Hlelo, RU Council has voted on a few things following today's tier shift. This time, Mienshao, Moltres-Galar, Politoed and Regidrago were voted on. Here are the results:
Mienshao:
8 ban votes (Beraldo, cyanize, eifo, EviGaro, Feliburn, Floss, GoldCat, TheFranklin),
1 no ban vote (Wally*)
Moltres-Galar:
4 ban votes (Beraldo, eifo, Floss, TheFranklin),
5 no ban votes (cyanize, EviGaro, Feliburn, GoldCat, Wally)
Politoed:
7 ban votes (Beraldo, cyanize, eifo, EviGaro, Feliburn, Floss, TheFranklin),
2 no ban votes (GoldCat, Wally)
Regidrago:
7 ban votes (Beraldo, cyanize, eifo, Feliburn, Floss, GoldCat, TheFranklin),
2 no ban votes (EviGaro, Wally)
*Wally is yourwelcomethanku I just did not want to write that four times
As the ban threshold was 6/9,
Mienshao, Politoed and Regidrago are now banned from SV RU! Tagging
Kris and
Marty to implement on ladder, thank you. Some reasonings:
- Mienshao was a very contentious presence last gen, being banned from NU, then RU, and finally UU. It retured to SV with a very similar toolkit, being an extremely powerful presence due to an incredible stab, access to Knock Off and U-turn, alongside a top tier ability in Regenerator. This effectively makes Mienshao unique as it's one of the few offensive powerhouses that can very easily outlast checks, even if foregoing boots like a lot of its competition likes to have. Barely anything changed in SV, bar a weaker tier than it left in SWSH RU, but it did get access to trailblaze, which is somewhat significant as Mienshao already has flexibility in the last moveslot, and could also make SD sets a more threatening presence. The Council essentially saw its toolbox as way too much for the tier as it is and thus it's gone for now.
- Politoed hasn't been a very good mon in a while, being way inferior to Pelipper, but RU really lacks options to handle automatic rain as it is right now. We already have one breaker in Basculegion-M that is fearsome in OU, but is slightly held back here, and other options like Kilowattrel, Overqwil, Ludicolo (that we also just got) and Drednaw just get way better with Politoed support. We did not act on damp rock as rain was fine without an autosetter, but there is certainly a worry that this drop would be too much, and so Politoed was banned.
- Regidrago had no coverage. but this was also changed in SV. If it was only tera, it would probably be fine, but it can also hit steels with Earthquake and Earth Power now, both boosting choiced sets and DD sets, which made it a worry for the Council. PERSONALLY since I voted no ban (and was the one tasked to write this as the Council is currently debating on the pronunciation of Mienshao) I would say that ground coverage, particularly without a stab, isn't really cutting it for me. I found it very tera dependent to not be pants vs fairies, especially since we got a really really really good one in this shift, plus tera fairy being super good in general. Its speed tier and defensive utility are also very lackluster. But I was outvoted SOOOO it's banned.
- On the no ban, we only have Moltres-Galar. I think everyone recognizes this thing has absurd cheese potential, and it's not hard to see why. Double boosting sets are fearsome, and Moltres has great natural bulk paired with an elite typing to allow it setup. However, and this is where the Council ultimately decided on for now, it has a fairly significant movepool issue. Dark / Flying, while incredible overall, has big limitations in the tier, particularly when it comes to hitting fairies - especially the tier defining Diancie - or other top threats like Bisharp. Which then puts Moltres in a bit of a conundrum: does it use its tera defensively, making its setup easier, or does it use tera blast in order to hit those roadblocks? Unfortunately there is no real answer yet, and tera blast needs different typings to hit what it wants, so for now it's staying in the tier. As people build around it and find a way to make it work, it could certainly become a cause of concern, so we are not rejecting a revisit quite yet.