazy Volcanion was in DLC1 (I even started running Toxic to catch it off-guard on the switch), and DLC2 hasn't really changed much so far on the special side at all. As for the other Torch Song users (moths, Heatran, Rotom-H/W sometimes but not anymore hopefully), they're only really any problem with Torch Song because its so easy to get going with it past Volcarona because funny moth.
Overall, ban Jet Punch, Water Shuriken, Torch Song, Kingambit, and maybe Weavile, give meta time to settle before nuking Meloetta if it's still stupid.