Actually, Stillman AND Commodore have both played for my hometown team, the Flames.
Stillman is a jerk. With the right support though, he'll burn alot of teams. He's worth it for a cup run on a cheap trade.
Commodore...well he played for the flames during their cup run that year. I hated him, despite loving the flames, cause he was ungainly and awkward. I think he got into the NHL cause of his size, to be honest, since defensemen are loved for three things:
1. Size. Chara is a good example of WHY this is selected for. His poke check ALONE can get a person into all stars. Also look at him fight and hit.
2. Shot power. Al McInnis made a CAREER of his shot. So did Souray. If you can blast it from the point, you might have a powerplay place.
3. Ability to hit. Coincidentally, Regehr can't skate or shoot...but man does he hit. I bet we can all name someone who can do that on just about any team.
What does commodore do? Aside from the novelty of the giant ginger afro outside his helmet.
Also, Teifu: Ottawa isn't just pushing for the win this year. Lets look back over the last few years. They actually do deserve a cup and they are trying to reward their fans with one. I mean look at the talent they developed and you'll see why: Alfredsson, Havlat, Hossa, Spezza, Emery (okay, his earring is talent but that's enough right?), Phillips...etc etc etc. Look how well they've been managed too!!!
Ottawa has had a very solid talent pool, much like Detroit or Colorado, for the last few years. They are amazing at scouting and developing, which builds long term character and talent. However, I do agree; they are running for the cup. Again, another however, I was certain the Heatley deal was a cup run too. They kept him. Detroit has done that with several players many times...and they are what place in the league a few years after?
In conclusion, I prefer the trade for Ottawa. When you are going for the cup (and apparently trying to go for broke) a 4th year in a row (or so), you really need to do what you can. They have been slumping lately, since even Montreal's best season in a while is almost up to par with them, and they need to score. Ottawa has never been a 'defense' team, not since Lalime. They have been a 'score as much as you can, as fast as you can and don't stop for any reason' team and just HOPE you end up with more. Also, Stillman has something in him. That guy has a shot I haven't seen since Iginla, he just needs someone to pass...and Staal can only shoot. :D