• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

[Standard] NOC Desktop Dungeons Mafia GAME OVER

I think our next logical lynch is Da Letter El. A few days ago I "buddied" him, thinking that he was wrongfully being accused. However, remember UncleSam had pretty strong suspicions against him and it seems DLE also wants me dead but obligatorily forgot this concept called reasoning which is usually nice to put in your argument.

I also think J-Man is a good lynch, as UncleSam said that if J-man was mafia so was polelover. I know we're doing that in reverse, but the mafia gave us pretty good signs that UncleSam was right in his suspicions. We tried it with polelover and it worked.
 
By post I meant defend yourself. I know full well you need absolutely no prodding to start posting.
Yeti said:
inspector has the choice of inspecting hga or hfa or hsa whatever his name is lol tonight and ccing tomorrow or ccing today.

whoever hits majority is likely mafia. we should allow any inspector to look at the situation and decide whether they want to speak up. if not, guess we have to trust hsa and hope he's telling the truth ! i still find him suspicious claiming and throwing a guy also under suspicion under the bus when he was voted but we'll see.
Click to expand...
I've already shown that this post was extremely poor. Yes HSA claiming was suspicious given the timing, but this post seems, to me at least, to be undermining HSA rather than stalling for others to claim.

Yeti said:
ok so now the question is:

do we believe there is an every-night alliance checker in this game?
i would fully believe it in a normal game but in a noc where the statement is there are minimal/limited power roles?
if there is an inspector, i sincerely doubt hsa's claim, however, if no inspector claims i can see us having solely an alliance checker.

ac is a lot easier to fake than a role where you actually require information ;x
Click to expand...
Questioning the existence of an every-night alliance checker... in a mafia game? This again seems to be trying to undermine HSA at a time when we weren't exactly sure we were going to follow his advice. You also seem to claim that alliance checker is too powerful for a game with limited power roles, yet too weak a claim because it doesn't require much info. Get your story straight lol.

The posts since then have been rather devoid of content. I don't think there's much point bringing them up.
 
i had assumed we would have an every-night inspector as opposed to an alliance checker, however it may be the preference of our host to have an alliance checker. considering what is revealed upon death, in retrospect it wasn't unlikely our scum-finding role was alliance and not alliance/role/name.

my statement was alliance checker AND inspector were too powerful to be in the same game if AC was both nights, however AC is the easier one to fake because you simply need to take a stab at the alliance as opposed to providing an accurate night action or role.

again, i had assumed there was an inspector itg, i found it suspicious when HSA began clarifying he was an alliance checker when, to me, he had presented himself as an inspector. having seen no CC and HSA's result being accurate, i now think it to be the case we have a sheriff, which does make more sense for how AW set this game up.

considering there were conflicting demands for another inspector to CC or stay silent, and HSA's timing, i was seeking a CC should there be one. as i said, it would be rather easy to false claim sheriff in a NOC game, moreso than inspector. with no CC, i believe HSA's claim.
 
Yeti's logic was flawed, I can't deny that, but I don't really see why her over people such as Rick or Fangren. Convince me why not to vote someone who has less posts here than the hosts and I will vote.
 
i did think them through... to the point where i overthought and felt it was somehow necessary for an inspector to inspect HSA to verify if he was clean or not
obviously if there had been another inspector/sheriff they would've known he wasn't clean but i guess i was thinking a fluodome situation where a villager claims hooker/inspector to distract the mafia.

in any case since there has been no CC i was inclined to trust hsa in the end, a profitable venture at best.
 
24 hours without a post? What happened to this game?

Yes Billy she would be more competent, and I agree on Rick, but Fangren I'd have a bit higher expectations for. Could just me having higher expectations, could me being right that they're more competent.

Either way, temporary Vote: Yeti for now. Bit of pressure never hurt anyone, and we need a lynch.
 
Vote: Spiffy

I don't know about everyone else, but for some reason, I feel like Spiffy has been trying to use the vigilante claim as cover. There has been one death every night so far, and Spiffy has been "hooked" every night. Please tell us who you tried to kill tonight and I will remove my vote. That is all I want to know (which is why I will put on a little bit of pressure).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top