In a post-kyurem meta, I really wouldn't support any more bans apart from tera blast. However, there are still some mons that have suffered the cruel and unjustified outrage of the masses for nearly two years at this point...
These innocent souls should be out of the question for a suspect:
- It's 2024. Gambit is not broken, people. The meta has adapted so hard to this mon, it's unreal. Encore and roar on every team? Zama on every team? Lando on every team? Cheap moltres? Tusk, which is still on a million teams since it's the only removal? Skarm? Dozo, which can absolute worst case still emergency tera fight vs tera dark black glasses 5 fallen gambit? And no, mental herb gambit will not exist, and even if it does, it's terrible.
- This mon is completely fine. I think we’ve figured out that ghold isn’t the main culprit behind the hazard meta, it’s just that we have literally 0 good removal options + the setters are insane (1200 bst moose, scorpion that never dies, and the stupid otter u lead and click one move with). Offensively, we’ve always known it doesn’t have too much immediate power and has a pretty bad speed tier. But nowadays, it can often be a liability when getting a kill with this mon enables ur opponent to bring in shit like moon and moth and set up for free (unless ur cheap twave, but this set is pretty inoffensive anyway). Defensively, this mon is fine to check even for fat unless it runs a fishy set like psyshock which is generally terrible into the rest of the metagame. Don’t think there’s much to elaborate on, it’s probably in the bottom half of mons I don’t like on team preview.
- It's not even that it can make teambuilding a breeze by providing speed control, checking almost every physical attacker in the tier, and possibly being the best dark resist in ou history. We don't have to make this argument that borders on 'broken checks broken' because it's straight up not broken, and has way too much counterplay to be anywhere near banworthy.
We can pretty much disregard balance or anything fatter because Zama isn't really doing much into those since they usually bring around 3+ mons that together beat every zama set there is. If something like boots or band zama (which is bad imo) breaks your balance or fat team, you got outplayed and deserve to lose, end of story.
Anyway, zama is a mon that offense *should* be dedicating either tera or more than one mon to beat, since it's a mon entirely dedicated to the offense matchup. It would be quite bad if it usually just traded 1v1 in the matchup it actually does something in, no? Offense still has a ton of counterplay available, such as booster moth (which is mandatory on HO imo), encore val, encore dnite, prim (1v1s), BU poison tusk (1v1s if no roar or last mon), deo speed, enam (if no slam), or even okidogi. Or, you could just slap tera ghost on a mon that could feasibly beat zama given a body press immunity.
It doesn't matter if these mons don't consistently beat it 1v1 or throughout a game, as beating zama *should* be a team effort for offense teams. This team effort isn't unreasonably constraining either, as once the dog goes down, all your physical threats are enabled.
Even then, offense is flexible enough such that it can fit mons like cm sinistcha and bold ghold, which severely limit zama all by themselves. A ban may be the biggest L in the history of this tier, which unfortunately isn't out of the question since this mon absolutely stomps low-mid ladder and players in that area are prob able to get reqs if they try.
On value based arguments
I could have made value based arguments for all 3 of these mons, since all 3 are essential to balancing the current metagame, but I didn’t. In general, value based arguments should be discarded in both directions. If your argument revolves around ‘but what value does it bring to the tier,’ you’re pretty much just using a reversed version of the broken checks broken argument. If value should not be a reason to keep a mon in, then it should not be a reason to keep a mon out either. And what even is value? Anything that makes it easier for u to use ur favourite team?