I think we need Toothache to randomly vote, because unlike Gormenghast, he always gets it right...
If we're going to vote off someone randomly, it should be Kira. Disclaimer: not good reasons for a lynch!
1) He had the longest lifetime of everyone in HP II, so on average he can't really complain about dying early
2) He's shown what he can do if he's left alive for too long last time, and his behavior is pretty much the same
3) No offense, but while he may have been doing great last game, he still does not seem very contributive to the total intelligence of the game, though I may be biased due to him not seeing the Rebels are actually good.
Another option would be to lynch someone who is way too quiet. Of course, this nets you a good chance of anything not a pillager (so both special roles and mafia), but even if that person is good, you lynch someone who would slow the game down by not being around.
Most of this logic is better applicable later in the game though, when we know who has been consistently quiet.
Not voting, just wondering what you think.